Author Archives: Jason Qu

Posts by Jason Qu

Club 57 Visit Response

Club 57 was an incredibly unique experience and one of the most engaging exhibits I’ve seen at the MOMA. Immediately stepping into the exhibit, I was struck by the massive array of bright colors and a vibrancy that really embodied the image of the East Village and formed an excellent background to the considerable variety of different pieces. The subject matter of the artwork and the juxtaposition of said artwork with a club environment is significant and intentional. Understanding the culture of the club especially in the context of the LGBT community, counter-culture, and the aids crisis in the 1980’s is crucial to understanding the nuances and messaging of the works that have been posted throughout this exhibit. Many pieces of art came attached with political messages as notions of self-awareness, the LGBT community, and other social issues became deeply politicized.

One piece in particular that really stood out to me is this painting, posted above, of a figure whose face has been painted white and his body has been masked in a brown paint, highlighting his body from the neck-above. The drab mosaic cuts through the vibrancy of the club environment and symbolizes the darkness of the AIDS crisis in a place that is supposed to be marked with happiness and the forgetting of life’s trials. The historical message it imparts is something that I thought about as soon as I saw the artwork. The face of the individual in the painting has also been reduced to a simple, blank, white, and gaunt face, resembling a skull and having an air of “death” around it. This helps establish part of the mood in that time that likely inspired this work. This was a very dark drawing whose meaning was exemplified due to the burst of colors in some of the other works. I think it really called attention to this particular theme of the gallery and was a work of deep intrigue to me.

M. Butterfly Play Response

I found the use of panels and a moving set in this play absolutely amazing in not only demonstrating turmoil or a particular emotion when paired with music and a particular set of images, but also in helping to emphasize a sense of, to me, motion. This can be seen in almost all the opera scenes and the scenes of the Cultural Revolution, which would simply not be the same if it was simply just a handful of people moving on the stage. The rapidly shifting panels, combined with powerful music, helped give me a sense that a momentous shift was occurring. The use of panels during the Cultural Revolution, which displayed images of Mao Zedong and Chinese communist propaganda in the play is a prime example that really brought me into the “eye of a revolution”. In contrast, the panels also served to provide a practical change in scenery and inspire other feelings which can be seen in the scene in which Gallimard was in jail. The drab, grey panels helped provide a sense of darkness and isolation that went beyond plain incarceration.

Another very interesting aspect of M. Butterfly as an art form was the artful use of perspective to enhance the play, which served both a practical and aesthetic function. The practical function was to help move the story along and present multiple dimensions to the plot, which aided the viewer in their understanding of M. Butterfly. However, the aesthetic role that it played in the play was to help attendees to the play be able to see the perception of their relationship in Gallimard and Song’s heads, and their contrast to reality. In multiple scenes, the eclectic shift from first-person perspectives helped shed light on the rapturous misunderstanding between Gallimard and Song’s understanding of their relationship. I thought this was incredibly fascinating and something I had not seen personally in a play before. These elements of M. Butterfly provided an unforgettable experience, but it not does supersede the stunning performances of the actors who played Song and Gallimard, who manipulate these elements in order to inspire a sentiment of happiness and struggle in the beginning with a sense of deep emotion, pain, and separation in the play’s end.

Second Visit to African Burial Ground

For our second visit to the African Burial Ground, the focus of the visit shifted from just looking at the site and leaving time for introspection to the inclusion of elements we might have glossed over. We noticed a poem in the front of the monument that is meant commemorate the history of those who were buried here and we spent a good deal of time going over it, as well as recording shots of us reciting the poem. I think it’s an astounding part of history that we stand on ground where African-Americans were brutalized and buried to be forgotten for centuries, as an incredibly diverse group that is able to pay our respects in this manner. Another significant part of the site that we decided to focus on builds off the wall of religious and cultural symbols on the wall of the site. This wall is centered around a map of the world, with a walkway in the shape of an arrow pointing in the general direction of Africa, which represents the remembrance of the origins of those who were buried here, especially slaves that had just been forcibly moved to North America. This feature helps bolster a deep respect of the monument for not just those who are buried here and the experiences that they went through, but also the fact that for many of them, they or their ancestors were removed, against their will, from their native lands. This attempt at recognizing the brutal role of colonialism as part of this monument can be broken down to this one arrow, pointing towards home for many who were buried here. This drives home important themes that my group wants to focus on. We want to do a “draw-my-life”, illustrating much of the history that has been emphasized in this monument but we also want to convey a notion of not just the past but the future that the African-American experience and community has created in terms of cultural and social works and development.

The Legacy And Voice of a Lost Diaspora

For my group’s project, we chose the African Burial Ground National Monument. It is often easy, in such a modern city, to forget the centuries of history that have passed through New York, shaping its public spaces, culture, and people. Oftentimes we look towards art, statues, and monuments to remember and memorialize the individuals, events, and places that have sculpted our collective past. The African Burial Ground National Monument is dynamic in that it not only attempts to preserve history, the site is one of a recovery of history – where black slaves and freemen were buried from the 17th to 18th centuries, relegated to forgotten soil until a construction project in 1991 uncovered the bodies which prompted the city to find a way to preserve the previously lost history. One particular aspect of the African Burial Ground National Monument that I found extremely fascinating was the inclusion of dozens of religious symbols on the walls of the monument, ringed by the burial sites. Although my image doesn’t do it justice, this includes symbols that are instantly recognizable to us such as the Cross or the Islamic crescent but also includes symbols from places as what is now modern-day Ghana, a former significant source of African slaves in the Atlantic Slave Trade. This was significant to me because it represented how colonialism and the experience of slavery painted the diverse African continent as a monolith, a source of labor and nothing else. This feature was touching in that it appeared to cut through the stereotyping of Africa, in respect of the massive diversity and differences in experiences of not just black slaves in American but the African-American experience throughout American history in general. One part of the experience that wasn’t part of the monument that truly made me appreciate the historical value of the monument wasn’t in the picture or part of the site itself, was that during our time examining the beautiful structure, a tour guide led a group of what appeared to be kindergarteners, as he explained the history behind the monument. Their eyes gaped with wonder and they were eagerly asking questions about the space, and in that, I could see the prominence and importance of the monument – in producing a physical connection and bridge between today and the crucial history that has passed where we stand.

Response to Buried Child

Buried Child by Sam Shephard is a play that revels in its darkness, sense of confinement, and challenges societal expectations of what family is meant to be. The death of the American Dream is a clear and present theme in this shocking play and this is embodied in a different manner in each of the characters. It’s important to recognize the setting of the play, which is an Illinois farmhouse in complete disrepair, in the 1970’s, an era of American history noted for the socioeconomic decline of much of rural America as well as a backdrop of general discontent and “malaise”. Throughout the play, references to a lack of crops and a general notion of poverty are actively present. This context is emphasized in not only the physical house that the play is occurring in – where we see knickknacks strewn everywhere, a seriously old couch, and other worn-down furniture – but in the fundamental flaws in the characters as well as what they stand for. We can see the fall of what is traditional American morality centered around a father figure and tight-knit family. Dodge has abandoned his role as the patriarch of the family, rather he is simply an immobile, helpless figure which is something that is blatantly obvious from the beginning of the play to the end. Rather, the role is reversed and he is actively dependent on much of his family which can be seen in his sloth, bitterness, and desperation for more alcohol when Tilden ends up drinking his bottle while he’s asleep. Instead of being a major figure of the family, he appears more of an emotional drain, a rebuke of how people picture the father when they see a stereotype of the American dream.

This betrayal is also obvious in one of the major plot arcs of the play, which is Hallie’s incestuous encounter with Tilden, her son as well as the killing of their subsequent baby by Dodge. She betrays the notion of the caring mother, which appears to have had severe emotional repercussions on Tilden, who himself appears to be mentally delayed. Bradley, Tilden’s brother and Hallie and Dodge’s son, is also seen as a dark figure, someone who has lost use of a foot, and appears to be an aggressive and angry bully. Hallie beckons this end of the American Dream, by reminiscing about it, which I believe is symbolized in her constant recalling of her dead son, Ansel, who she often talks about creating a monument for. I believe she so badly wants to leave her current reality, she longs for any distraction or thought of a better time. The notion of morality in religiosity in the context of a generalization of America is also shattered which we can see in Father Dewis having an affair with a married woman, and then in the heat of a great domestic struggle, fails to provide any significant or any guidance whatsoever. Even Vince and his girlfriend Shelley, who appear to be individuals that appealed to the audience’s need for some level of optimism in the play, are sucked into the doom of the fall of Dodge’s household. Throughout the course of their time there, they separated and Vince himself appears to have resigned himself to a position at the broken home, giving up, perhaps a symbol that this fall of the American Dream as can be seen by the shattering of this household, is like a tree whose roots can still hold down the branches that reach out furthest.

Two Fantastic Works of Art

The performance we observed last week was magical. The initial piece was smaller in scale in terms of the number of performances and the range of motion that occurred in every moment. It featured women who were dancing in contortion, with a few characters that emphasized the confusion of motion. The mood was deeply more somber and there was heavy emphasis placed on the noises and action produced by the individuals rather than the music that was being played. However, the second performance was more “lively”, featuring bolder musical pieces that complement the massive activity by the large group of numbers. They both shared a sense of repetition, but the crux of the first performance was defined by how the audience perceived the constant recycling of motion. My reaction to the first piece was one of deep confusion, the repetition, confusing dances, and cast of characters was unlike anything I’d ever seen before. As someone who hasn’t had much exposure to interpretive dance, dance performances in general, or theatre, this was perhaps one of the most challenging artistic experiences of my life. I was unsure of the purpose of the piece. The second performance was also challenging but the dance was much easier to follow than the initial dance piece. It was “easier” to enjoy but still, I struggled with capturing the essence or purpose of the dance. Like the beginning, there seemed to be a focus on one or two individuals but the role this focus played in framing these dances would need to be studied in greater detail to be truly appreciated. Thusly, this was an incredibly rewarding experience and despite being perplexed, I thoroughly enjoyed the masterful work that were these dances. Oftentimes, the most rewarding observations of art in motion are in pieces that are not easily understood, rather than pieces that possess shallow depth.

The Garden Among Skyscrapers

The High Line continues to be one of the most iconic features of lower Manhattan, and its importance as a green space continues to be more paramount than ever in a rapidly developing downtown. In a part of a city that aims to be “trendy” or different at every turn, many people overlook the unique aesthetic and nature of the High Line – Chelsea’s answer to Central Park.

The particular experience of such a beautiful location can be captured in this photo looking out of the High Line towards a street that is steadily filling with people. Rule of Thirds is present, which I think help demonstrate how powerful this park is, the bottom layer of flowers and greenery representing the natural aspect of the High Line, juxtaposing it with the busy street and bustle below, symbolic of the city. The photo then melds with a grey sky that plays off the color contrast of the scene below it – a combination of green, brown, and yellow. The toned colors also help represent the “sleepy” nature of the High Line on this particularly rainy day.

In this, the charm and character of the High Line can be captured because the entire area is a place of contrasts. While the throngs of people, buses, and cars below the tracks emit a buzz of noise, the High Line is a place of people who are reading, speaking in hushed tones while on a walk with a friend, or simply staring at the sky. Highlighted by the steel railing, apartment buildings, and construction in the back, there is more emphasis placed on green spaces, trees, and stunning flora.

I noticed that on the street, everybody was in a massive rush to get wherever they were going but once you step foot on this platform, the world seems to get a lot slower. This photo demonstrates the natural beauty that is left behind in a big city and compels people to just stop and take a long look.

Comments by Jason Qu

"I completely agree with your comment on the incorporation and the constant presence of the elements of Chinese opera throughout the play. This, among other aesthetic and musical elements that M. Butterfly as a play is elevated from simple words into an amazing and immersive performance. I think that the Chinese opera in particular with its brash and striking musical tones to define a transition, change in tone, or intensity in a particular moment of a play was fascinating. It really helped transform a number of scenes and made them incredibly dramatic and visceral. Furthermore, it helped reinforce a theme or a recurrent image of Gallimard being deeply in love with Song, with their first encounter being at the Opera."
--( posted on Nov 22, 2017, commenting on the post M. Butterfly )
 
"I think your project proposal is incredibly interesting and I look forward to seeing your group present. This post really gave me a new perspective on how the subway helps demonstrate other features of New York City. This is especially true because I never gave much thought to the vibrant nature of the city through the lens of the Q line, which is usually a source of drudgery and a sense of dread (like all other subway lines). Also, I think your group's idea to use a video, as compared to more technical analysis of the subway line is a really innovative and thoughtful idea to show not only what the Q line stands for but what it represents from the view of a single person."
--( posted on Nov 8, 2017, commenting on the post Visit #2 )
 
"I love your project idea! I know most of us in this class are native New Yorkers and for me at least, I've never had the experience of actually staying in one of those ritzy hotels of New York that often line busy, clean avenues and streets. Most of what we see are in movies or television shows and dismissed as something that the "Wall Street crowd" indulges in. I was incredibly intrigued by the way in which you described the architecture, decor, design, and the people that populate and give the hotel its character. The description was incredibly vivid and I could see the hotel being an incredibly important part of the aesthetic fabric of New York City, something I hadn't given much thought. Your project really made me think and I look forward to seeing you guys present."
--( posted on Oct 24, 2017, commenting on the post Extravagance and Luxury )
 
"I really enjoyed how you analyzed the characters and broke down major things they said as well as their mannerisms in order to deduce their personalities. I found myself in agreement with much of your analysis, especially the way that you "profiled" Dodge. I think that Shepard was trying to emphasize how broken his role in the household and family was and how this translated to how broken he was at a fundamental human level. Your response really made me think about how different the play seemed when you read it in contrast to when you saw it. I think that Buried Child should definitely be a play that needs to be portrayed rather than just read because of the raw emotion that came out of the acting and the much more developed inferences and insights about the characters that a person can draw."
--( posted on Oct 11, 2017, commenting on the post Buried Child Character Representation )
 
"I completely agree with your assessment of both portions of the performance, but notably that of Cafe Mueller. Cafe Mueller was a piece that was certainly a lot more challenging for me and as you mentioned, lacked a clear plot. It seemed as if, over time, the lead character of the dance was constantly shifting as motion picked up and slowed down among others. The Rite of Spring was also something that, for me, was incredibly engaging and something that really created a stirring feeling. However, I think it would be shortsighted to say that the plot was clear in either case. I think this was likely due to the more organized structure and recognizable dance patterns in the second dance piece."
--( posted on Sep 26, 2017, commenting on the post The Evolution of Bausch’s Tanztheater )
 
"I really enjoy how your commentary emphasizes the role that the people of the High Line plays. I can really see that without the people in your photo and in this massively special landmark, it becomes just another set of railings and plants. Although I don't believe that art needs human subjects to be powerful, I think you make a strong and poignant statement that the High Line's personality and charm really shine through in the way that people interact with it. They use it as a gathering place, a focal point of meditation, somewhere to walk and breathe in nature, and as you point out numerous times, a place to fall in love."
--( posted on Sep 12, 2017, commenting on the post Love and Loners )