Harley’s History: One Villain, Three Origins, Endless Problematic Narratives

Download (PDF, Unknown)

Download (PPTX, 80.73MB)

Please click on the powerpoint download link to be able to watch embedded video and view notes for each slide. If unable to do so, the following are the links to the original YouTube videos on Slides 2 and 4, respectively:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=km9_hkx0Fb0&t=363s

(Watch from 4:50 until 6:00)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P1oBFNQBjcU

(Watch from 0:55 to 2:03, from 4:55 to end)

Harley Quinn: Particularly, Palatably Queer

Harley Quinn (alternately known as Dr. Harleen Quinzel, the Clown Princess of Crime, the Joker’s girlfriend, and Poison Ivy’s best friend and occasional paramour) is a character in the DC comic book universe who has recently experienced a meteoric rise in exposure and popularity due to her prominent inclusion in Warner Brothers’ Suicide Squad. She has established herself as a fan favorite, cultivating such a devoted following since her inception in 1992’s Batman: The Animated Series that the show’s creators incorporated her initial single-episode appearance into an integral series-long residency. She has since emerged as a perennial presence across almost all strata of the DC universe, garnering such audience and critical enthusiasm as to earn her own eponymous comic series.
 
There is a dearth of scholarship on this still-young character and her unprecedented pop cultural transmutation; most academic work exploring her multifaceted macrocosm is dedicated to psychological, philosophical, and sociological discourses on Batman, the Joker, and the larger universe they cohabit. In an attempt to rectify this disparity, I examine Harley Quinn as an unlikely proponent of a peculiar phenomenon: the acknowledgment and celebration of non-normativity in many of its varied psychosocial configurations. Using a critical lens informed by several fields of scholarship, I undertake an intensive character analysis of Harley Quinn while mapping her metamorphoses across multiple media.
 
Drawing upon queer theory, disability theory, and postfeminist scholarship, I probe the character’s popularity and her unique translation across television shows, graphic novels, films, and fan-mediated creative spheres. I argue that the character is a prism through which audiences can situate themselves in close relation to Harley Quinn’s singular place in pop culture as a paradigm of particularly palatable queerness.
 
(Word count: 280)

Abstract: Draft #2

Harley Quinn (alternately known as Dr. Harleen Quinzel, the Clown Princess of Crime, the Joker’s girlfriend, and Poison Ivy’s best friend and occasional paramour) is a character in the DC comic book universe who has recently experienced a meteoric rise in exposure and popularity due to her prominent inclusion in Warner Brothers’ Suicide Squad. She has established herself as a fan favorite, cultivating such a devoted following since her inception in 1992’s Batman: The Animated Series that the show’s creators felt compelled to incorporate her initial single-episode appearance into an integral series-long residency. She has since emerged as a perennial presence across almost all strata of the DC universe, garnering such audience and critical enthusiasm as to earn her own eponymous comic series.

There is a dearth of scholarship on this still-young character and her unprecedented pop cultural transmutation; most academic work exploring her multifaceted macrocosm is dedicated to psychological, philosophical, and sociological discourses on Batman, the Joker, and the larger universe they cohabit. In an attempt to rectify this disparity, I examine Harley Quinn as an unlikely proponent of a peculiar phenomenon: the acknowledgment and celebration of non-normativity in many of its varied psychosocial configurations. Using a critical lens informed by several fields of scholarship, I undertake an intensive character analysis of Harley Quinn while mapping her metamorphoses across multiple media.

Drawing upon queer theory, disability theory, and postfeminist scholarship, I probe the character’s enduring popularity and her unique translation across television shows, graphic novels, films, and fan-mediated creative spheres. I argue that the character is a prism through which audiences can situate themselves in close relation to Harley Quinn’s singular place in pop culture as a paradigm of a particularly palatable queerness.

Abstract: Draft #1

Harley Quinn (alternately known as Dr. Harleen Quinzel, the Clown Princess of Crime, the Joker’s girlfriend, and Poison Ivy’s best friend and occasional paramour) is a character in the DC comic book universe who has recently experienced a meteoric rise in exposure and popularity due to her prominent inclusion in Warner Brothers’ Suicide Squad. She has established herself as a fan favorite, cultivating such a devoted following since her inception in 1992’s Batman: The Animated Series that its creators felt compelled to incorporate her initial single-episode appearance into an integral series-long residency. She has since emerged as a perennial presence across almost all strata of the DC universe, garnering such audience and critical enthusiasm as to earn her own eponymous comic series. Despite this unprecedented transmutation across multiple media, there is a dearth of scholarship on this still-young character; most academic work exploring her multifaceted macrocosm is dedicated to psychological, philosophical, and sociological discourses on Batman, the Joker, and the larger universe they cohabit. In an attempt to rectify this disparity, I examine Harley Quinn as an unlikely proponent of a peculiar phenomenon: the acknowledgement and celebration of nonnormativity in many of its varied psychosocial configurations. Drawing upon queer theory, disability theory, and neofeminist scholarship, I probe the character’s enduring popularity and her unique translation across television shows, graphic novels, films, and fan-mediated creative spheres. I engage the character as a prism through which audiences can situate themselves within a uniquely dynamic manifestation of the third wave feminism movement and its emergent principles by arguing for her singular place in pop culture as a paradigm of a particularly palatable queerness. Using a critical lens informed by several fields of scholarship, I undertake an intensive character analysis of Harley Quinn while mapping her metamorphoses across myriad media.

Harley Quinn: The Clown Princess of Crime as a Paradigm of Particularly Palatable Queerness

Introduction: Harley Quinn: Is she a feminist icon? A competent psychiatrist fallen tragic victim to severe mental illness? Villain(ess) extraordinaire? The Joker’s girlfriend? Champion of the LGBTQ community?

Or does she, throughout her myriad iterations, rather claim a small piece of all of those identities, exhibiting the nuanced liminality that is the practiced territory of characters so complex, so enduring, and so popular that they transcend their own medium and permeate into more mainstream pop cultural consciousness?

In this class, we will examine Harley Quinn as an unlikely proponent of a peculiar phenomenon: the acknowledgement and celebration of queerness in many of its varied psychosocial configurations. We will critically engage with the character as a prism through which audiences could — and can — situate themselves within a particularly palatable manifestation of the third wave feminism movement and its emergent principles.

Students are encouraged to follow this fascinating character from her origins as a silly, sexy sidekick to her breakthrough into blockbuster cinema and beyond. Using a feminist lens, we will undertake an intense character analysis of Harley Quinn and trace her metamorphoses across multiple media.

 

Continue reading Harley Quinn: The Clown Princess of Crime as a Paradigm of Particularly Palatable Queerness

Supervillain Scholarship: Who is Harley Quinn? Four-Week Syllabus

Introduction: Harley Quinn: Is she a feminist icon? A competent psychiatrist fallen tragic victim to severe mental illness? Villain(ess) extraordinaire? The Joker’s girlfriend? Queer hero?

Or does she, throughout her myriad iterations, rather claim a small piece of all of those identities, exhibiting the nuanced liminality that is the practiced territory of characters so complex, so enduring, and so popular that they transcend their own medium and permeate into more mainstream pop cultural consciousness?

In this class, students are encouraged to follow this fascinating character from her origins as a sexy sidekick to her breakthrough into blockbuster cinema and beyond. Using a feminist lens, we will undertake an intense character analysis of Harley Quinn and trace her manifestations across multiple media.

Continue reading Supervillain Scholarship: Who is Harley Quinn? Four-Week Syllabus

Supervillain Scholarship: Proposal on Character Analysis of Harley Quinn

I am interested in using a feminist lens to undertake an intense character analysis of Harley Quinn (aka, Dr. Harleen Quinzel), a supervillain in the DC comic book universe. She was created in 1992, and since her inception as a cartoon character in Batman: The Animated Series she has appeared in countless comic books, video games, and films (including the recent Suicide Squad), becoming a fan favorite. As a psychiatrist who later develops schizophrenia – a working clinician attempting to reconcile her own escalating mental illness with her professional duties even as she begins to identify more with her patients than with her colleagues – she has a complex backstory that is too frequently dismissed in favor of her more ubiquitous, grossly reductive label: the Joker’s girlfriend. Furthermore, she is often (but not always) portrayed as an oversexualized, battered puppet, as much a victim of the Joker’s cunning as she is the brilliant psychiatrist who originally treated and analyzed him. In this way, she is a constantly shifting figure – almost a barometer for the prevailing (anti)feminist sentiments of any given work, and a powerful statement on the double standard facing female characters who must manifest countless traits (sexy, strong, weak, mature, infantile, battered, empowered, intelligent, foolish, vulnerable, naive, calculating, etc.) somehow simultaneously.

In order to undertake this multifaceted analysis, will use previous scholarship examining the origins of the comic book genre as well as its evolution through the decades. I will investigate how the comic book “universes” have permeated popular culture and, having emerged from their subcultural niche, how prominent characters like Harley Quinn now more than ever inform/are informed by prevailing conceptions of femininity, sexuality, and heightened or fetishized subversions thereof. Studying Harley Quinn is also a singular opportunity to assess current attitudes toward and understandings of mental illness; therefore, I will also incorporate relevant scholarly articles or passages from The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Finally, I will have access to a wealth of comic books, television shows, zines, movies, video games, and other media from which to cull more information and thus create a psychobiography. In summary, I will attempt to present an appropriately nuanced portrait of a complex character and map her metamorphosis in popular culture against shifting sociocultural schemas.