Macaulay Honors College Seminar 4 | Professor Robin Rogers

Tag: housing

Urban Poverty, Housing & The Racial Divide

Those like Edward Glaesar, Harvard professor of economics, which in itself should tell you all you need to know, who contend that racial segregation in cities has all but abated, are living in a fantasy. What some may see as the integration of mixed race neighborhoods is often gentrification in reality. As housing costs rise, people who usually would stay in Manhattan are moving out and up to neighborhoods like Flushing, Forest Hills, Williamsburg, and Bayside, and they bring upscale products with them. For instance, new avocado-themed restaurant Avocaderia opening in Sunset Park doesn’t really cater to the current clientele around it, but rather what it sees on the horizon- the gentrifiers of Brooklyn moving in to enjoy their avocado this and that. The worst part is, I understand the appeal of a store like that! I would go there if in the neighborhood, and I can see friends of mine- that are white, read between the lines- specifically seeking the place out for things like savory toasts or sweet salads. But places like that price higher for clientele that can afford their higher prices, and afford the rent that creeps up higher as the neighborhood demographic changes, push out mom-and-pop delis and bodegas that cling to life in ethnic enclaves.

Another contributor to the racial divide in housing is that many landlords actively discriminate against certain races or social classes, even if those applying can afford the rent. In areas where a tenant board must approve new applicants, everyone suspiciously seems to be of the exact same background. It’s like a Stepford Wives situation, except it’s Astoria.

The prison-to-poverty cycle studied by University of Washington sociology Becky Pettit (oh why, why, why is her name Becky) is something I’ve heard talk about except in reverse- the unfortunately termed “pipeline” of minorities, often black people, from bad homes to delinquency in school to the streets to then, prison. To know that it works in vice versa, as such to create a negative feedback loop, is galling. The prison system is an overwhelming problem in American society today, and yet all these studies seem to leave us without solutions, only more proof of the problem.

Housing

Homelessness is a pervasive issue in New York City especially, as evidenced by the fact that many of our first thoughts for Issues of New York was homelessness. Interestingly, I don’t think anyone chose to follow up with it, likely because it is so often a dead end policy-wise and emotion-wise. In New York we don’t even see homeless people as human beings, just detritus. The Trevor Noah comedy night we had at Queens College last week involved a whole bit about homeless people trying to get money- as in, to survive- and everyone was laughing because they all know what’s it like from the outside looking in. And yet, these are human beings.

I read this lovely feature in the New York Times about a Girl Scout troop made up entirely of homeless girls and it was heartwarming. That HUD count that pointed out that 66 percent of homeless adults with children live with friends before entering shelters is vital to demonstrating that these families are trying. It’s just that people don’t have the ability to couch surf forever, especially with children.

When I was in elementary school, there was a little boy who used to annoy the hell out of me. He didn’t smell great, constantly fidgeted, and even fought with me. I complained about him to my mother, who went to the teacher, and the teacher, rather than shooing my mother off, actually explained to her that the boy had pent up energy and often was unable to shower properly because he lived in a shelter, and every day when he left school he had to go line up to make a bed for the night rather than playing with children his own age. Things like that exist because children continue to attend zoned schools even after they have lost their homes, often with little help from guidance counselors who have way too many other kids of whom to take care.  I worry most about children.

I agree with the idea presented at the end of Chapter 9 that finding permanent housing for people should take priority over making sure they have fixed their substance abuse issues. Having a place to live that isn’t in danger of disappearing on you is essential to feeling stable as a human being, and being able to live somewhere permanently gives one the freedom from that anxiety and allows one to focus on then self-improvement.

Housing discrimination certainly exists, but New York State has taken significant measures (at least on paper) to combat this issue. Of course, the real housing discrimination exists in the price tag.