Ted Bundy, according to Newton (2002), was the “perfect” serial killer. Bundy was
attractive, charming, intelligent, and seen largely as an “average white male citizen.” Indeed, Bundy’s role in politics and law emphasized his normalcy. Additionally, Bundy utilized subtle tactics to become more relatable to the public. More specifically, for example, Ted Bundy once appeared in court in a Seattle Mariners T-shirt. Bundy’s attempt at normalcy was nothing short of successful. In fact, when Bundy was put on trial, “The newspapers were full of statements from Ted’s friends, outraged that this all-American boy was accused of these heinous crimes” (Rule, 2012, p. 114).
Bundy also portrayed himself as an exceptionally sociable and even gracious human being. For instance, he volunteered for a rape-crisis hotline and received an honorable mention for catching a purse-snatcher (Schmid, 2006, p. 212). The young law student was respected and adored by those around him. Ann Rule recalled her positive experience working with Bundy at the Seattle Crisis Clinic, “I can hear… the infinite patience and caring in his voice… He was never brusque, never hurried” (Rule, 2012, p. 25). According to Katherine Ramsland (2013), “A campaign co-worker thought of him as ‘Kennedy-like,’ while a Mormon missionary who baptized Bundy in 1975 said, ‘I wouldn’t hesitate to line [Ted] up with my sister’” (p. 20). Indeed, Bundy’s normalcy was heavily emphasized and vouched for, making his guilt all the more terrifying.
In her 1981 book The Phantom Prince, Liz Kendall (her pseudonym) recounts her long romantic relationship with Bundy; during a time in
which she found herself becoming suspicious of Bundy, Kendall recounted how she “watched his every move, but what I saw was Ted playing games with [my daughter], carrying my niece on his shoulders, helping my mom in the kitchen…Hardly the actions of a madman” (Kendall, 1981, p. 85). Indeed, Bundy was incredibly chameleon-like, able to easily blend and mesh with those around him, but many wonder: Who was the real Ted Bundy? Eerily, according to Seltzer (2003), “It was observed again and again that ‘he never looked the same from photograph to photograph’” (p. 11).
In order to fully understand Ted Bundy and the public’s fascination regarding the killer he became, it is critical to start at the very beginning. According to Kevin Sullivan, author of The Bundy Murders: A Comprehensive History, Theodore Robert Cowell, primarily known as Ted Bundy, was born on November 24th, 1946 to Louise Cowell and a man rumored to be a sailor named Jack Worthington (Sullivan, 2009, p. 47). Worthington, however, had no desire to be a father and left Cowell to have and raise the child on her own. Consequently, Cowell gave birth to a healthy baby boy at the Elizabeth Lund Home for Unwed Mothers (Sullivan, 2009, p. 27). Shortly after, Cowell returned to Philadelphia to her family, who welcomed the child with open arms.
According to Sullivan (2009), experts would later wonder how Bundy became such a notorious man and they turned to his childhood for answers. Many have a preconceived notion that serial killers likely experienced abuse or trauma during their childhood. Indeed, according to researchers Heather Mitchell and Michael G. Aamodt (2005), “Childhood abuse has been given varying levels of blame in the development of serial killers” (p. 40). The two conducted a study on the incidence of child abuse in serial killers. In a sample of 50 serial killers, they found that 68% experienced some type of maltreatment; more specifically, 50% reported psychological abuse, 36% physical abuse, 26% sexual abuse, and 18% neglect.
Although Bundy’s childhood was not one filled with any sort of trauma, there were aspects of his youth that were certainly bizarre and thus often debated. For instance, for a period of time, according to Sullivan (2009), Bundy believed that his grandparents were his parents and that his mother was his sister. This widely-believed claim that is often seen in clickbait articles, however, has been disputed by authors Stephen G. Michaud and Hugh Aynesworth; in their 1999 book The Only Living Witness, the two argued that although “A story attributed to an adult Ted Bundy had it that [Cowell] posed as his older sister, not his mother…This is not so; he always knew her as his mother” (p. 59). In addition, it was rumored that his grandfather was incredibly violent; there was speculation that Bundy’s grandfather was abusive to animals, had a large selection of pornography, and talked to himself (Sullivan, 2009). Michaud and Aynesworth (1999), however, note that Bundy’s grandfather “doted upon him,” and that Bundy was incredibly upset when he and his mother left his grandfather to travel to Tacoma, Washington. Despite the rumors surrounding his grandfather, Bundy regarded him as a “highly educated and loving grandfather” (Sullivan, 2009, p. 47).
Perhaps these unusual factors played a role in Bundy’s odd behavior as a child. One of his aunts, for example, recalled a time that she woke up in bed only to find the three-year-old placing knives under her covers and around her body (Sullivan, 2009). According to Polly Nelson, author of Defending the Devil: My Story as Ted Bundy’s Last Lawyer, “Ted had episodes where he would seem to turn into another, unrecognizable person. A great-aunt who had witnessed one such episode suddenly, inexplicably, found herself afraid of her favorite nephew…” (Sullivan, 2009, p. 48). These anecdotes, while once perhaps strange or peculiar, are now incredibly eerie knowing who Bundy would later become.
In 1951, Cowell met John Bundy; the two fell in love and quickly married. John Bundy, known widely as Johnnie, adopted Cowell’s son and had his name legally changed. Bundy’s relationship with his stepfather seemed to be strained. According to Terry Storwick, a childhood friend of Ted Bundy’s, the two would argue often. Storwick recalled Johnnie resorting to violence; Storwick recounted, “this reaction was Johnnie’s only recourse to Bundy’s intellectual attacks” (Sullivan, 2009, p. 49). According to Sullivan (2009), matters became worse when Bundy learned of his illegitimacy.
It is unknown exactly how Bundy discovered his illegitimacy and it is difficult to pinpoint the true account. For example, many claim that Bundy was still being told his grandparents were his parents and his mother was his older sister; therefore, the possibility of being illegitimate was never an option.. As noted earlier, however, this claim has been disputed. Consequently, Sullivan (2009) notes that there are two scenarios surrounding Bundy’s discover of his illegitimacy that have circulated. In one scenario, Bundy found out through his cousin, John, who used the tidbit to tease him. When Bundy questioned it, John led him to his birth certificate. In the other, Bundy found the birth certificate himself while delving through papers. Regardless of how the discovery took place, Bundy’s illegitimacy reportedly had a major affect on him, leaving him “bitter” and “humiliated” (Sullivan, 2009).
Ted Bundy’s odd story – from his unusual upbringing to heinous crimes – has long fascinated the public. Even years after his death, many have continued to wonder: How could this charming, intelligent man do what he did? Why exactly did he turn out that way? What happened? These questions, along with the public’s fascination with serial killers in general, may be why Ted Bundy’s media presence continues to remain strong today, particularly in film and television. Moreover, this ethical dilemma that arises from the public’s fascination with serial killers prompts the question: Who is really serial? The murderer, the producer, the spectator, or are we all to blame?