Questions: Week 4, Emergence of the Germ Theory

1. What was “contagionism” to mid-19th century physicians and early epidemiological researchers like Ignaz Semmelweis and John Snow? How did they challenge and/or revise earlier interpretations of the contagionist theory?

2. What were the steps by which John Snow developed his case for a contagious cause for cholera. Do you think his work fully supports his hypothesis? Could miasma be substituted for a germ?

3. Neither Snow nor Semmelweis lived to see his hypothesis accepted by scientific and medical peers. Why do you think that was the case?

4. In what ways was there a continuity between 1) miasmatic and new laboratory-based contagionist interpretations of disease causation and 2) in the daily practice of public health before and after the rise of germ theory?

About Margaret Galvan

Margaret Galvan is pursuing a PhD in English and a film studies certificate at the City University of New York Graduate Center. She has taught at John Jay College of Criminal Justice and Borough of Manhattan Community College and serves as one of the coordinators of OpenCUNY, the student organized, open-source, social media for the Graduate Center community. Her research focuses on the representation of women's bodies in twentieth and twenty-first century graphic, filmic, and text narratives.
This entry was posted in Questions, Week 4 (10/1). Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.