In her book Rambunctious Garden: Saving Nature in a Post-Wild World, Emma Marris presents a new way of viewing nature. In her eyes nature is not limited to untouched ecosystems, but instead, it is everywhere. Marris rejects the conservationist approach of fencing off nature in hopes of preserving or attaining the pristine. Instead, she supports the idea that nature is in constant flux and consequently, proposes the cultivation of wild gardens alongside human development.
According to Marris, the typical conservationist fruitlessly aims for a retreat to the baseline, before human actions induced negative changes on the ecosystem. Using Hawaii as an example, she proved that restoring an ecosystem to its prehuman baseline is almost impossible. Human activity on the planet has altered temperature, landscape, and even the air composition. Hence, when experimenting on the possibility to reverting Hawaii’s Big Island to its native tree species, Marris found that the results were discouraging. In addition, she noted that the cost burden of getting rid of invasive species, repopulating the ecosystem with its native trees, and maintaining the baseline conditions would be too expensive for any government to bear. As a result, Marris does a good job of affirming her point that returning to the baseline is not a feasible approach to conservation.
Likewise, Marris also makes a good case for approaching nature by looking to the future, where gardens sprout amidst the destructive human hand. She states that there is no scientific reason for believing that the baseline nature is better than the nature of today. In fact, she supports the idea that ecosystems have always been subject to change. Meaning, there is no scientific evidence supporting the idea that nature will be stable or static if reverted to its pristine state. As a result, Marris claims that we are better off focusing on the future ecosystems that will be most responsible for driving the Earth’s natural processes. Hence, the search for the pristine should be replaced with a desire to cultivate the “gardens” in our own backyard. In other words, Marris believes that we need to foster a new thought, where nature is embraced as being everywhere. Through this idea, we can begin the process of creating rambunctious gardens that encourage humans and nature to interact, grow, and coexist.
Overall, Marris made a good case for leaving behind the ideals of a pristine ecosystem to focus on a future where nature is conceived as being almost omnipresent. Her ideas have a clear logical progression that supports the incorporation of both the human hand and wild nature.
