I did my reflection as a timeline in dipity. TechnO’Hagan looks at the way technology has changed over the course of the lives of my family members, and how it has affected the way we work, play, and interact with each other and the world around us. I think focusing on my family allowed me to show the impact of technology on multiple generations, as well as show when technology impacted people on a large scale (assuming my family is average), rather than simply when the technology was invented or became available.
I see many advantages to doing my reflection in this format: it allowed me to show change over time in a visual, easily digestible manner, and it allowed me to include video. The ability to show change over time can help the viewer reach conclusions they might have otherwise missed – for example, how technological advances have speed up over time, increasing exponentially. The ability to show the viewer the actual video of my interviews also can demonstrate more than a transcript or summary might have. For example, the viewer can see how matter-of-fact my father is about having once bathed weekly in water from a well that he heated over an open hearth – something that I, and I assume most of my peers, find strange and foreign.
However, there are certainly disadvantages. It took me much longer to prepare this reflection than any of my previous reflections. It will take you much longer to examine the entire reflection that it would if I had just written a few pages of summary. In fact, while I might have directly drawn conclusions in a longer written piece, by doing my reflection this way I am forcing the viewer to make connections and draw conclusions for themselves. For example, I do not specifically say anywhere in my timeline that as time passed and technology became more integrated into society, people became exposed to it at a much younger age. However, this can be inferred from the fact that my younger siblings all got their first phone/computer when they were younger than I was when I got my first phone/computer. The affect this has had on them can be gleaned through my final video, where my family reflects on the good and bad things about technology. Forcing the viewer to find the meaning themselves can be a positive aspect of such a project, because conclusions that one reaches on their own, having examined the raw data (in this case, the interviews with my family) may resonate on a deeper level, further the viewers understanding, or simply make a more memorable impression.
Overall, I think the benefits at least counterbalance, if not outweigh, the detriments. Either way, I had a lot of fun putting this reflection together. If I had had an infinite amount of time, I would have loved to have added many more points on the timeline, as well as fixed up my editing (it was my first time using iMovie – very easy, but my skills could definitely be improved!). I hope you have as much fun viewing my reflection as I had making it.
A guide to my family tree, in descending age order:
Hugh – Father
Kathy – Mother
Kaitlyn – Me!
Erin – Sister
Connor – Brother
Colleen – Sister
Okay – this should be fully working now. I checked it on someone else’s computer who was not logged into eportfolio, YouTube, or dipity and everything came up properly. I’m sorry for the delay – it seems the default setting for everything was private, and I assumed the opposite! Let me know if there’s any more trouble.
Oh no, I’m sorry! I changed it to public, I didn’t realize that private was the default. Let me know if it still isn’t working. I used the embed code from dipity in my post but it just added that last line – let me know if there is another/better way to embed it.
Shoot, I’m still not seeing it with that link. Even when I click the link to it on this page http://www.dipity.com/kohagan/ , I get “Great Scott, We couldn’t find that page.” Something else seems to be wrong. I’m sure we can track it down. See what happens when you check the link, maybe?
It takes me to the right page, here’s the URL:
http://www.dipity.com/kohagan/TechnOHagan/
Excellent. Now it works fine, and I got the embedding working, too. You did everything right for that, but WordPress tends to strip out some of the code when you switch from the HTML editor to Visual Editor (or vice versa, I can’t figure out which). Something to be cautious about when you edit the post.
Now to actually check out the timeline!
Except–Oh no! The videos are all private (probably your setting on YouTube?) too. Another drawback of this particular medium, it seems.
Kaitlyn, it seems like the link is not working! I can help get the timeline embedded, but right now I can’t even find it on dipity. Is it maybe still marked as private? Let’s try to get it posted. I very much want to see it!