Macaulay Honors College Seminar 4 | Professor Robin Rogers

Author: YueMin

Chapter 11 & 12- Response Paper

The main goal of this class is to solve social issues in New York City. One of the major issues in NYC is urban poverty. Since NYC is a metropolis with millions of people, there are always people that are not meeting the federal poverty line. According to CQ Researcher, “An estimated 45 million Americans have annual earnings below the federal poverty line- $24,250 for a family of four.” I am not personally surprise at this data. As a child from an immigrant family, this is the yearly earning for my family of three. But can you imagine going on budget from month to month and your parents do not dare to take a day off? This is the case or even worse for many more Americans. So what can we do to alleviate the urban poverty that is concentrated in many major cities?

 

The current minimum wage in NYC is $10.5 for a company under 11 employees and $11 for any company with more than 11 employees. Compare to the national minimum wage, NYC has much higher wage but the living expense is much higher. Housing expense in NYC usually takes more than one third of a family’s paycheck. This lead to hardship to afford necessities. Housing and Urban Development estimated that “… 12 million households pay more than 50 percent of their annual income for housing.” The other 50 percent must divide equally for food, clothing, transportation (please do not get me started with the rising fare with MTA) and medical care. It is hard to live a quality life with half of your paycheck going to a landlord or rental office. In order to help families, government should has more rent controlled or subsidized housing. NYC has great initiatives but they need to partner up with private sectors more. The supply cannot keep out with the demand. They wait line for subsidized is more than one year and there is income requirement. For families under the poverty line, they do not qualify for the nice subsidized housing. They can only live in housing project which are plagued with even worse poverty, gang violence, and drugs. The housing projects are not ideal for families with kids, but many can only live there because that’s all they can afford.

 

I strongly believe that urban poverty can be alleviate with the right employment training programs and support system. Incarcerated people are most prone to poverty because of their dirtied personal profiles. Especially for the colored people in the United States. From a study aimed for “prison-to-poverty” cycle, 37 percent of young African American men have gone to jail after drop out of the high school. This directly result in poverty increasing for colored people. Often time, these young men came from the housing projects. They live with their parents and bring more violence into the neighborhoods. The lack of job opportunities in the region without good transport systems around them. The young kids cannot see any good role models so they choose to join gangs to seek protection. The poverty cycle therefore continues. So to break this cycle, the government should lift the families out of the cycle with enhanced education opportunities. With better job training, parents can work in better job with better pay. With more income, they can move the family out of the housing projects into better neighborhoods with good public schools. This domino effect can bring the children to see positivity in this world and attain higher goals.

Chapter 10- Response Paper

You might still remember the Occupy Wall Street Movement back in 2011. The movement centered on the economic inequality in American as CQ Reader’s Chapter 10 has explored as well. As the world becomes more globalized, many jobs can be done in various countries separately. This also has a profound effect on wages of typical workers. Economic Policy Institute found that, “Since the 1970s, wages for the bottom 70 percent of earners barely grew even as corporate profits rose and as income for the top 1 percent increased 156 percent…” This is not a good news for low and middle class. People struggled to meet the monthly end, while the rich are spending time on the sunny beach enjoying life. So what makes America so unequal and how can we change that?

Historically, people with the most power tend to be richer than others. They hold down money and land from previous generations and make investment on top of it. They grow money with money with different investments or simply interests in the banks. CQ Reader states that, “According to Forbes’ global billionaires list, the top wealth holders have seen their holdings rise at 6 to 7 percent per year from 1987 to 2013.” The wealth holders are not just only working on high paying job, but their money can increase by sitting there. The wide gap in wealth eventually lead to further inequality in economy across all classes. More wealth for a family means the children can afford to go to well-funded public or private schools. With the top education, they can make into prestigious universities and head into international firms. On the other hand, middle or lower class are struggling to pay every bills. Their children might not be able to receive the best education. Often time, some kids need to work during school time to support their families. They are less likely to receive college education than the rich kids. The domino effect affects many generation and lead us to the situation today. As the cycle continues, the rich invests into the economy where the middle and lower class have no access too. The trickle-down theory does not work when the lower class’s wage is staggering. People does not receive the same benefit as the rich does.

I personally believe a huge part of inequality in this country has to do with the old tax system. The tax system has not been updated for centuries. The income brackets are not up to current income situation. The top 1 percent sometimes pay less tax than the middle class because they have various ways to avoid tax or transfer the money oversea to these tax haven. The middle class is struggling to nature their families while paying all the taxes. The country is built upon the strong middle class; we cannot let the middle class to disappear. However, the rich has the money to pay to the government to help out different programs. Some economists argue the economy will be worse if the rich gets tax more. I completely disagree on this. It might be true that the rich invest the most into the current economy and ask for more service. But the real question is how much does these get pass onto the normal people? Are we benefitting from their investments other than getting jobs that are paid in minimum wage? A country cannot be prosperity with a small amount of people. The middle class is the real source of better economy.

Chapter 9&11 Response

Housing is a major issue for all non home owner. It often takes up more than one-third of a family’s paycheck. Some people may ask why is it so hard to buy a house in the United States? Isn’t is an American Dream? It is true that many people dream about owning their own home; however, it is not possible for everyone due to poverty or housing segregation. Sometimes, people cannot even find or afford a proper place to live. So they have to either live on the streets, or in motels or shelter. Historically speaking, United States have a long history in housing segregation which forced minority to concentrate in ghetto and hinder their ability to purchase a house. The global economic recession is also a factor that drives up the housing segregation and rate in homelessness.

 

In pre Civil War era, slaves and masters lived in separated quarters and it stayed the same way even after the Civil War. African Americans were often found themselves in very poor housing condition with concentrated blackness in one area. They could not find better housing option because many places set up rules to forbidden them to enter. During the post World War II period, the GI Bill was not fully benefitting everyone. African Americans still found themselves to be denied from the benefit. They did not receive any mortgage to purchase houses in the newly built suburban and they found themselves back to the urban center with poor housing condition. This did not solely happen to African Americans, but to many minorities as well. Banks practiced redlining to prevent handing out loans to minority so they could not purchase a house of their dreams. Redlining was still in practice today; it could not be completely eliminated without proper government overreach. Many housing discriminations could not be solved by private sectors alone. Government has to set up necessary policies to prevent companies to do so. According to Washington-based Urban Institute, “… racial and ethnic minorities continue to face ‘subtle forms of housing denial’ by real estate and brokers and apartment owners, even though ‘blatant’ acts of racial discrimination are declining.” These subprime loans led to the mortgage crisis during the economic recession which forced many people to leave their homes and became homeless.

 

Homelessness has always been an issue for this country. In the current economy, it is hard to find affordable housing with decent living condition. Many rental houses and apartment take out more than one-third of a family’s monthly paycheck. In addition to the mortgage crisis, many families become homeless because their rental homes are foreclosed. According to HUD’s 2012 study, more than 66% of families lived with a friend or relative before moving into a shelter. When they move into a shelter, some people said they give up dignity. Many people rather stay on the street or live in a motel if they still have cash. There is no definite way to end homelessness because different people are losing their jobs each day. Without a steady cash flow, it is hard to rent a home monthly. For other people, lack of education or trauma lead to poverty and then lead to them being homeless. Shelters have implanted on-site job training and support programs to get them back on their feet. HUD’s Housing First program is a great way for homeless people to return to normal lives, but it tends to be very costly to do that. Housing sources are tight because real estate developers do not wish to minimize their profit. The government should set up incentive for private sectors to provide more affordable housing The Affordable Housing program in New York City is a great example which prevents low-income families from being homeless. At the same time, the city government gives the developers tax break for each unit they have provided.

 

Discrimination in housing and homelessness often goes hand in hand together. If there is less housing discrimination, people are able to find housing everywhere with reasonable price. Homelessness would decrease because some people would not have to pay extraordinary prices to live in certain area. As the economy is recovering, people can find more stable jobs to provide them with consistent income for housing. However, the government would still need to work on policies to help minorities, especially people with disability and from disadvantageous background, with more affordable housing. The current housing price is beyond the capability of many minimum wage workers. People would return to shelters if the rent or mortgage exceed their monthly paycheck.

Chapter 8 Response

Since the dawn of the United States, racial inequality has plagued this country. Historically speaking, we had many racism laws implanted in our system and we had forgotten about them all. This caused the built up tension between different races in the United States. In the recent years, all these tension had exploded and became a national movement. “The Black Lives Matter” movement was a new wave of modern civil rights. More African-Americans were seeking better treatment with the police and less discrimination in governmental programs.

 

Many experts were in doubt that government programs could narrow today’s racial gaps. Harsh laws in petty crime and drugs caused incarnation population to quadruple. Minority, often Hispanics and African-Americans, was the main targets for police’s search. In New York City alone, Blacks were the subject of half of the Stop-and-Frisk policy. As more and more minority was in jail, family structure outside was heavily restructured. The lack of father figure and breadwinner in the family forced male teenagers to join gangs. They forfeited their education because the public schools in the area were usually very bad. Schools did not have funding to provide all the students with the same education quality as the majority White neighborhood. It was hard for any students to stay focus in school when they were surrounded by violence and drug. Only seven percent of Black high school students went to college comparing to 33 percent of White students. Many Black students spent their time outside of the education system in seek of income from crime. Once they went to jail, it was almost impossible for them to reenter the workforce or even continue their educations. Therefore, many politicians has suggested to implant more programs to allow disadvantageous students to continue their educations or create new job opportunities that were willing to accept them.

 

“Black Lives Matter” movement was the result of police militarization and widen racial gaps. The deep misunderstanding between Black communities and the police were finally set off after a record amount of police shooting footages surfaced on the internet. These phone videos were named the “C-Span of the streets”. It did helped the public to see how police was over-enforcing; however, it also impeded police’s ability to do his or her job. Current situation was like the old time when White fascists would lychee on African-Americans. The Jim Crow laws were actually still lingered around in today’s society. Blacks and other minority often faced discrimination in education, housing, jobs and etc. For example, the GI Bill after World War II was only limited to White veterans. Even though the bill should extend to every veterans, but only the White received college fund, housing mortgages, and chances to climb to middle class.

 

In short, the racial inequality could not be narrowed within the upcoming years (at least not with the President we have right now). The social gap between each ethnic group could only be narrowed from us within. Government programs could bring minority out of the poverty by giving them chances to learn new skills and escaped the ghetto. But there was no government programs could erase racial prejudice within our hearts.

Chapter 7 Response

Gang is a very unfamiliar term for me. I did learn about various types of gangs in New York when I was in elementary but that was about it. Living in peaceful neighborhood, people often forget about people in those rough neighborhoods. My last impression of gangs remains in violence outbreaks and distinctive clothing. However, Christina Hoag gave us the most recent update on how gangs work now. The fist gang ever appeared in 16th century, England. In the United States, gangs first appeared after the Revolutionary War to gain territory. After the mass immigration waves, immigrants began to form their own gangs for protection. The most famous one was the Latinos gang. Their connection with other Latino gangs provided more issues here.

As time has passed on, gang become more sophisticated. They no longer relied on drug and illegal weapon dealings, they move their businesses to more lucrative trades. For example, more and more gangs are set their hands in prostitution, human trafficking, online fraud etc. According to National Gang Intelligence Center, there is a 40 percent increase in gang membership since 2009. They find that, “Gangs are responsible for an average of 48 percent of violent crime in most jurisdictions and up to 90 percent in several others.” (434) Most violence incidents have connections to gang rivals. This directly cause to have more victims on the science because there will be more firearms and more use of synthetic drug. Teens are often the victims between the gang violence. They seek identity and protection which sometimes their homes cannot offer. Gangs become their second home. This is the case for both boys and girls. Experts has seen a rising number in female participation in gang activities. It is unknown why there is more female participation, but police often overlook the fact that women can commit violence acts as well. Additional to more female involvement, internet also become a strong weapon for the gangs. Because of the exponential growth of the social media, gangs start to use social media to recruit new members and wage wars against their rival gangs. Teens use internet a lot so it is easy to influence them over the internet. Rap and hip-hop music glorify the lifestyle of gangsters which can strike a false impression.

In order to prevent the growth of gangs, it is important to start with the youth population. They are often lure by the cool outlook of the gang. I find the Youth PROMISE Act is a good way to start because it teaches kids about the gangs and help rival gangs to negotiate when there is an issue. It is necessary to prevent kids from entering gangs because gangs are fueled by youth to commit crimes. At the same time, these youths can achieve higher education so they can bring their own family to a better neighborhood. It will also save taxpayer money from sending more people to the prison.

Urban Issues- Chapter 6

Racial profiling has a long history in the past. Since the ratification of Thirteenth Amendment, African-Americans did not receive the proper respect within the society. They fought against the Jim Crow laws and protested to earn their civil rights. Hispanics and Mexicans also had to fight against injustice when Texas became a state. Even though they were the indigenous people there for generation, the white imperialism over their land made them like the foreigners. The treaty after the Mexico-America War did not grant them citizenships right away. White settlers treated them unfairly and deported them as illegal immigrants.

 

In today’s society, Hispanics and African-Americans are still the main population subjected to racial profiling. For example, “… 53 percent of those stopped were African-Americans and 32 percent Hispanics.” (384) under New York’s Stop-and-Frisk law. These numbers are alarming high for two minority groups. Some experts argued that this law helped New York to lower the murder rate. But in reality, there is not much difference in murder rate with and without the Stop-and-Frisk law. This law can only build more distrust between police and minority community. The development of distrust is bad for the growth of the society overall. When the people started to doubt the integrity of police, this caused people to question the motive of police for anything. This is hard for police to perform their services and start more active patrolling.

 

Court’s involvement in racial profiling is helpful to set up a statement for the public. Nevertheless, it is up to police to enforce the decision. Often times, the police tends to ignore the statement because they are very “stressed” on the job. It is easier to write on paper than acting it out. I agree with a statement in Urban Issues, “… some racial profiling critics say remedies may be more effective if crafted by law enforcement agencies themselves.” (387) If the police department can set up the requirements to stop a person, then it will become more lucid to every police. Police departments should also trained police more strategy to de-escalate the situations. Body camera can also help the police force to learn from their actions. Many cases in Black Lives Matter movement can be de-escalated. I strongly believe that a police’s life is as important as a citizen’s life. With more friendly approaches, many cases can be solved with no causality. Personally I just found Tamir Rice case outrageous. How can possibly a 12 years old hurt anyone even with a real gun? Any 12 years old would be scared if a police tells them to do anything.

 

Racial profiling will not end unless there is no more prejudgment in this world. We can only try to reduce racial profiling with more police training and technology to check the power of police.

Here Alone

“It is very common to send your kids to school abroad in China these days. Before it was only college, now the parents sent their kids out when they are in elementary school. I came here alone when I was fifteen.
My homestay family helped me with my oral speaking and my high school is definitely very supportive. They are very friendly to me. Sometimes the culture difference caused little friction but it was fine. I guess the only downside is that there is no one can help you. I remember once during a rainy day, I dropped all my books on my way to school. I just felt kind of hopeless. I just stood there for a while. Then I collected my books and continued my way to school.
Well, I finished my college application by myself completely. My parents are in China so they can only help me financially. I just did everything online and now I am waiting for my acceptance letters. My high school did a few counseling lessons on college application so I guess I am fine.”

CQ Researcher Chapter 4 Response

Air pollution is one of the issues arise from industrialization. The excessive carbon dioxide, ozone, and pm 2.5 in the atmosphere caused global climate change. These harmful particles are also dangerous to the vulnerable group of people, such as elders and children. According to CQ Researcher, “Air pollution kills 3.3 million people a year, including 55,000 in the United States, mostly from strokes and heart attacks…” Air pollution has indirectly caused many people to have serious health issues. The government therefore steps in to regulate the amount of pollutants that can be released into the air. The Clean Air Act set up regulations for power companies and factories. President Obama raised the standard even higher after the participation in the Paris conference. Environmentalists are happy about this because finally there is a degree of control for air pollution. However, the power corporations are not happy because they need to invest more money for cleaner energy. This would also mean some of the coal or oil burning factories would be shut down due to the high level of pollution. Corporations would have to build new plants to keep up the demand of energy. It would take them years before they can retrieve the up-front investment. The energy bills for average residents will increase as a result.

Both environmentalists and the corporation owners have valid point. While the price would definitely go up if the equipment undergoes upgrade, the local air quality will become better. The current Clean Air Act is not as strict as the environmentalists would like because the energy corporations have more money to lobby the Congressmen or Congresswomen. In order to upgrade or renew the Act, I strongly believe listing out the economic benefits for corporations would be more useful. We cannot only look in short-term revenue, but also long-term revenue. Clean coal or renewable energy will be more sustainable on the Earth and brings beneficial health effects. It does cost a lot of money to invest in sustainable energy, but this is the road that the planet needs to go. The Earth cannot support lives on this planet if the greenhouse gas would not reduce. Currently, we are making our own end-of-world apocalypse by pollution the planet. If the energy corporations wish to earn more money in the future, they need to act now to reduce the release of carbon dioxide. We need to think about our future generations.