Category Archives: The Therapeutic Trio

Team Members: Jennifer Mikhli, MalkaNiknamfard, and Ilanit Zada

Insight into the final deliverable

The digital deliverable that we have constructed is a two-fold endeavor that seeks to bring about several learning outcomes. The deliverable that is in the form of a podcast consists of educating the public about the topic at hand, with the intention of bringing about the audience’s advocacy for the issue. Hence, the podcast is entitled “Music Therapy: Educate and Advocate.” The deliverable is synthesized from a recording of the physical engagement conducted on our part with musical therapy, overlaid with vital portions of the interviews conducted with Brian Abrams, Ellen Whealton, and Kalini, all board-certified music therapists. The first learning goal is educating the audience as to what exactly constitutes music therapy. The voice of Brian Abrams will bring about that learning outcome by his providing a definition for the field, an explanation about the range of clients for whom it is used to treat, a description of the systematic way in which music therapy is utilized, and, ultimately, the creation of a distinction from it and other allied health professions. The second learning outcome lies along educating the listeners about the issue of the lack of state recognition and the dangers it poses to the field of music therapy. Parts of Ellen Whealton’s interview is used to convey this to the audience. Lastly, Whealton and Kalani’s voices will be used to inform the public about how they can take part in advocating for music therapy itself. The first two learning outcomes should establish a concrete picture of the field within the audience’s mind, allowing them to internalize the final message of the deliverable and take part in the advocacy endeavor.

The aforementioned learning outcomes are achieved through the use of the strands of learning. To encourage the audience to engage with the message being imparted from the podcast, the first strand of learning that involves sparking interest and excitement is utilized. The deliverable begins with a popular fast-paced song to incite excitement and curiosity within the listeners. As the audience is introduced to the podcast with a member of the The Therapeutic Trio singing “Rolling in the Deep” by Adele, they will be more obliged to listen to the series of educating thoughts that proceed after. Music continues to run through the entire deliverable, breaking up and dividing the didactic portions of the podcast. Through the use of Whealton, Kalani, and Abram’s interview extracts we are generating understanding of scientific content and knowledge, which is characteristic of the second strand. The sixth strand of identifying with the scientific enterprise is aimed to be achieved by the deliverable, stressing how all can advocate for music therapy. Through the suggestions listed by Whealton and Kalani, as to how ordinary citizens can work to promote state recognition, listeners can begin to think of themselves as individuals capable of contributing to the scientific realm of music therapy. This identity component will be enhanced through the distribution of a template for an advocacy letter that anyone in the audience can send to a politician and bring about change in the field. This allows for the audience to further engage in the issue presented as the sample letter transforms the novel idea into a tangible activity.

Sample Advocacy Letter

A big component of our digital deliverable is educating the audience as to how they can get involved in advocacy for state recognition. We will encourage them to contact their local legislators, who can make a direct change in passing legislation to put measures in place that will guarantee music therapy a slot as an allied health profession. To facilitate this process we have tried to obtain sample letters that would serve as a template for their future engagement.  The one attached below will be handed out at the end of the presentation to encourage further engagement and catalyze their future advocacy roles.

 

Sample Advocacy Letter

Effects of Music Therapy-Based Bereavement Groups on Mood and Behavior of Grieving Children

Russel E. Hilliard’s article “The Effects of Music Therapy-Based Bereavement Groups on Mood and Behavior of Grieving Children: A Pilot Study” sought to study the measure of the effects of music therapy bereavement groups on the mood and behavior of 18 grieving children. Two groups were formed- the experimental (which consisted of 8 sessions of group music therapy and the control group, which featured children who were not exposed to group music therapy. The subjects then participated in a series of psychometric tests that measured behavior, mood and grief symptoms.

As difficult as it is for adults to cope and come to terms with the loss of a loved one, it is all the more painful for young children to cope with a loss. Unfortunately, many children are unable to articulate and express their emotions when trying to cope with grief and are therefore unable to find a suitable method of expression and acceptance of loss.

Music therapy has been used to affect behavior modifications in developmentally delayed children, behaviorally handicapped children, and even children with attention deficit disorder. Additionally, the emotional health of children has been treated successfully with music therapy hen used in school, homeless shelters, children’s hospitals, and even psychiatric community mental health centers.

This study sought to test whether or not a significant decrease in grief symptoms among children would be observed and assessed via psychometric tests.  The subjects used in this experiment were children between the ages of 6 and 11 and had all experienced the death of a loved one within the past 2 years, and an overall presence of grief had been measured at the time of the study. Because grief symptoms vary in children, a battery of four psychometric tests were used. The Behavior Rating Index for Children (BRIC) was used in two separate environments- the home  (evaluated by parent/guardian) and at school (evaluated by a teacher). The BRIC measures the degree of children’s behavior problems and measures the frequency in which children lose their temper, hit or push others, and say or do strange things. Additionally, the Bereavement Group Questionnaire for Parents/Guardians (BP) was designed to detect the type and severity of grief symptoms in children and measured emotions (guilt, sorrow, anxiety, anger, etc.), behaviors (over activity, withdrawing from others, avoiding reminders of the deceased, etc.), thoughts (disbelief of death, panic, sense of presence of deceased, etc.) and physical symptoms (headaches, stomach aches, lack of energy etc.). The BP also states the parent/guardian’s perception of the effectiveness of treatment on the children.

The experiential group sessions were 1 hour in length and consisted of singing, song writing, rap writing, rhythmic improvisation, structured drumming, lyric analysis, and music listening.  These musical techniques were brought in during therapy sessions in which the children not only shared their individual death story, but identified their loved one and were taught to express themselves by learning about what happens to the body after death, sharing something they enjoyed about the funeral or memorial service, and how their lives have change since the death of their loved one. Throughout the process, children were engaged in evoking their emotions vocally through song and even through writing words that expressed how they felt after the loss of their loved ones. Throughout every session, songs wee brought in that related to the topic that was being discusses every day, and students would say how they think the song they are listening to relates to their current feelings and emotions, and seek to identify with a part of the song with which they personally relate to. Additionally, the therapist defined the word ‘grief’ and students would write emotions felt during their grieving experiences while playing the drums. Through out the 8 sessions, different topics such as grief, anger, pain, etc. were discussed, and songs pertaining to those specific topics were played so that the children would be able to relate to them and analyze the ways in which they too felt some of the emotions that were being evoked through the song. Music was identified as a healthy means of expressing anger and pain, and songs were written to relay the pain felt during grieving. Another idea that was touched upon was using music to celebrate and retain the memories of the persons who died. Children replaced song lyrics with nostalgic memories of their loved ones.

In terms of the results, the BRIC test indicated a significant difference between the pre and posttest difference scores of the experimental and control groups and the mean posttest score for the experimental group was 7.22 points lower than the pretest whereas the control group posttest was 1.45 points higher than the pretest. Additionally, in terms of the BP, the mean score of the experimental group lowered 14.89 points after group musical therapy sessions whereas the control group mean lowered by merely 1 point. Parent/guardian perceptions of effectiveness of the treatment indicated that 56% viewed it as “extremely effective” and 44% viewed it as “effective”, and non guardians reported that the treatment was not effective. Also, 88% reported that they would “strongly recommend and 12% reported that they would “recommend” and “not recommend” was not indicated whatsoever.

The subjects that participated in the music therapy showed significant reductions in grief symptoms and behavioral problems as measured by the BP and BRIC, and the guardians found the treatment to be overall effective and stated that they would recommend others to music therapy groups. It was noticed that the children enjoyed attending the music therapy groups and verbalized their enjoyment of participation in the groups, thus proving that music therapy provides a positive medium through which children can work through bereavement and grief.

Interview with Ellen Whealton

This week, we conducted an interview with Ellen Whealton, a certified music therapist. She went beyond simply informing us about the field and its benefits, and actually told us how one would be established as a professional in the field. She said that an individual would have to receive a college degree in music therapy or an equivalent degree (in which case they would then have to enter a program to receive a master’s degree). In addition, the person would take a certification board for music therapy to get credentials as a board certified music therapist.  Interestingly enough, Whealton told us that there is national certification, so it should be recognized by all states; unfortunately though, that is not the case and many states do not recognize music therapy as an emerging field, as is the case with New York.  She informed us that the lack of state recognition poses a danger to the field because it makes it harder to get reimbursements through insurance companies. We ended the interview with her informing us of what we can do to advocate for the music therapy field as ordinary citizens. She said that we can write letters to our legislators and also sign the occasional petitions that we may come across online. In this case, people will raise awareness and possibly encourage state recognition.

Dialogue with Kalani

To learn about the requirements and state recognition issues rampant in the field of music therapy, a dialogue was initiated with Board-Certified Music Therapist, Kalani. He provides music therapy services in the Los Angeles Area and works to educate others in his field. He spoke about the requirements for music therapy which involve an individual completing a bachelors degree in an accredited music therapy program, completion of an internship, and board certification. He spoke about the ways in which state recognition is being brought about. On a national level, the American Music Therapy Association meets and discusses strategies to bring about the recognition of music therapy as an allied health profession. On an individual level, simply educating the public as to the work of music therapists is advocacy in itself. Kalani also proposed writing letters and sending emails to local politicians to bring about state recognition. This will be extremely helpful in proposing to the general public (our audience) how they can advocate for state recognition of music therapy.

Educate and Advocate

We have been working diligently to establish a concrete body of evidence validating the music therapy field, and illustrating its salutary benefits. This is a vital component, as we want to educate the general public about music therapy so that they can advocate for state recognition of the field itself. Although there is current board certification of music therapists known as MT-BC, many states refuse to recognize this training and board certification, resulting in a lot of patients being denied access to the treatment. As is noted in “Music Therapy in Texas: A Fact Sheet,” state recognition is vital for creating a state license or registry that would “ensure the safety of our citizens and for increasing their access to services.” 38 states have already established task forces aimed at the recognition of music therapy through legislation, by creating licensing and regulation requirements for therapists. It is reported that this state recognition allows access to a funding stream previously denied due to lack of state recognition. Currently, the AMTA and CBMT are working together on a State Recognition Operational Plan. The primary purpose of this plan, as noted by musictherapymaven.com, “is to get music therapy and our MT-BC credential recognized by individual states so that citizens can more easily access [music therapy’s] services.” This collaboration is hinged upon citizen advocacy of the topic to push such legislation onto state government agenda.

We have been sending out emails to get an authoritative insight about the issue of state recognition. This is being done with the ultimate purpose of learning how ordinary citizens can partake in advocating for the state recognition of this clinical field.

Interviews are set in motion as of now. Stay tuned………..

A Brief History of Music Therapy

The existence of music therapy can be traced back as early as the 1800’s, however it did not emerge as an organized clinical field until the mid-20th century.  Writings about the beneficial value of music therapy appeared in the medical dissertations of Edwin Atlee and Samuel Mathews, within the first decade of the 19th century. They were both influenced by Dr. Benjamic Rush who strongly believed in the use of music to treat physical and psychiatric diseases. This was followed by an actual intervention of music therapy in an institutional setting by Blackwell, and an experiment by Corning that used music in correlation with psychotherapy. Subsequently, in the beginning of the 20th century, several short-lived associations sprang about contributing various journal articles, books, and educational programs. However, these associations were unable to nail down music therapy as a clinical profession. Finally, in the 1940’s three important figures worked to facilitate the creation of music therapy as a clinical profession. These individuals were Ira Altshuler, MD, Willem van de Wall, and Thayer Gaston. As a result, many universities such as Chicago Musical College, College of the Pacific, and Alverno College, amongst others founded formal academic programs in the field. The field of music therapy developed into an organized profession in the mid 20th century. Associations were founded to give credibility to the field and place restrictions and requirements upon those seeking admittance. One such association was the National Association for Music Therapy (NAMT) founded in New York City itself in 1950, as it created a board-certification program for the field in 1985. Today the AMTA, an associated founded upon earlier such organizations, works to garner credibility for the field and educate the public about its salutary benefits.

Recent Articles Relating the Benefits of Music Therapy

Many magazine articles have come out over the years articulating the  results of numerous  studies that prove the benefits of music therapy. Two such studies are examined below:

A new study came out in “Science Daily,” an online source for the latest research news. It discusses a study that suggests that music therapy sessions can improve behavior in children living with autism. This study was reported in Pertanika journal. The study was conducted over a ten month time period in which hour-long sessions of music therapy were conducted on two groups of children with autism, 2-11, and 11-22. Their behaviors were measured using a target behavior checklist developed especially for the study. Behaviors such as restlessness, aggression toward other children, noisiness and tantrums improved by one or two points in more than half of the each group.

 

Another study conducted by researchers at the University of Jyväskylä in Finland found a connection between music therapy and its ability to alleviate depression. This was written about in an article on a website entitled News Medical Today by Catharine Paddock. 79 people of working age were recruited to receive 60-minute sessions of individual music therapy plus standard care, which includes anti-depressant medication.  Trained music therapist played a mallet or percussion instrument in a one-on-one session with the patient. The participants were clinically assessed before and after the study (within 3 months and then 6 months afterwards).  After  3 months, “ the participants receiving music therapy and standard care showed greater improvement than those receiving standard care only in symptoms of depression .They ultimately concluded that:

“Individual music therapy combined with standard care is effective for depression among working-age people with depression. The results of this study along with the previous research indicate that music therapy with its specific qualities is a valuable enhancement to established treatment practices. ”

This is significant as it bolsters the claim of music therapy’s ability to improve the mental health of an individual for whom it is conducted upon. The study also found that these results only lasted while the sessions were ongoing. Ultimately the article elucidates the “cathartic” qualities of music therapy. While these patients may not be able to fully express themselves, these emotions were released through the music therapy sessions as displayed with their drumming along.

Benefits of Music Therapy in the NICU

We were scouring the internet in search of lectures that we could attend in our area pertaining to music therapy. We were unable to find any in our area; however, we came upon various lectures online. One such lecture was Aniruddh Patel’s lecture on the website known as TSN, the science network. The lecture entitled “Music for NICU Infants: Effects and Mechanisms” focuses on the benefits that music therapy poses for neonatal infants. Dr. Patel notes that these newborns are subjected to living in a stressful environment during a crucial stage in their development. In the NICU ward, newborns are isolated, face unpredictable alarms and noise, and have frequent sleep interruptions. Because of this stressful environment, these babies undergo a rapid stress response with the sympathetic nervous system, accompanied by the slower stress response associated with the endocrine system (stress hormones such as cortisol). This could affect their metabolism in the short term, as well as their brain development in the long run. For instance, this could result in structural changes in neurons in brain regions that are rich in stress hormone levels. Thus, there is a hypothesis that this stress and stress related response can result in these babies having language delays, executive function delays, ADHD, and behavioral issues later on in life. In order to mitigate this stress response and thereby eliminate the negative effects it has on newborns, soothing music therapy sessions can be given to neonatal infants. In studies already conducted upon adults, music has the ability to lower the stress response by activating parts of the limbic system that has strong projections to the autonomic nervous systems and neuroendocrine systems via the hypothalamus. This same method could be used with infants in NICU wards because both audition and the limbic system are precocious features that develop even before birth. Studies have also shown that newborn babies show a response to music. The music that would be played would be lullabies as this simulates a womb like environment, with its slow contours and soothing patterns.  Recent studies have illustrated that such music therapy sessions have resulted in faster weight gain and earlier discharge, as the music mitigates the stress response, allowing for the energy that would have been diverted towards a stress response, to now being expended upon metabolism and digestion.  The music can also stimulate brain development as it provides sensory stimulation. Ultimately, Patel articulated the multi-faceted benefits of music therapy in NICU settings.

The Effects of Music Assisted Relaxation on Preoperative Anxiety

The Therapeutic Trio

The journal article titled “The Effects of Music Assisted Relaxation on Preoperative Anxiety” sought to describe the effects that music had on calming 20 pediatric burn patients between the ages of 8 and 20 who were preparing to undergo surgery. The purposes of this study were to determine whether or not there was a significant decrease in anxiety scores and physiological indications of stress following Music Assisted Relaxation interventions prior to surgery.

This article seeks to shed light on a different aspect of musical therapy’s potential to affect people in need of recovery and discusses the idea that not only can music be used to improve medical, physical, emotional and psychological health, but it is also used to calm people down prior to an operation. Before people undergo surgery, they experience anxiety due to emotional and physical distress as well as thoughts of fear, pain, and even potential death.

This experiment was prompted by past advancements n the field of music therapy in which many studies were carried out in order to demonstrate the effects of music on an individual’s physiological and emotional state in anxiety-causing situations. In a study conducted by Kaempf and Amodei, individuals who underwent arthroscopic surgery experienced a significant decrease in respiration rate, systolic blood pressure, and anxiety scores when being exposed to music listening interventions. In a similar study, Moss found patients who received music listening interventions had a significant decrease in their anxiety scores and experienced less of an increase in heart rate that the patients who did not receive music intervention. Additionally, Ralph Spintge compared groups of patients who received anxiolytic music as treatment with patients who received traditional psychopharmacologic treatments and concluded “music influenced all levels of the emotion ‘anxiety’ by reducing the need for drugs such as sedatives, analgesics, and anesthetics by 50% of the usual dosage” (Robb).

The aforementioned studies aptly convey the beneficial effects of music listening and relaxation interventions for anxiety management, and although it has long been known that music produces behavioral, emotional and physiological changes, research is now focusing on what characteristics of music are responsible for affecting the mind and body in such specific ways. It has been determined that slow to moderate tempos that are at or below a resting heart rate of 60 beats per minute are most beneficial, as well as a smooth, flowing rhythm without sudden changes. In addition, melodies that are slow and sustained as well as low pitches that promote relaxation and elicit soft music are key in decreasing heart rate and conductance level.

The study that this particular journal addresses was designed to examine the effects of a music assisted relaxation program on the physiological and emotional status of pediatric burn patients undergoing a surgical procedure. In terms of the experimental group, music assisted relaxation (MAR) interventions were presented to patients in the evening prior to surgery in order to familiarize the patients with the instruments that would be used the following morning prior to surgery. The following morning, the subjects were asked to get comfortably settled, the lights were dimmed, and music was played free field at an accommodating volume. The registered music therapist (RMT) lead the subject “through deep diaphragmatic breathing, progressive muscle relaxation, and imagery, which was used during breathing and muscle relaxation portions of the session, as well as ending with an imaginary trip that had been described by the subject the evening prior to interventions. On the way to the operating room and while undergoing anesthesia, subjects listened to music through headphones and the RMT served as a transitional figure that offered emotional support through the explanation of environment as well as supportive touch. In terms of the control group, patients received preoperative interventions that were normally given to all patients in hospitals and did not receive MAR interventions or music listening during any portion of their surgical experience.

The State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children (STAIC) was used to demonstrate the effectiveness of MAR intervention in decreasing anxiety and the scores revealed a significant decrease in anxiety from the pre to posttest period of the experimental group (p=.0082), while no significant difference was observed in the control group.  Results of the study show that subjects who received MAR interventions preoperatively experienced a significant decrease in anxiety, as measured by the state portion of the STAIC. When compared with subjects who had not received these interventions, MAR subjects revealed significantly lower anxiety scale scores, and patients even revealed that they experienced less anxiety, were better able to relax and sleep, and if given the opportunity, would use MAR for future surgeries.

Although physiological measures of heart rate, respiration rate, blood pressure, and temperature showed no significant change from the pre to post intervention, a slight decrease in heart rate was seen for the experimental group. However, this study did succeed in conveying the benefits and effectiveness of MAR interventions preoperatively to manage stress and anxiety. The effects that were observed and proven included decreased perceived anxiety, increased relaxation, increased coping strategies, and emotional support to the patient and his/her family.