Walk through Sunset Park Thursday Feb. 19th

 

Visiting Sunset Park was something of a nostalgic experience for me in terms of community and environment. My family is Dominican, and most of them have relocated to New York in the last couple of decades and began establishing families in uptown Manhattan, in a neighborhood known as Washington Heights. It became immediately apparent to me that the latin-american immigrant culture was just as powerfully represented here as it was in the neighborhoods in which I spent much of childhood. I was greeted right off the bat to what I consider to be a staple of latin neighborhoods, the latin bakery. Here I found baked goods that I hadn’t gotten a chance to enjoy since the last time I visited my Aunts a few months ago, and while Sunset Park’s Las Rosas bakery’s coffee and bread pudding might be amazing, I still have an admittedly biased preference towards the ones I get on Dyckman in the heights. I failed to ask the patrons their ethnicity, as I am now retroactively curious if the different manifestations of the same carribean treat were due to slight cultural differences as opposed to simply a matter of craft.

Close by to the bakery was a Peruvian chicken restaurant, a clear sign of the dense variety of cultures within the latin american communities of New York. There was also the classic Limousine Car service business. My grandfather was responsible for opening and operating one of the same vein in the Heights, so I am quite familiar with the role these businesses play within the community. As a whole I felt very at home within the culture of those few blocks at least. The differences in architecture between the two neighborhoods manifests itself in Sunset Park feeling more open, definitely less crowded, but the space also made the neighborhood feel slightly more menacing to me once the sun began to set. I walked to the neighborhoods titular park.

I noticed on the way the transitions from latin to chinese businesses. I dont think I ever made it into the Chinatown proper, but I definitely saw the influence of the community spreading into what seems to be the predominantly latino sectors of the neighborhood. The park itself is beautiful but by the time I made it there  it was already dark so I don’t think I was able to appreciate much of the primary interactions that would typically take place in a park during the daytime. It would be interesting to see how the different cultures come together and interact socially.  I could still, however, appreciate the amazing view.

The cold in general made it very difficult to appreciate much of the communal aspects of the neighborhood as I imagine most people were in doors avoiding it, and I myself had my face buried in my hood most of the time. I am planning on visiting again in better weather for sake of appreciating the park. That was quite the discovery for me. I’d only first heard of it through articles I read in preparation, and having seen the view I don’t understand how it isn’t a more popular attraction.

Neighborhood Observations: Red Hook

I never really knew much about Red Hook before travelling there, so I didn’t particularly have many expectations or conceived notions about the area. Perhaps my first surprise was learning how difficult it was to actually reach Red Hook. The most common way to get to Red Hook is by taking the bus and walking further into the area. I decided to take the shuttle bus from Borough Hall to the IKEA and begin my observations around and within the building itself.

I reached the IKEA at around 5pm on February 18th. The streets themselves were pretty void of people except for those lining up to get on the bus or those who were walking into the store. I feel like this probably had a lot to do with the fact that it was freezing cold outside. Across from IKEA was a patch of green space in front of another building as well as a lot full of buses. Many of the lots that I could see from the distance had graffiti on the gates. IKEA actually seemed to contrast its surroundings quite a lot. It seemed to be a huge reason that people were coming to Red Hook in the first place. Most of the buildings that were within spotting distance from IKEA had “For Rent” signs and generally seemed like older buildings.

Since there weren’t many people outside, I decided to go inside of the store to see the different individuals that possibly lived around the area. I noticed there were a lot of families with young children in the stores, many Hispanic and Caucasian. There were also many couples in their twenties looking around. I don’t know how clearly these observations represent the population of the area since the main public transportation routes to Red Hook stopped right in front of the store. Many of the visitors of the store might possibly be from other areas.

By around 6pm, I decided to start walking further down Bread St. Most of the contents of the street confirmed the images that I saw from afar. The streets were mostly covered with older buildings in between large lots that were filled with buses, cars and the like. Again, I feel like the lack of individuals I saw wandering about most likely had to do with the fiercely cold weather. Although the area that I was walking through seemed slightly barren, I feel like there would be more people roaming about during summer or perhaps earlier in the day.

As I was taking the shuttle bus back to Borough Hall around 7pm, I saw a lot of apartment buildings clustered together, but I couldn’t clearly get the street names. The apartment buildings seemed to be in the same condition as most of the other buildings.

However, I feel like the most surprising thing about Red Hook, is the view. When you look far out into the distance, you can clearly see the Statue of Liberty and a really beautiful glimpse of the Verrazano Bridge.

Reading Response 3

Mayor de Blasio’s new housing plan is merely building on Bloomberg’s plan of inclusionary zoning. Mayor de Blasio is setting up a plan that basically slightly addresses the major criticisms of the plan before it, by making more developers build inclusionary housing and creating better income targets. But how successful will his plan be? In his article “De Blasio’s Doomed Housing Plan,” Samuel Stein makes it clear that inclusionary zoning is not the best way to create affordable housing in the city. Instead of truly making a change to benefit those who need more affordable housing, de Blasio’s plan seems to focus more on keeping the capitalists happy while performing little improvements. Stein offers alternatives to inclusionary housing, such as building or obtaining public housing and maintaining it, making rent controlled apartments, or even community land trusts. Yet, Stein feels like these ideas are being pushed aside for the sake of politics.

Ritchie Torres and David R. Jones also bring up problems that already exist within the system, such as how the federal budget has been decreasing because of decisions made in Washington, how the NYCHA does not have to comply with the Uniform Land Use Review Procedure, which allows for the community to take part in development decisions and how the NYCHA is exempt from any of the listings of local housing and building code violates.

Yes, the plan tries to answer the question of what to do about affordable housing, but there should be more of an emphasis on finding the best solution and not merely one that works.

East Harlem Observation

Heading to East Harlem on February 20th around 3:30pm, I looked up the location on HopStop, which directed me to take the s79 to 86th street, then the R train to Atlantic Ave followed by the 2 train to Time Square and finally the 6 train to 116th street. I exited near the intersection of E 116TH ST (Luis Munoz Marin Blvd) and Lexington Ave. As I exited the subway, I could immediately smell pizza, which was coming from Sam’s Famous Pizza. The area was covered in snow except for the streets, which were congested with automobile traffic. The sidewalks, on the other hand, didn’t have that many people since it was extremely cold. Traveling down Lexington Ave, towards 115th street, there were a number of small, old “mom and pop” type stores like Raysol Farmacia, Kodak Film services…etc. As I approached 115th street, I immediately recognized “chain stores” like MetroPCS. The area began to look much more commercialized. There was also a Department of Health around the corner on 115th Street. The smell of food began subsiding from the air as I moved away from the small, unmaintained stores that mainly sold food & produce. Walking further down Lexington Ave, past E 115th street, I passed by a playground. I decided this would be a good area to spend some time in and observe the people.

The playground seemed like any other playground, filled with benches, a slide, a jungle-Jim as well as a basketball court separated by a gate. The playground was in an area directly adjacent to a number of apartment complexes, which reminded me a lot of those found on Tysens Ave on Staten Island. Although much of the playground was covered in snow, there were still a number of children playing, some even playing in the snow. The playground seemed to be a positive influence on the community, encouraging adults and children to exercise, even in below freezing temperatures.

After spending around thirty minutes in the playground, I headed past the apartment complexes. Although there weren’t many people outside, the ones I did notice were mostly middle-aged men and women (most likely out to shop for necessities or possibly coming home from work). They were mostly Puerto Rican and African American, though I did notice some Italians. Many of the stores in the area, particularly the “mom and pop stores” were based on these cultures. Once I hit E 117th Street, I decided to walk down toward 3rd Ave. As I walked down, I noticed a number of houses under construction. Once I crossed 3rd Ave, I noticed a number of stores, some new like a McDonalds and others were based on the culture of the area like Wok Express, a Chinese restaurant suggesting an Asian population.

Before heading back to the 6 train, I met up with fellow teammate Julia at 4:30 at Cuchifritos on E 116th Street between Lexington Ave and 3rd Ave. The menu consisted mainly of traditional Puerto Rican cuisine. Even though there were some new stores in the region, it was nice to see that the neighborhood hadn’t been engulfed by gentrification. There were still restaurants like Cuchifritos that offer traditional meals. I had never been to East Harlem before but it was clear that gentrification is beginning to appear in some areas, while others still maintain the feel of ethnic enclaves.

Reading Response 3

After reading Samuel Stein’s De Blasio’s Doomed Housing Plan, I felt disappointed with how de Blasio is trying to handle creating more affordable housing. He believes inclusionary zoning is the key, but this solution might do more harm than good. While inclusionary zoning allows there to be more affordable housing that targets households with lower incomes, the private developers and real estate companies are the ones getting benefits by making more money. This plan is not even targeting households with the lowest incomes which is even more upsetting. The government decides on how the inclusionary zoning will be handled based on their calculation of the Area Median Income, which was calculated to be $77,310. This is almost $30,000 higher than what the average household makes. This inclusionary zoning plan does not sound promising at all.

I agree with the article’s alternative plan to helping those that need more affordable housing. This plan is to build more public housing and to properly manage it. The price of rent should also be managed better. I do not understand how the price of housing can increase at such high rates when people’s wages are not increasing at those rates too. It is not fair that people have to spend over half of their income just to pay for the rent. The first paragraph of the article stated that the idea to use inclusionary zoning came from its popularity in other cities including San Francisco. San Francisco is one of the most expensive places to live in the U.S. so I do not see how this method is working. The number one focus for creating more public housing should not be how to make the most money but how to help the people who are struggling to pay their rent or who are currently without a home.

Question: What do you think Mayor De Blasio should do to overcome the housing crisis?

Neighborhood Observation- East Harlem

I took my trip to East Harlem around 2 pm on Friday, the 20th of February. It took a little over an hour to get there from my house. I took the B train and transferred to the 6 train on Broadway.  I got off at East 116th Street. This was the street I focused on while exploring East Harlem. As I walked towards 3rd Avenue, I saw many small businesses such as delis, nail salons, and a dentist’s office. There was an abundance of fast food places including Taco Bell, Burger King, a pizza parlor, and a restaurant called Cuchifritos. There were also apartments on the upper floors of the stores.

As I made my way towards 2nd Avenue, I began to see more Mexican restaurants and also one Italian restaurant called Nocciola Ristorante. There were more barber shops on this part of East 116th Street as well. I also started seeing more stores and signs with Spanish words. One photo store was called Numero Uno Photo. There were also more fast food places. I walked one more avenue down and saw a juice bar and two more barber shops. The people who walked around me were of different ethnicities, but the majority was Latino. Most of the people were middle aged men and women. It was extremely cold outside so there weren’t too many people walking down the sidewalk. The four-laned streets were busy though. I made my way back but also turned on 3rd Avenue so I could walk down East 117th Street for a few blocks. This was a residential street with old looking multi family houses. I didn’t see anyone as I walked down this street. Despite this being a quiet residential block, I did see a McDonald’s as I got to the corner. I also saw a few churches while walking around. On East 117th Street I saw one church called St. Paul’s Roman Catholic Church. There were more multi family houses on this street.

After all of the walking, I went back to East 116th Street and I went inside the Cuchifritos I passed by earlier. I met with one of my group members, Fatema, at this Puerto Rican restaurant at around 4:30 pm. The restaurant had a cozy environment with a long counter and seats for staying and eating. While the staff were all Spanish speaking, the people who were eating there were of mixed ethnicities. There were fried Spanish dishes being served at Cuchifritos. I tried the meat stuffed plantain while I was there. It was surprisingly cheap with the price being only $1.50. Most of the food on the menu was very affordable.

Even though East Harlem is located in Manhattan, the area of the neighborhood that I walked through reminded me more of Brooklyn. The small businesses and local restaurants were the reasons why. Even though the area’s population is predominately black and Latino, I did see people of mixed ethnicities walking through the streets and also at the restaurant I went to. With the abundance of Latin American restaurants settled in East Harlem, one can also see other restaurants with different cuisine making their way into the neighborhood. An example of this is the Italian restaurant I saw and the few Chinese restaurants that were scattered around the streets I passed. One can clearly see more cultures popping up in this neighborhood.

Crown Heights – Izabela Suster

If one wishes to visit Crown Heights, the Nostrand Avenue stop on the A or C subway line will drop you off right at the northern most tip of the neighborhood, at the intersection of Nostrand Avenue and Fulton St. Another option would be to take the 2, 3, 4, 5, Q, B, D, N or the R to the Atlantic Avenue-Barclays Center Station. From there, one can walk eastward along any of the streets cutting across Flatbush Avenue between the Barclay’s Center and Grand Army Plaza. This route, while admittedly more time consuming and tedious, captures the gradual shift from gentrified Flatbush to Crown Heights. I decided to take this route, walking along St. Marks Avenue from Flatbush Avenue to Nostrand Avenue.

From my time spent in the neighborhood, no other institution seems more central to the Crown Heights community than religion. During the course of my walk, a string pizzerias and delis popped up and then receded every few blocks. However, this food desert doesn’t lack houses of worship. Baptist and Methodist churches come in the form of derelict storefronts and crumbling stone churches.

Location 1: Royal Bakery & Roti House at 618 Nostrand Avenue

Date: February 12th

Time: 4:05 – 4:25PM

The Royal Bakery, according to Yelp, is “where the locals go”. The traditional Trinidadian bakery offers coconut rolls, roti and sponge cake. Behind the counter stood a Trinidadian woman and at the far end of the counter was another man engaged in conversation with a male customer. Hanging on the wall behind the men was the flag of Trinidad. The woman took my order (two coconut rolls) and granted me permission to take photographs. There was no seating area so I remained standing. While there, the main event was the conversation between the two men, who spoke of politics. Occasionally the woman would interject with her opinion. For the duration of my visit, the place quiet with little foot traffic. The few customers who did shuffle in were regulars, as indicated by their casual relationship with the employees.

Who is here: The locals (Yelp didn’t lie.)

Location 2: Connecticut Muffin at 615 Nostrand Avenue

Date: February 12th

Time: 5:30 – 6:30PM

The Connecticut Muffin located at the corner of Nostrand Ave and Bergen St., struck me as being oddly out of place. I recognized the coffee house franchise from its two locations in Park Slope. The café is spacious, with several round tables and one large communal table. The space is large enough for customers to keep to themselves. At 5:30, when I walk in, there are only two women sitting in the café, both charging their phones. I order a small coffee and become the third patron to do so. The large selection of pastries offered remains untouched as right outside the glass doors, lay authentic and inexpensive bakeries like Royal Bakery. Over the course of an hour, one group of three white males walk in and joke with the barista. Shortly after, another group of three walked in. After an hour, I left the establishment, witnessing no major shift in mood or occupancy.

Who is here: People who want to charge their phones and to drink crappy coffee.

Who is not here: The locals.

Housing in NYC

“Inclusionary zoning might displace more poor people than it houses, but when the system’s casualties aren’t counted, they aren’t seen.” Despite the façade of success that inclusionary zoning may at first be promoting, Inclusionary zoning cannot be fixed with a mandatory vs. relaxed approach. Under Mayor Bloomberg, inclusionary zoning did not create affordable housing and in addition, affordable housing was not very “affordable” since many of the families living in NYC make much less than the area median income, which is the basis of inclusionary rent. Even with Mayor DeBlasio mandating that developers set aside 20% of the new apartments for low incoming, it still leaves around 80% for high-income earners. With an influx of affluent residents, neighborhoods will be pulled even more towards gentrification, increasing the cost of living in the area. Inclusionary zoning also risks pushing out already affordable housing. Many housing complexes are rent-stabilized at much lower rates than inclusionary zoning would require. As bigger buildings are built, landowners of rent-stabilized housing will be encouraged to sell and the once “affordable housing” will be replaced with more expensive housing and only a few affordable housing complexes. Affordable will no longer be affordable under inclusionary zoning.

 

Question: Are there any other housing models that could be used to provide affordable housing?

Affordable Housing

Public Housing in New York City faces various problems. From the flawed approach of the affordable housing plan by Major Bill de Balsio, that combines Robert Moses and Bloomberg’s approach to housing projects, to the funding deficit New York City Housing Authority faces. The affordable housing plan, is supposed to be better than Robert Moses and Bloomberg by including inclusionary zoning. However, the three main problems that arise from Bloomberg’s model, is that it hasn’t produce much low cost housing, it fails to match population growth, and the rising inequality of income. New Yorkers must deal with the lack of affordable housing, due to it being based off of the area median income, and they must deal with terrible living conditions if they living in affordable housing due to the budget cut for the NYCHA. Many tenants face living in apartments filled with mold and water damage, most of which goes unrecorded and unenforced.

Question: What are the housing models, that other cities use? What are the housing problems other cities face?

Neighborhood Observation: Sunset Park

Living in Borough Park, I was very fortunate to be assigned to Sunset Park, a mere thirty-minute train ride away. I ventured to the neighborhood twice enabling me to get a clear picture of what it was like. The first time I went was on Wednesday, February 18, around 5:45 PM to attend a community meeting of Community Board 7. I took the R train and got off at 45th street and 4th avenue. Upon exiting the train station, I saw a moderately busy street. Fourth avenue consists of a wide street with cars rushing back and forth and a large variety of stores. There was a peculiarly large amount of bodegas and delis. There were also other commercial shops such as clothing stores, restaurants, and shoe stores. I had known previously that this part of Sunset Park consisted mainly of Hispanic people; however, I did not realize how much of Hispanic culture permeated the neighborhood. Nearly every person I saw was Hispanic and many of the restaurants served Hispanic cuisine. Coming off of 4th avenue were residential streets with brownstones of different colors, not like the uniform looking ones you see in neighborhoods like Fort Greene and the Upper West Side.

Walking to the community meeting, I noticed that the houses on the side streets were built on a pretty steep hill. After the community meeting, my GPS unfortunately led me in the wrong direction to the train station; however, I was able to see a much talked about thoroughfare at the meeting: 3rd avenue. Third Avenue is not a place one wants to be at night. As I approached the avenue along 34th street, I started to feel a bit on-edge. Unlike the streets leading up to 4th avenue, those between 3rd and 4th are very industrial looking with a few small junkyards and not a lot of people. Third avenue is right under the Gowanus Expressway. Cars travel down this street at very high speeds, and there weren’t many pedestrians. Unfortunately most of the stores were closed, but there weren’t as many as there were on 4th avenue.

The second time I went to Sunset Park was on Sunday, February 22, around 5:00PM. I started off at 55th street and 5th avenue and continued walking up 5th avenue toward Sunset Park. Fifth Avenue on a Sunday is extremely busy. There were large amounts of people, mostly families, roaming the streets going from store to store. Fifth Avenue had even more stores than 4th Avenue. In addition to clothing stores and supermarkets, it had a lot of pharmacies, phone stores, taco joints, and, surprisingly enough, quite a few pawn shops. There were many street vendors as well, selling anything from food to jewelry. As I walked I heard a lot of Spanish music, saw a few murals, and passed by many schools and churches. The park was absolutely beautiful. With a great view of the neighborhood and Manhattan, it’s the perfect place for families to enjoy, which is exactly what they did.

IMG_4137  IMG_4138 IMG_4141 IMG_4142