“Chapter 7: Growing Up West Indian and African American: Gender and Class Differences in the Second Generation”
-By Mary C. Waters
In preparation for the class discussion, we split the article in half, where Reid would discuss the first half and Andrew would tackle the second half. We read the article together, while highlighting and taking notes on the parts we deemed most important. Unsure of how to start the discussion, we decided to have people write something on the board so that we could assess their familiarity with and understanding of the reading. Unfortunately, we forgot to take a picture of the board after class, so we will put up a different picture as our featured image.
Reid:
Since I was presenting the first half of the article, I decided that it would be best to open up with a little bit of a background about the author, Mary C. Waters. Mary Waters is an American sociologist and professor at Harvard University. She specializes in the study of immigration, identity formation, and inter-group relations, with an emphasis on ethnic and racial identity among the children of immigrants (which is what this article is about!) She is especially noted for her concept of ethnic option which is the idea that the children and descendants of immigrants have the option of choosing whether or not to identify with the ethnicity of their ancestors based on 4 factors:
- Knowledge about ancestors
- Surname
- Looks
- Relative rankings of the groups
Here are some notes that I took on the parts of the article that I presented:
- Waters began a study in the early 1990’s of West Indian immigrants and their teenage children in New York City to explore how they developed racial and ethnic identity, given the overwhelming attention to race in American society. She also aimed to explore whether first and second generations would follow the same assimilation pattern that immigrants of European origin did at the beginning of the 20th century
- To do this, Waters conducted many in depth interviews with first generation immigrants from English speaking Caribbean countries, native born whites, native born blacks, and adolescents who are the children of black immigrants from Haiti and the English-speaking islands of the Caribbean.
Ethnic and Racial Identities
- 1st generation immigrants go to great lengths to differentiate themselves from black Americans, which serves as an aid in their assimilation process and relative success in the economy.
- Materialist American culture, oppressive racial environment, and segregated city schools and neighborhoods pose serious obstacles to the children of West Indian immigrants.
- Immigrant children grow up hearing negative opinions voiced by their parents about American blacks and to the belief that Americans respond more favorably to foreign born blacks.
o However, since they lack their parents’ accents and other identifying characteristics, other people are more likely to label them as American blacks.
o Some adolescents agree that the U.S. holds many opportunities, while others believe that racial discrimination and hostility from whites will limit their ability to achieve their goals.
- Social class, type of neighborhood they grow up in, schools they attend, and gender all play a role in how young people experience race.
- People from poor households in inner city neighborhoods are more likely to develop an “oppositional identity.”
3 Paths of Identity Development
- Identifying as American
- Identifying as an ethnic-American
- Identifying as an immigrant
- 42% of respondents identified as black American.
o They had definite elements of oppositional identity and saw schools as representing white culture and white requirements.
- 31% of respondents adopted a strong ethnic identity and distanced themselves from American blacks.
- 27% of respondents had more of an immigrant attitude.
o Accents and styles of clothing signaled to others that they were foreign born.
- Ethnic identified people were more likely from the middle class.
- Middle class children who attended local high schools were more likely to be recent immigrants who, due to the superior education in the West Indies, were the best in high school, attended honors classes, and were bound for college.
- First generation immigrants believe that while racism exists in the U.S., it can be overcome through hard work, perseverance, and the right attitudes and values.
- The second generation constantly experiences racism and discrimination, which influences their perceptions that race plays an overwhelming role in their chances of success in life.
- Parents are terrified of their children becoming Americans. For children, however, to be American is to have freedom from parental control.
- The parents’ faith in opportunity and structure open to hard work is undermined by their children’s peer culture and actual experiences.
Gender and Identity
- There are no gender differences in teens’ choice of identities.
- Girls experience greater restrictions and control by parents.
- Boys experience more racial solidarity in the face of societal exclusion and disapproval.
- Boys also face a more violent environment.
- Girls are more likely to graduate high school
Immigrant and American Identities
- Europeans experienced “straight line assimilation” which was learning the language, voting, adopting the culture, and achieving economic security and social mobility for
their children. By the third generation, they were thoroughly American, which was coupled with economic success.
- Since assimilation for Caribbeans was becoming American blacks, one of the most stigmatized and abused people in American history, the incentive to maintain their cultural and ethnic ties was high.
- The middle class used their Caribbean identity to claim “model minority.”
- Choosing to be American is an economic decision. The Europeans chose to become American because it positively impacted their economic success. Caribbeans choose not to become American because the less Americanized they are, the better they do in school, more time they spend on homework, less materialistic they are, and the less they challenge their parents’ and teachers’ discipline and authority.
Andrew:
In the rest of the article Waters continues to talk about the role of West Indians as a model minorities, but also goes on to speculate on the future of second generation immigrants as well as the cultural color line in the United States as a whole. When it came time stimulate some discussion with the class I believed a series of questions would hopefully bring out volunteers and bring new opinions on the topics discussed. I had hoped that differing opinions would arise and that this would organically lead to more discussion. Unfortunately, the class was not responsive and no argumentation broke out. Perhaps I had suffered from question either too narrow, leading people to one word answers, or perhaps they were too vague leading people to not know how to answer due to a lack of direction.
One question I asked was “How do you feel about this article’s explanation of the model minority concept being pushed onto West Indian blacks in retrospect with other views we have seen in this course?” My responses were largely blank stares and a single student saying that this was basically the same as we had previously discussed and it was a self fulfilling prophecy. Everyone nodded and continued with blank stares and since no one had any divergent opinions the idea trail was dead and we had to move on. I believe that the main reason this question was so poorly received was because everyone felt that this discussion had already taken place so it brought nothing new to the table.
One idea that Waters discussed was the idea that model minorities were a conservative answer to other minorities living in a “victim culture”. When I tried asking the class how they felt about this idea the answers were about as complex as “bad”. I feel like this question suffered from the bias of the article, clearly leaning on the idea that suggesting someone is using a misfortunate circumstance as an excuse is completely unethical and morally irresponsible. Personally this level of bias turned me off from the article; it confused me about the identity of the paper thus lowering its credibility in my opinion. Although there is a ridiculousness to get angry at people for being upset about a disparity and citing their low starting place as a reason they could not rise as high, I find it necessary for the victim mentality argument to exist to provide a certain moderation. If you always excuse people for a lack of success they will not become more successful. These are the types of options I was hoping to receive as feedback from the class. I wanted people to explore controversy, have others serve as moderating voices, and let a chain reaction take off, but I failed to execute in initiating this type of response.
I believe a better question I should have asked was “Did any of you feel like Waters showed a bias in this article? What was that bias?” From there I may have gotten a response or two and then could have asked, “Does anyone disagree?” I feel like this would have been better at eliciting a response from the class because it is structured enough to give them some larger concept they have previous experience with, but open enough that they are free to choose any part of Water’s article as the premise of their answer. Additionally this is more inherently opinion based on a matter that people would not have answered so unanimously to.
In a discussion of poor class response I have to address other factors beyond the questions I asked. First off, it seemed clear that not the entire class completed the reading as only a few people had any response the entire session. Secondly, I had used no visual aid to stimulate the class. This was a trend apparent in the more successful class presentations than my own. Mia and Jonas’s presentation hit the class with sights and sounds of her powerpoint in an aesthetically pleasing way. This was more engaging as it literally targeted more of the five senses than speaking questions by mouth could have. Another successful group in leading the discussion was Susan and Mario. Susan’s map that evolved as she relayed information chronologically helped the class make sense of a lot of information that can come across as dense in paragraph form. Unfortunately, Reid and I had no real geographical analog to work with and we did not devise any symbolic pictures such as Venn Diagrams at the time, but that would be a direction to move in with similar assignments in the future.
Here is an outline for the second half of Water’s article:
Model Minority:
-Idea of cultural vs structural obstacles facing blacks
-conservative vs liberal views of roots to difficulty for blacks
+liberals believe it to be structural
+conservatives believe it to be cultural-victim mentality
-West Indians generally have better interactions with whites
+Water’s hints it is because West Indians do not expect whites to be as racist so they are less tense which will make whites more comfortable
+Model Minority Ideas are self fulfilling prophecies
+West Indian success is not a triumph, merely a contrast to failure by white society
Future of the Second Generation:
-Structure rapidly affects culture
-Blacks disconnect with society when they perceive white culture as hostile towards them
+This creates a second self fulfilling prophecy as this disconnection leads blacks not to climb as high in the society
+This also promotes a culture of opposition
+Idea that blacks would rather be hated than disrespected because they will not accept the treatment their grandparents received
+Cycle of attacks and disrespect by whites, retaliation from blacks and counter retaliation from whites
-Policies that benefit immigrated Americans benefit all Americans
The Future of the Color Line in America:
-Prior to 1965 immigration wave, black/white was the prevalent race dichotomy
+People of color has come to encompass all non-whites
+People of color should challenge white hegemony
-Irish and blacks used to be on equal footing when dealing with racial prejudice
+Eventually all Europeans crossed the color line and became white
+Most asians crossed the color line and are effectively white
+Koreans fullfill the old niche role of Jewish Americans in ghettos
+West Indians are the the blacks who have crossed the color line and are thus the whites of the black population
-Wealth grants decision to choose identity
-Both whites and blacks in America view themselves as children of immigrants
December 17, 2024 at 9:28 pm
Your article was so inspiring, it really made an impression on me. Don’t miss the free New HPE6-A73 test pattern questions—the key to promotion and higher pay!
December 18, 2024 at 12:05 am
Mary C. Waters’ *“Chapter 7: Growing Up West Indian and African American”* explores how the children of West Indian immigrants develop racial and ethnic identities in America. Through interviews, Waters identifies three paths of identity development—American, ethnic-American, and immigrant—shaped by factors like social class, neighborhood, and gender. First-generation immigrants often see racism as surmountable through hard work, while their children experience it as a central barrier to success, influencing identity formation. Waters highlights how cultural ties and opposition to American black identity can impact economic outcomes, with Caribbean identity often linked to academic success and disciplined behavior. Moreover to play volleyball game click here https://spikevolleypro.com
December 18, 2024 at 4:38 am
This is a thoughtful analysis of Waters’ work, highlighting key themes like identity, social class, and the challenges faced by second-generation immigrants. Your reflections on class engagement and suggestions for improvement, like using visual aids, show great insight. Well done!
December 18, 2024 at 10:22 am
Interesting discussion on the perspectives shared by Andrew and Reid. It’s always valuable to consider different viewpoints on important topics. On a lighter note, if you’re looking for a fun Android app, I recommend Panda Master. It’s the Best Android app for your phone if you enjoy exciting mobile games!
December 18, 2024 at 10:48 am
FlyonCars offers an exceptional private hire taxi service in the UK, combining affordable pricing with a diverse range of vehicles to suit every need. Whether you’re traveling solo, with family, or for business, their hassle-free booking system ensures a seamless experience from start to finish. With professional drivers, reliable service, and options for both comfort and luxury, FlyonCars makes every journey stress-free and enjoyable. Explore their fleet today and discover a travel solution tailored to you at a price that won’t break the bank! https://flyoncars.co.uk/
December 18, 2024 at 1:20 pm
भगवान श्री कृष्ण की भक्ति में गहरी श्रद्धा रखना है? आप हमारी वेबसाइट पर जाकर श्री कृष्ण से जुड़ी विभिन्न भक्ति सामग्री और चालीसा पा सकते हैं। अधिक जानकारी के लिए कृपया यहां पर क्लिक करें और अपनी भक्ति यात्रा को एक नया दिशा दें।
December 19, 2024 at 12:23 am
Thank you! Embark on a journey to uncover the secrets of a forgotten world and carve your own path through the unknown with the immersive experience of Lost Life APK, where each twist and turn brings fresh challenges and unexpected discoveries.
December 19, 2024 at 12:24 pm
I run a small business and recently started using Telegram to connect with customers. At first, growth was slow, and I didn’t know how to get noticed. Then I found the Telegram SMM panel at https://likesmm.net/telegram-smm-panel and it made a world of difference. The services offered include boosting followers, enhancing post views, and improving engagement metrics. I used the panel to promote a product launch, and the response was incredible. More people saw my posts, and I even gained new customers from the increased visibility. What’s great about the panel is its reliability. Everything works as promised, and the process is seamless. It’s a must-try for anyone struggling to grow their Telegram channel or group.
December 20, 2024 at 4:30 am
In discussing Mary C. Waters’ chapter on gender and class differences in the second generation, Reid and Andrew prepared thoroughly, emphasizing background knowledge about the author. Engaging critical dialogue is vital. Just as finding one’s identity can be thrilling, so can navigating exciting realms like the Snow Rider 3D game. Both exploration and understanding bring us closer to our roots.
December 20, 2024 at 5:46 am
Thank you for sharing such an insightful and uplifting article! I used the Vce 101-500 format to get promoted and get a pay raise. Now it’s free to all. I hope you all get promoted soon!
December 22, 2024 at 11:14 am
“शिव जी की भक्ति में लगे भक्तों के लिए एक शानदार वेबसाइट है जहाँ आप शिव आरती के शब्दों और अन्य धार्मिक सामग्री को आसानी से पा सकते हैं। यदि आप भी इन भक्ति गाथाओं को पढ़ना चाहते हैं, तो आप इसे यहां पर देख सकते हैं।”
December 22, 2024 at 8:14 pm
Class discussions like this are always insightful and help deepen understanding. Engaging in them feels as rewarding as solving wordle unblocked both challenge your mind in the best way!
December 22, 2024 at 11:40 pm
Thank you for producing such a fascinating essay on this subject. This has sparked a lot of thought in me, and I’m looking forward to reading more.
December 23, 2024 at 11:36 pm
Thanks for the website it was an amazing. ReadWorks
December 24, 2024 at 12:00 am
The article here is amazing KMFusa App
December 24, 2024 at 2:49 am
“Worldbox is a fantastic game for learning about ecosystems , societal development, and the impact of natural disasters. It’s amazing how this game turns complex concepts into an engaging and interactive experience!
December 24, 2024 at 4:34 am
But let me tell you that if you want to apply, then before that you will have to check some of your information like you can check your qualification, and you can check your date of birth to see if you are eligible to apply online or not, if you are eligible, Lottery Sambad Today then you can apply online from the link given below.
December 24, 2024 at 5:13 am
As soon as you click there, first you will register, Tafcop after registration you will get the registration number and password which you would have created yourself and after that I have given the link below for you to login, from there you can do it, in this way you will be able to apply online.
December 25, 2024 at 6:35 am
Thank you for producing such a fascinating essay on this subject purble place free game. This has sparked a lot of thought in me, and I’m looking forward to reading more.
December 26, 2024 at 5:57 am
The analysis in the article is thorough, and I’ve gained a lot from it. Reliable Lead-Cybersecurity-Manager study plan content is excellent and available for free.
December 26, 2024 at 6:48 am
The class discussion on Waters’ article effectively explored the complexities of ethnic and racial identity, particularly among immigrant children. Waters’ concept of the ethnic option is intriguing. Similarly, examining details like Chipotle Brown Rice Nutrition reveals broader impacts, whether in sociological studies or making informed dietary choices.
December 29, 2024 at 7:41 am
If we talk about the conclusion of this movie, then it is a romantic comedy drama movie and all the actors in it, that is, almost all the actors are new, and they have acted very interestingly and they have made this movie in a very good way. If we talk about the scenes of this movie, you will find people having very good dialogues and the actors have also made this movie in a very good way.
December 29, 2024 at 12:03 pm
हनुमान जी की पूजा और उनके भक्ति गीतों का महत्व अत्यधिक है। यदि आप भी हनुमान जी से जुड़ी और जानकारी प्राप्त करना चाहते हैं, तो आप इस वेबसाइट पर जा सकते हैं: यहां क्लिक करें और बजरंग बाण के बारे में पढ़ें।
December 29, 2024 at 10:30 pm
अगर आप भगवान हनुमान की भक्ति और उनकी महिमा से जुड़े शाब्दिक मंत्रों को जानना चाहते हैं, तो मैं आपको एक बेहतरीन वेबसाइट की सिफारिश करता हूँ। यहाँ पर आपको बजरंग बाण के सम्पूर्ण गीत और अन्य महत्वपूर्ण जानकारी मिलेगी। आप इस वेबसाइट पर विजिट कर सकते हैं: बजरंग बाण और अपने भक्ति अनुभव को और भी गहरा बना सकते हैं।
December 31, 2024 at 4:39 am
Slope 2 is not just a game, it’s an adventure!
January 3, 2025 at 5:25 am
Can’t stop myself from liking this amazing content. Free Reliable 300-425 practice questions download test papers—good luck to all!
January 3, 2025 at 5:40 am
“Andrew and Reid are such a dynamic duo! Their creativity and teamwork always bring something fresh and inspiring to the table. If you’re writing about them or showcasing their work, try using a stylish font changer to make your text pop! It’s a simple way to match their energy and make your content look as impressive as their achievements. Keep up the amazing work, Andrew and Reid!”
January 4, 2025 at 8:41 am
Del Taco Secret Menu offers a cool and customizable way to beat the heat with some hidden gems! From their signature Strawberry Lemonade Freezes to the Tropical Smoothie Freeze, these icy beverages are perfect for refreshing your day. Del Taco’s unique blend of crushed ice and flavorful syrups creates a smooth, slushy texture that’s perfect for cooling off. Plus, you can mix and match flavors to create your own secret drink or enjoy the seasonal specials. For example, try the Coco Loco Freeze or the Razzleberry Freeze, two fan-favorite creations. With these options, there’s a frozen treat for everyone, crafted to deliver a sweet, satisfying chill in every sip. Check out the Del Taco secret Menu
for more deliciously cool options!
January 5, 2025 at 6:52 am
The “FFNHELP” charge on a bank statement typically refers to a transaction related to a service or payment made through a financial service provider, often for assistance or support. It may be linked to customer support, a subscription service, or a specific financial transaction. If you are unsure about the charge, it’s best to contact your bank or the service provider for clarification. https://statementgeeks.org/
January 5, 2025 at 10:00 am
MiSide Game – The Ultimate Psychological Horror Adventure
https://www.misidegame.app/
January 7, 2025 at 1:59 am
“Andrew and Reid make a great team, whether it’s in business, sports, or just a fun collaboration. Their dynamic energy is always a joy to watch. If you want to enhance your pictures of these two or any other duo, try using face app to add some creative flair and make your photos even more fun and memorable!”
January 8, 2025 at 4:28 am
Google+ pages: Check them out for the latest updates on Nol Card Balance Check Number, your ultimate resource for all thrilling adventures and challenges
January 9, 2025 at 7:12 am
“Andrew and Reid make a dynamic duo in any project! With whatsapp plus original, you can easily stay connected, share ideas, and collaborate on the go to make sure everything runs smoothly between you two!”
January 10, 2025 at 4:38 am
Get in touch with Navrathan Jewellers to know more about Online Gold Jewellery Shopping in India
January 11, 2025 at 3:10 am
Die Fragenkataloge zur Axis ANVE Zertifizierungsprüfung aus PrüfungGuide ist eine Sammlung der Erfahrungen der zertifizierten IT-Fachleute in der IT-Branche und das Ergebnis unserer Innovation. Wir garantieren für Ihre einjährige kostenlose Aktualisierung, nachdem Sie unsere online Prüfungsfragen zur Axis ANVE Zertifizierung gekauft haben. Wenn die Fragenkataloge zur Axis ANVE Zertifizierungsprüfung irgend ein Qualitätsproblem haben oder Sie die Axis ANVE Zertifizierungsprüfung nicht bestehen, erstatten wir alle Ihren bezahlten Einkaufsgebühren zurück.
January 12, 2025 at 1:39 am
If we talk about the conclusion of this movie, then this movie is coming out as a masterpiece movie and its rating is quite average. If we talk about this movie, you people are going to see a lot of sources of very good quality.
January 12, 2025 at 2:04 pm
The decor at a Gary Reeder Wedding Africa is often inspired by traditional African art, using vibrant colors, intricate beadwork, and hand-crafted elements that bring the essence of Africa to life. Couples may choose to incorporate elements from various African cultures, such as Maasai bead necklaces or Zulu drumming, to honor the continent’s rich cultural heritage. Gary Reeder Wedding Africa
January 13, 2025 at 12:01 am
The audience has also liked their work, so the movie is going very well. If we talk about some important parts of it like what is the story of this film, how is the casting. And who is the music director, who is the director of this film, then you guys will get information about all the things in this blog, so you guys read our review.
January 13, 2025 at 3:30 am
Jika Anda tertarik untuk memahami perbedaan antara downstream dan upstream, saya menemukan artikel yang sangat informatif yang bisa membantu. Anda dapat membaca lebih lanjut di sini: https://askanydifference.com/difference-between-downstream-and-upstream/ untuk penjelasan yang lebih mendalam.
January 13, 2025 at 5:22 am
Si vous souhaitez mieux comprendre les différences entre le judaïsme, le christianisme et l’islam, cet article complet peut vous intéresser : https://askanydifference.com/judaism-vs-christianity-vs-islam-difference-and-comparison/.
January 13, 2025 at 8:38 am
This cafe is well-known for its coffee, which includes iced coffee and icy chocolate. Dunkin also offers eye candy bundles and combinations that are highly valued. Dunkin Donuts Menu
January 13, 2025 at 11:53 pm
So you can talk to them directly, you can only meet them. Tafcop So you people are being given an email ID, I am attaching a screenshot, you will get information from it.
January 14, 2025 at 3:57 am
Một trong những khía cạnh hấp dẫn nhất của 88CLB là các chương trình khuyến mãi hấp dẫn. Nền tảng này thường xuyên giới thiệu các ưu đãi hấp dẫn, phục vụ cho cả người dùng mới và người dùng hiện tại. Các chương trình khuyến mãi này được thiết kế để tối đa hóa sự hài lòng của người dùng và mang lại những lợi ích vô song, khiến nó trở thành lựa chọn hàng đầu cho bất kỳ ai đang tìm kiếm các giải pháp đáng tin cậy và tiết kiệm chi phí. Nhà Cái 88CLB
January 16, 2025 at 8:39 am
Interesting discussion on Andrew and Reid’s perspectives! Just like in thoughtful conversations, tools like the beautyplus video background remover can help streamline and enhance the creative process, making your content more impactful.
January 16, 2025 at 11:58 am
Will call you later in the best content ever for the same engagement and useful information thankyou so that we have been informed Shubham Visual
January 16, 2025 at 12:48 pm
I really enjoyed reading the class discussion! It’s interesting to see how different perspectives come together on such an important topic. If you’re looking for something exciting to engage with, you can check out firekirin777 for an exhilarating gaming experience.
January 17, 2025 at 9:47 am
Great insights on the discussion surrounding Andrew and Reid! It’s interesting to see how different perspectives shape our understanding. For those looking to enhance their mobile experience, the android app vblink/a> offers innovative tools for improving connectivity and user engagement.