Professor Tenneriello's Seminar 1, Fall 2023

Author: Anna Deng (Page 1 of 2)

Ramen Talks: The Red String Theory

What does the red string theory mean to you?

Cailyn: I believe in the power of free will. Everyone is born into different environments and circumstances, but one thing we all have in common is that we’re naturally equipped with the knowledge to choose and it’s our right to choose. Every day we are faced with choices, yes or no, stay or go, and so on. Every choice, no matter how big or small, has an impact on your life. As much as we may account these choices to someone else or an otherworldly being, we aren’t controlled by them. We have no chosen path until we individually choose one. Our choices determine our outcomes and consequences, which determine our morals, which determine our journey, our future, and the kind of people we are. 

Gab: I believe that the red string theory provides grounds for an interesting discussion on why things are the way that they are, but should not be taken very literally. We are faced with many important decisions to make throughout our lives, and by relying on destiny to have these choices already sorted for us might remove the significance of each consequence. Free will would also be contradictory to a heavy belief in the red string theory since the former suggests that each individual action leads to a different possible outcome and the latter states that our futures have already been set. While it is a fascinating subject to consider, I personally do not believe that it should be taken very seriously as it could also be used to deflect blame for irresponsible and harmful actions. To argue that it was “meant to be” should not mask the active steps it took to reach those circumstances. 

Anna: I believe in the red string theory. It gives a sense of solace knowing that the person who I am meant to be with is set and that I will meet them when the right time comes. As a person who is extremely impatient, I often stress about minor details such as who I am destined to be with or when I will meet them. However, reminding myself of the red string theory or listening to Taylor Swift’s invisible string reminds me to not stress over things I do not have control over. With that being said, I think it’s important to mention that my belief in the red string theory doesn’t revolve around the belief that god has tied an actual red string around people. My belief in the red string theory is more loose and involves believing in what it stands for. The belief that everything happens for a reason, and everything that is meant for me will come in due time. 

Claire: I believe in the red string theory, but more specifically I believe in destiny and fate. It brings comfort to me as every decision that I make is one that was predestined. It was the right choice and as someone who constantly thinks about what could’ve happened if I had made a different choice, this theory gives me a reminder that everything’s meant to happen for a reason. Another part of this theory that really draws me in is the idea of the right person, right time. Even if you were in the same place as the person you are meant to be with, you do not meet yet because it isn’t the right time. Everytime a person comes into your life, that was the exact moment that you were supposed to meet and every time someone leaves your life, that was just how it was supposed to be. This makes the people in my life more special to me because we were supposed to meet and we were supposed to be together in this life. 

Whether bound by a string of fate and destiny,

Or bound by a string of choices and decision

We are all where we’re meant to be

Link to podcast

Reading Response 5

I chose to visit the American Museum of Natural History as a means of gaining a deeper appreciation of the scientific world around us. As I continue my day to day activities of going to school or hanging out with friends, it’s easy to lose sight of how far we have come as a society. People have become more focused on their own agendas and have forgotten the scientific world they’re encompassed in. Over the years, people have studied all aspects of the world, and because of this, there’s an abundance of knowledge about earth’s animals, natural gems, and extinct species that’s waiting to be explored in the American Museum of Natural History. 

The exhibit that caught my attention was one of the first exhibits I visited; this exhibit was the Akeley Hall of African Mammals. The centerpiece of this exhibit was the large life size sculptures of elephants that resided in front of the entrance of the exhibit. Surrounding the elephants were various dioramas of different African mammals and their habitats. Though a specific cultural moment wasn’t highlighted by these dioramas, one thing I appreciated was an emphasis of community in each of the dioramas I saw. A trend among all the dioramas was that each mammal represented was accompanied by at least two of its kind. For example, the dioramas of the Greater Koodoo, which was created in 1971 by Carl Akeley using a paper mache method, had three Greater Koodoos within it. The diorama labeled Bongo, which was created by Carl Akeley using the same paper mache method during the 1900s, had two Bongos in it. In the Greater Koodoo diorama and the Bongo diorama, it seems like both species were scouring for food. By having multiple Greater Koodoos or multiple Bongos scourging for food, there was once again this emphasis on community as the mammals were searching for food as a collective. It was significant to find out that the layout of each diagram was a replica of a photo taken by scientists exploring Africa. Knowing that the diorama wasn’t fabricated to show the community made the exhibit seem more authentic. To find out that in their natural habitat, the Greater Koodoos and Bongos naturally ban together to solve problems such as sourcing food makes the theme of community more prevalent in the exhibit.  

Viewing this exhibit helped me realize how important community is. Community encompasses all aspects of life, and to see how different species of animals all encompass community by working together to scourge food, it made me realize the importance of working together with my peers whether it be on assignments or helping each other out with mundane tasks. Hopefully, this message is prevalent when others decide to visit the museum. Apart from that, people should visit the museum because the opportunity to view the unique species in their natural habitat is quite rare. With the advancement of technology, people can easily see the species displayed at the museum online. However, seeing it in person as forms of sculptures is more significant and realistic. Seeing a 3D depiction of these species helps employ more empathy compared to viewing a 2D version of the species and their habitat online. Seeing these animals purely in their natural habitat made me realize humans are not the only people living on earth. With issues of climate change becoming more prevalent in the world, there is more emphasis on visiting the museum. If we are not preserving the planet for our sake, we should at least be preserving the planet to protect these innocent animals and their habitat. This museum should speak to everybody who lives on earth because everybody has an equal responsibility to preserve the earth and ensure its habitants and their habitats are maintained for years. In summary, if not for admiring the sculptures of unique species in their natural habitat, people should visit the museum as a means of realizing the importance of preserving our earth not just for us humans but for the various animal species that also reside on earth. 

Apart from that, I believe the exhibit was effectively organized. The large life size elephants that were created by Carl Akely in 1914 using paper mache effectively helped attract a large audience into the exhibit primarily due to its size and lifelike appearance. As I was walking around the elephant sculpture, my eyes naturally gravitated towards the dioramas surrounding the elephant because the dioramas were lit up compared to the dim lighting of the exhibit. Also, each diorama consisted of complimenting colors that didn’t distract from the main focus of the dioramas, the animals! However, one design flaw was the lack of direct accessibility to the dioramas on the floor above the floor with the elephants. Since the entrance leading to the second floor of the dioramas weren’t very apparent, many might opt out to view the second floor of dioramas. Other than that, I believe the exhibit was neatly and effectively curated to attract audiences to each different diorama. 

Blog Post #3

As I walked around the Food & Fashion exhibit at FIT, the pieces of clothing that stood out to me were the chocolate dress, the ramen printed pajamas, the Campbell’s Soup dress, the tomato dress, and the corn dress. A common theme that I see among these pieces of clothing is that they highlight a particularly common food you can find lying around in any household. Perhaps the designers chose these specific food items because they knew a majority of people can recognize it and grow fond sentiment over the fact that it is a food they have had numerous times. For me, if I had seen a dress that was inspired by caviar, though I would recognize what the food was, I don’t believe I would be as attached to it as I would the corn dress because I don’t have much experience or memories eating caviar. 

With that being said, I believe the use of common goods over luxurious goods is significant because it highlights prominent political issues in America. One political issue highlighted by the exhibit is America’s growing wealth gap. Due to the growing wealth gap in society, people don’t have access to luxurious foods such as caviar or high quality meat. People often have to resort to the cheapest options because, though the quality is compromised, they can buy the foods in high quantities to feed a whole family. For instance, I took interest in the ramen printed outfit because I realized the author intentionally designed a pajama set to signify how ramen is a go-to late night snack. Although the packet of ramen does not have much nutrition to it, most people eat it because it’s affordable and it feeds the stomach. With the giant wealth gap in society, the majority of people are on the lower income side of the spectrum and the exhibit highlights more common goods than luxurious goods to subconsciously highlight how most people can only afford common goods. The outfits designed with these common goods are very extravagant and luxurious themselves. This can emphasize how most families who are put at a disadvantage by the wealth gap often make the most of what they’ve got. It is crucial that we try to mend this wealth gap as soon and effectively as possible, but it is comforting to know many have not let this financial disadvantage put them down.

Reading Response #4

Desdemona’s aspirations to get into Princeton was made apparent in Ching Chong Chinaman. Throughout the whole play, Desdemona seemed to be on edge because she was trying to build the best college application that would get her into Princeton. For example, she was eager to discover a niche story about her family’s history to write about in her personal statement for her college application, and she was relentless on winning her school’s canned food drive because presumably it would build her resume and increase her involvement with the school. Apart from that, Desdemona even went against her own morals to maintain her grades; she assumed Jinqiang was good at math because he was Chinese, and she ended up throwing her math problems at him to finish even though she knew it was wrong of her to make Jinqiang work for her.

With that being said, I believe it is normal for students to have aspirations of going to an Ivy League, and I believe it is normal for students to work hard to ensure they get accepted into an Ivy League school. However, in the case of Desdemona, I believe the pressure she has put on herself to get into Princeton is unhealthy. Desdemona’s desire to attend Princeton has taken precedence over all aspects of her life, and this struggle highlights a larger issue among college applications today in the United States of America. Today, the criteria required to get into top colleges like Ivy League schools have reached an all time high, and these exceedingly high expectations for students to maintain good grades, uphold multiple leadership positions, have an exceptionally high SAT score, and start a non-profit organization just to be noticed certainly causes stress on students.

As someone who just recently applied to colleges, I can attest that this growing issue in the US is true. For a large amount of time, I always perceived that going to a top college like an Ivy League would ensure an easy way to success. Success to me was landing a job that provided a stable income because my goal in life has always been to be able to provide for my parents who have worked hard and selflessly to provide for me. In the midst of trying to apply for these highly sought out schools, I found myself feeling unqualified even though I had good grades, was the captain of my school’s Badminton Team, was the cofounder of the Mental Health Club, and was an SEO Scholar who attended an additional 720 hours of classes to prepare for the SAT. With that being said, while reading Ching Chong Chinaman, I heavily related to Desdemona who was feeling insecure about her own qualifications to get into Princeton, and I assure many other students must have related to her because the criteria to get accepted into these top colleges have become absurdly hard. It is a duty of our society to address this issue. Thought some competitiveness is valuable because it encourages students to work hard to seek out the goals they want, too much competitiveness can be negative. The mental health of students can become negatively impacted if they are continuously exposed to the relentless competitive nature of college applications. To protect our students and ensure they have an abundant life that isn’t solely focused on getting into these top colleges, the college admission process must be heavily examined and altered to prevent relentless competitiveness and exceedingly high expectations that only a few can meet.

NYC – a place where you’re never alone

New York City is 302.6 square miles big

And best believe every piece of land is occupied

If not by skyscrapers and stores

You got museums, parks, and statues

It’s easy to get lost among the chaos

But, there’s certainly someone who’s willing to give you a tour 

For the city that never sleeps at night, there’s one guarantee

You’re never alone

Situation one

is where you’re most comfortable 

You are surrounded by friends and family 

You’re having fun 

You go watch the waters

You visit Little Island

You go to karaoke 

You go study 

You do this 

Together 

Situation two 

is where you are most observant  

You’re subconsciously surrounded by 8 million people

You see faces you may never see again 

You see people walking past you 

You see people having fun

You see people laughing 

You see people crying 

Though your friends are not around 

You are not alone 

You’re actually one step closer 

From making a new friend 

Situation three

is where you’re most reflective

You may find yourself in a barren place

You may find yourself feeling lonely

You may find yourself at peace

You may find yourself scared

You may find yourself lost

You may find yourself by yourself

But, you’re not alone

Our thoughts keep us company 

Though their company can bring joy or sadness

You’re never truly alone in NYC
You have your friends

You have strangers who can become more 

You have your thoughts

Be intentional with your time 

Whatever company you seek 

It’s attainable 

Blog Post 2

On a walk around Manhattan, I witnessed this street performer who was elegantly swinging a short metal pole that was attached to her hands with a string. There was no planned choreography to her dance, but it seemed like she was going with the wind which is a sentiment about New York City; sometimes you just have to live in the moment and explore the city with no restrictions. A specific aspect about New York City that’s so special, is the fact that I may never see the lady’s performance again which makes it even more important for me to take it all in the first time I see it.

I have hyperlinked the video here.

(The size of the video was too big and couldn’t upload)

Reading Response 3

When Amin Nawabi started talking about his father in the film Flee, I was able to feel his raw emotions; I could recognize and understand how devastated he was when his father was taken away from him. The director’s stylistic and narrative choices certainly helped establish and build my understanding of Nawabi’s trauma.

In terms of stylistic choices, I saw the director Jonas Poher Rasmussen utilize three distinct types of visuals which helped emphasize the pain Nawabi felt when his father was taken away. In chronological order of the film, Rasmussen decided to introduce the topic of Nawabi’s father with a colorful cartoon adaptation of Nawabi’s family, excluding Nawabi’s father, sitting together in their house in Afghanistan. Rasmussen then shifts from this cartoon adaptation to a real televised film featuring the new Afghani government. The final transition of this sequence occurs when Rasmussen transitions to an indistinct black and white description of the moment Nawabi’s father was taken from the family. All these shifts in visuals effectively helped me understand the pain Nawabi felt when his father was taken away from him. With a cartoon depiction of a true story, it is easy to forget what being depicted is an actual true story. It is easy to get lost in the colorful visuals of the cartoon depiction of Nawabi’s story, but Rasmussen manages to reel the audience back by introducing a real televised film that introduces context as to why Nawabi’s father could have been taken, the reason being the new Afghani government felt threatened by Nawabi’s father’s presence. The introduction of the real televised scene helped remind me that the film is based on a true story, and that the events described not only happened in history, but also happened to multiple Afghan families who were all victim to the new Afghani government. Apart from that, Rasmussen’s decision to provide an indistinct black and white visual was also effective. The stark contrast between the buildup to Nawabi’s story about his father, which was colorful, to the actual scene depicting his father’s departure, which was black and white, made me realize how negatively impacted Nawabi was by his father’s removal. In contrast to the colorful animations, the black and white animations are impactful because they are limited and tend to focus on the more traumatic moments of Nawabi’s life. Having a distinction and purposely making Nawabi’s father’s removal displayed in different tones helped emphasize how pained Nawabi felt by his dad’s removal. Also, I thought it was an interesting approach to have the scene of Nawabi’s dad visually indistinct compared to the earlier animated depictions which were very color and detailed focused. The indistinctness of the black and white scene emphasizes how the removal of his dad was a blur for Nawabi; perhaps the moment was so painful, he doesn’t want to remember it.  

In terms of narrative choices, I believe the music accompanying each scene and narration helps reinforce the mood the director wanted to portray. In comparison to the colorful animation, the realistic televised scene introduced eerie background music which helped emphasize a scary mood. This is effective in that it emphasizes how scared Nawabi was by the new Afghani government. He was scared by the fact that they had the power to take his father, but also the eerie music can re-emphasize how the government mysteriously made his father “disappear.” On the other hand, in the black and white scene where the father was taken away, violin instrumental was used to build a sympathetic mood for Nawabi. It makes sense to use a slow-paced violin in the background, because Nawabi frequently mentions how he views the removal of his father as “sad.” All in all, the director Ramussen’s specific visual and narrative choices were very effective because they all helped emphasize how traumatized Nawabi is by the removal and “disappearance” of his father.

Photography Reading Response

In today’s world, there has been a noticeable increase in the public’s use of photography. The catalyst behind this trend can certainly be traced back to technological advancements that allow more people to participate in photography. For example, the inventions of smartphones have reduced the need of an actual camera to take photos, and because smartphones are easily accessible for the public, the action of taking photos have also become accessible and thus popular among the public. With that being said, society’s increased uptake in photography has revealed a lot about both photographers and their audiences. The photographs themselves reveal the subconscious interests of photographers and their audience.

It’s easy to assume that photographs reveal the photographer’s interests because people tend to take pictures of subjects that cause strong emotions for them whether it be a feeling of awe or disgust. However, the specific elements highlighted in the photograph of the subject provides a closer look into the subconscious interests and priorities of the photographer. Author Susan Sontag summarizes this idea perfectly in her book On Photography which states, “Even when photographers are most concerned with mirroring reality, they are still haunted by tacit imperatives of taste and conscience” (Sontag 4). In other words, photographs reveal a world that’s subjective to the photographer. Even if five different photographers were tasked with taking a picture of the same subject, the pictures would be different because each photographer would choose to highlight something that peaks their own interest. This is suggested by Sontag as she mentioned a group of photographers tasked with photographing a sharecropper ended up taking pictures where their subjects’ facial expression “supported their own notions about poverty, light, dignity, texture, exploitation, and geometry” (Sontag 4). As you can see, even though the main subject was a sharecropper, it wasn’t necessarily what they were interested in photographing; you can see the photographer’s subconscious interests by understanding the small details that were taken into consideration while taking the photograph. Photographers who were primarily interested in today’s poverty issue would try to highlight that aspect in their photograph of the sharecropper, while those who may prioritize the daunting conditions of life as a sharecropper may highlight the blazing sun behind the sharecropper.  

Apart from revealing the photographer’s subconscious interests, photographs also reveal the subconscious interests of its audience. Sontag touches on this topic as she mentions, “A photograph that brings news of some unsuspected zone of misery cannot make a dent in public opinion unless there is an appropriate context of feeling and attitude” (Sontag 12). How I chose to interpret this line follows: when you view a photograph, the photograph itself cannot enforce emotions onto the viewer unless the viewer already has an established connections with the subject of the picture. For example, “photographs of ill-clad, skeletal prisoners held at Andersonville inflamed Northern public opinion—against the South” (Sontag 21). As you can see, the depictions of prisoners who were malnourished and weren’t properly dressed for the weather ignited a strong fury among Northern public viewers. This is particularly because the Northern public were interested in the Civil War fight, and upon seeing these horrendous images, it made them feel angry because they realized how inhumane their enemies, the South public, were towards their fighters. To come back full circle, photographs are very vulnerable because, to viewers, they can either ignite strong feelings of awe or disgust depending on the subject portrayed. To have a strong reaction, emphasizes how the subject of the photograph is of interest to the viewer because people react nonchalantly to topics of insignificance to them. All in all, photographs have the power to reveal the subconscious interests of both the photographer and viewers. With the continuous advancement of technology, there have been updates made to allow AI to generate photographs. As to what AI generated photos reveal about the “photographers” subconscious interest is still subject to questioning, but perhaps the interests among the audience will still remain apparent. 

Blog Post 1: Madison Square Park Tour

I have lived in New York City my whole life, but up until Tuesday’s tour of Madison Square Park and neighborhood, I have never noticed the floating hats at 23rd street or the beautiful architectures we have in the city. Since my parents moved to America, they have worked endless hours to provide a good life for my brother and I, and because of this, I have always felt a need to become financially successful. Being financially successful will make me capable of supporting my parents in the future when they can no longer support themselves. In the midst of working towards this goal, I never found time to truly appreciate the art thats around me in New York City. When I finally took the time to see what’s around me, I grew a new sense of awe for the city. It made my life before noticing the art seem so mundane. With seeing the art around me, I also found a new sense of motivation and appreciation for life; seeing so much life in the city makes life in general seem so much more enjoyable and intriguing. These series of thoughts were taken into account to make the poem I attached below.

____________________________________________________

The city of lights

but I have narrowed my vision towards one sight.

One vision, one plan, one goal.

Financial success.

Stay focused, work hard, and don’t compromise

That’s how I’ll achieve what I seek.

library is home

read textbooks, complete assignments, repeat

the rewards of my effort will be sweet.

dreaming of visiting Paris and seeing the beauties oversees

knowing my success will get me there.

But little did I know,

what I seek is in front of my eyes if I took the time to stare.

The Courthouse down at Madison is there

It’s not Paris, but the building’s beauty sure is

My mind is in awe, when I see Beaux-Art intricately incorporated.

But, I can’t help but feel frustrated

Would I have missed this, if it was not for Tuesday?

Speaking of which

there’s floating hats on twenty-third.

Perhaps I am a nerd

Never have I noticed them until now

because my eyes were glued to

my one vison, one plan, one goal

The hats were so vibrant

shades of pink, blue, green.

Art is all around us

we need to stop and stare

because before you know it

it may be gone in a second

or never appreciated.

Life will be dated

with little inspiration to stay motivated

Cultural Heritage

I was born and raised in New York City; however, I always refer to myself as Chinese American because of the way I was raised by my parents. With my American identity, it always felt like a given to me: I grew up listening to artists like Maroon 5 and watching shows like Full House. In other words, I was surrounded by so much American influence as well as consuming so much American culture that it felt easy for me to take on my American identity. This was a different case for my Chinese identity.

For some time now, it was hard for me to take on my Chinese identity. It wasn’t because I wasn’t proud of my Chinese background. More so, I didn’t feel worthy enough to call myself Chinese. I always felt like I had to prove my Chinese identity. For example, while speaking English is a given to me, I am not as proficient in Cantonese, and this always made me feel not “Chinese enough.” The hardest part is, my lack of ability to read, write or fluently speak Chinese isn’t due to a lack of trying. I have attended Chinese school on the weekend, but it just so happens to be that Chinese is one of the hardest languages to learn.

Currently, my mindset has changed. My proficiency with Cantonese is still not as good as it can be however, I realized that my Chinese identity also comes from the way my parents raised me. They raised me under the Confucius concept of filial piety which raises emphasis on respecting our elders, our parents and those who came before us. One way we reinforce this concept is by observing Tomb Sweeping Day.

On Tomb Sweeping Day, my family honors our ancestors by paying them a visit and providing offerings. I vividly remember annually going to the cemetery to visit the tombstones of old family members and friends who have helped my family greatly. On this visit, my family would clear away grass which may have covered the tomb stone, plant new flowers near the tomb stone, lay food and wine in front of the tomb stone (offering food to the ancestors), and burn fake money and gold near the tomb stone (it is believed that the ”money” and “gold” we burn will reach our ancestors for them to use).

As mentioned by Elena Franchi in her article “What is cultural heritage?”, “cultural heritage is not only limited to material objects that we can see and touch. It also consists of immaterial elements: traditions…” With that being said, my family’s tradition of honoring our ancestors through participating in Tomb Sweeping Day is an intangible aspect of cultural heritage. With my family’s tradition, there isn’t necessarily a material item which can be passed down generations to ensure our Chinese heritage is preserved making this aspect intangible. The part of our heritage that is passed down is the action of honoring our ancestors, the action of burning fake currency, and the action of providing offerings of food and wine.

As for how this tradition is being preserved and passed down, my parents continuously make the younger generation join along and actively help on Tomb Sweeping Day. By introducing this tradition to my brother, cousins, and I early on, it ensures that we know how to carry on this tradition once our parents may no longer be around to do so. Once again, in my family there is a big emphasis on obeying filial piety, and fulfilling this tradition and having future generations join along for Tomb-Sweeping Day ensures this concept and tradition will last far beyond our lifetime.

« Older posts