Category Archives: General Discussion

“Snapshot: Global Migration”

I stumbled upon this fascinating map of global migration patters on the NY Times website. Here is a link:

http://www.nytimes.com/ref/world/20070622_CAPEVERDE_GRAPHIC.html

The countries are divided into two categories, green for the countries where more people were coming in, yellow for those where more people leaving. 

I was surprised to notice that Russia had more people entering than leaving–I always thought that Russia was more a source of immigrants rather than a destination for them. Another surprise was Spain: more immigrants entered Spain than any other country! (I guess everybody likes Spanish food?? Kidding aside–what could be some possible reasons for this?) I was also surprised to see how many people were immigrating into Afghanistan…I would have expected the opposite! Why does Afghanistan attract so many immigrants? Or do the positive numbers come from foreign troops?

What are your thoughts? Possible answers to my questions above, about Spain and Afghanistan? Interesting observations? Surprises?

*Keep in mind, this map is from 2007. Do you think it would look any different in 2014?

Grand Concourse Tour Reaction

Our tour of the Grand Concourse last Saturday gave me a different perspective of the Bronx. The elegance of the architecture lining the street, the beauty of the fountain, and the overwhelming feelings of vanished wealth portrayed a Bronx of luxury and money and not of poverty and struggle. It was definitely a tour worth taking.

It was strange finding out that the buildings we entered, with their beautiful Art Deco interiors, were now extremely affordable. I left the tour thinking that if more people knew about the now decaying beauty of the Grand Concourse, and the affordability of the apartments lining it, then there would be a furious migration to the area, for better or for worse.

Essay on the Meaning of Home

from Connie:

In poking around the NYTimes site, I came across this essay on the meaning of home, written by Roger Cohen, a very eloquent columnist and former reporter for the paper. Indirectly, it explores many of the themes we’ve been talking about in class, notably the meaning of home and what happens when people leave or return to their homelands.

I’d be interested in your comments. Please, everyone share a few lines about his argument and whether and how it resonates with you.

April 2 Discussion

I just wanted to summarize some of the things we brought up and decided in last night’s discussion on the final project (codename Stories of Making It In New York — SOMINY. Please someone come up with a better codename!).

Stories will be on the past, present, and future of “making it” in the city. That means that you can either research histories of individuals and how they “made it” and retell their story (past); you talk to people about how they are currently “making it” (present); or you can talk to people about how they hope to make a place for themselves, achieve their ambitions, realize their dreams etc. in the years to come (future).

You can understand “making it” in broad terms: making a place for yourself, finding happiness or acceptance, getting the part in a play, etc. It’s about more than just making a living, but achieving a sense of belonging, etc. You can of course also dwell on the ways in which people are barred from making it due to structural injustices, racism, hard knocks, etc.

Stories should be people-driven/people-focused. Even if you write about groups in the past, try to use individual people’s stories to narrate its trajectory.

Everybody will contribute at least one story, though you are free to contribute more.

In terms of the presentation of the story collection, we talked about two different visual organizing principles: a grid (Pinterest-like) vs. a map (guidebook-like). In general, there seemed to be a preference for the map, though we may try to integrate the two. If anybody wants to link to an example or a mockup, please do so in the comments.

Connie brought up Mr Beller’s Neighborhood, a collection of stories about different neighborhoods in NY. This is closer to the guidebook idea. Take a look and see if there’s something we might learn from that site.

Deadlines: Please post story pitch in the appropriate category by Sunday 4/6 at midnight. Between Monday and Wednesday of next week, read your fellow students’ story pitches and comment on them with praise, ideas or possible concerns. We’ll discuss further deadlines next week.

In the meantime, please don’t hesitate to reach out to me with questions and ideas. I’ll also be available by appointment for office hours at CCNY next Monday.

P.S. Sorry, Sabrina, about failing to address you by name. Ugh. I’m learning.

Macaulay A/V Equipment

This came up last night — the Honors College has some great A/V equipment available for you to check out for a week at a time. All you have to do is fill out this form three business days before you want to pick it up. We certainly won’t require it for the final class project, but you might enjoy trying out professional-grade equipment like a digital SLR camera for your final project. I can confirm that pictures taken with that kind of technology are noticeably nicer than smartphone camera pics.

2014-04-03-120330_501x665_scrot

Grand Concourse Tour Reaction

Despite the rain and wind, I enjoyed the tour on Saturday and definitely learned a lot. My favorite spot on the tour was the statue of Die Lorelei. I volunteer in the South Bronx so I walk through that park and pass that statue once a week. Somehow, I had never stopped to look at the beautiful statue. Hearing the incredible history of it and its place in history made me appreciate it even more. I will definitely stop and look at it for a moment next time I pass it. 

To me, the most significant part of the tour was the emphases Sam put on the idea that just because a neighborhood is poor, does not mean it has to be ugly. When we walked into the lobby of the first building on Grand Concourse and he showed us how much planning had gone into the building of the lobby so that there was a perfect view from the corridor of the fountain and the light, I was blown away. This, along with the statue in the park are things I would have never noticed but do make an incredible difference in the aesthetic of the neighborhood. It does prove that sometimes all you need is a little thought, not money to improve the way a place looks.

I have attached a picture I took of the statue and an Englishphoto1 translation of the poem that the statue is based on. 

 know not if there is a reason
Why I am so sad at heart.
A legend of bygone ages
Haunts me and will not depart.

The air is cool under nightfall.
The calm Rhine courses its way.
The peak of the mountain is sparkling
With evening’s final ray.

The fairest of maidens is sitting
Unwittingly wondrous up there,
Her golden jewels are shining,
She’s combing her golden hair.

The comb she holds is golden,
She sings a song as well
Whose melody binds an enthralling
And overpowering spell.

In his little boat, the boatman
Is seized with a savage woe,
He’d rather look up at the mountain
Than down at the rocks below.

I think that the waves will devour
The boatman and boat as one;
And this by her song’s sheer power
Fair Lorelei has done.

Aesop Storytelling Engine

The Aesop Storytelling Engine is a package that extends the functionality of WordPress (the software on which the Macaulay Eportfolios platform runs) for rich storytelling.

Please take a look at its functionality and features and comment here whether you think this would be a worthwhile tool for our final public project (the to-be-named “Making It” project). If you think it could be valuable, I will request that it be made available for us.

Histories of Migration Overlap in Charleston, S.C.

I was fascinated by this article in tomorrow’s Times on a relic from a former German P.O.W. camp in rural Charleston, South Carolina. Today the relic, a brick chimney, is located on land owned by a family with deep roots in South Carolina’s Jewish community. The chimney may soon be turned into a landmark, in which case, as the author of the article puts it, “Jews would be required to keep a Nazi-built relic on their property.” Incredible. Thought some of you might be as intrigued as I was.

Latino Voting Patterns

Note from Connie:

Regarding this article on Latinos rejecting the ballot box:

I never understand people voting against their own economic interests (or even more mysterious, not voting at all), but maybe someone can explain this for me. Are some groups simply so turned off when it comes to the political process (maybe understandable)? Is voting simply not part of the behavior norms of certain groups? Other explanations?

And remember, this is the demographic — younger voters — that helped bring Obama to the White House in 2008; what’s changed since then, beside a widespread disenchantment with Obama, even among many of his onetime supporters.

Anyway, all thoughts appreciated, as always.

Grand Concourse Tour

I thought the walking tour of the concourse was really interesting.  My best friend literally lives right off of the concourse on 165th so I knew my way around the neighborhood although not much about its history.  The Joyce Kilmer Park stop of the tour was the most interesting part to me because that was where my friends and I took our prom photos before we went to the actual location of prom in Midtown.  We took our photos right in front of the Heinrich Heine fountain.  It was interesting to actually learn about the history statue.  Without having gone on the tour, I would’ve just taken the fountain for granted, thinking “Oh, it’s just there.”  But now, when I visit my best friend and we walk past or through the park I can tell her what I know about the fountain :)

 

Prom2013
behind us is the fountain (I’m on the far left)

Practical Typography

Keeping in mind that our final project is to put together a website, I found this really neat online book by Matthew Butterick called ‘Practical Typography’. The book focuses on deciding what kind of type (font) to use for certain cases. I think it would be really cool to use some of his ideas and implement them to give our project a really nice, professional look. Here’s a link to his book: http://practicaltypography.com/

What do you guys think?

Reflecting on the Neighborhood Tour

Considering this was my first time visiting this section of the Bronx, everything seemed new and intriguing to me. I appreciated the art deco designs featured in the buildings, especially because I studied 1930’s art and architecture (in middle school, but I surprisingly still remember it). I realized that most of the architectural elements and designs of the buildings were mainly for aesthetics—rather than convenience.

Yet, what intrigued me the most was Mr. Goodman’s explanation of the premeditated “burning of the Bronx” during the 1970s. I did not want to believe that landlords deliberately burned their buildings because they profited more from the insurance money than tenants’ rents. 

I found this informative quote by Robert Worth:

 “… the Bronx began to burn in about 1970. Some of the fires were accidents, the inevitable result of decaying electrical systems. Many were set by landlords who would then collect the insurance money. Often they would sell the building–whether it was still inhabited or not–to “finishers” who would strip out the electrical wiring, plumbing fixtures, and anything else that could be sold for a profit before torching it. “Sometimes there’d be a note delivered telling you the place would burn that night,” one man who lived through the period told me. “Sometimes not.” People got used to sleeping with their shoes on, so that they could escape if the building began to burn.”           

It’s disheartening to hear individuals prioritize money over human lives. Imagine being one of the tenants who received a note that your home was going to be burned down. How would you react? What would you do first? Where would you go?

 Although it’s easy to label these landlords as greedy and heartless, I find it quite saddening that arson was a logical solution to some people. It came from a place of helplessness and desperation. It’s reflective of the social and political turmoil of the Bronx during the 1970s.

 To learn more about “why the Bronx burned,” read this article and visit this website!  

Macaulay Arts Night!

Hi everyone!

Every year, Macaulay hosts an Arts Night to showcase student talent. Do you have any talent? If so, consider submitting to Arts Night! 

Arts Night 2014_18_24

Artwork can either be dropped off at the Macaulay Building, or given to one of the campus curators. Please be sure to label it with your name, campus, and the works title. Sasha Whittaker and I are campus curators. 

Facts About Immigrants in NYC

Greetings everyone,

Here is a link with interesting statistical information on NYC ‘s immigrant population:

http://immigration.about.com/od/usimmigrationhistory/a/New-York-City-S-Immigrant-Population-Soars.htm

The article mentions the percentage of immigrants in many service jobs and the number of countries that NYC’s immigrants come from. The average income of immigrant families is also stated. The article does an amazing job at comparing different numbers and percentages over the last 4 decades (1970-2010). 

SHSAT Under Attack Again

Two weeks ago, John Boy posted a New York Times article where many critics scrutinized the admissions policy for New York City’s eight specialized high schools. In the upcoming fall school year, only seven blacks and 21 Hispanics have gained admittance to Stuyvesant High School. A recent article published by SILive once again highlights the low representation of blacks and Hispanics in another specialized high school, Staten Island Tech. 

Link for the article is here.

Just like Stuyvesant, SI Tech came under fire after the results of the admittance rates revealed that no black students will be part of the incoming freshman class this fall. The article, however, blames the entrance exam, even dubbing the SHSAT as ‘faulty.’ As an alumnus of SI Tech, I strongly disagree with the arguments presented in the article. I think that the admissions process should not be changed because the SHSAT does indeed give a fair playing field for all test-takers. Furthermore, unlike standardized exams like the SAT, the SHSAT is not meant to trick students; it is straightforward! It is neither discriminatory nor racially biased; it is merit-based. If admissions system is changed, then these schools will no longer be the ‘jewels in the crown of our public school system.’ If a student is unable to attain the score needed to get into these specialized high schools, the finger cannot be pointed at the test. There are plenty of factors that can determine how well a student performs on the SHSAT. Such examples include: Does the student have the motivation to study? Is the student learning the proper materials in school? Is the student receiving support from their families and teachers? Does the student have the confidence that they will do well? Etc. Others will argue that the reason some students are unable to do well is because they lack the economic resource to pay for test prep. This assumption is completely wrong. I never took test prep and I still managed to get into SI Tech. How? Through a lot of studying! I am aware that some people lack the motivation to study, but I believe that if a students wants it enough (like I did), they are able to get it.  

So what does everyone else think? Should the SHSAT stay or go? 

Microaggressions

Note from Connie: Re this article on microaggressions that appeared in the Times a few days ago, the writer raised the issue — are these comments mostly aggressive or are they mostly micro? The whole subject is provocative, and since you’re the demographic that’s the subject of the article, I’d be very interested in your thoughts. Do you think this is a real issue? A manufactured one? All thoughts appreciated, as always.

“New York’s Dream Act Dies”

Last week, the New York State Senate rejected the Dream Act, which would give financial aid to college students who are undocumented immigrants. What do you all think – is it good that the Dream Act was rejected? Or should it have gone through? (Is it worth our tax dollars?)

Personally, I really support giving undocumented immigrants a college education–especially to those who were brought to NY as infants. Moreover, as the article pointed out, having more people with college degrees benefits the state economy.

Check out the article here:

http://takingnote.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/03/18/new-yorks-dream-act-dies/?hp&rref=opinion

Who is the Artist in NYC?

I read this article a couple of weeks ago and it just occurred to me to relate it to NYC.

http://www.residentadvisor.net/feature.aspx?2021

 

The article is about a strange, exciting form of dance music that is emerging out of the isolated housing projects of Lisbon, Portugal. Although the music is definitely intriguing, it is the circumstances surrounding the creation of the music that makes it relevant to this class. 

If this were last semester, I would ask some question like; What art (in any form) is being produced in NYC at this moment? For this semester, however, I’ll ask a different question; Is there a certain neighborhood or group of people within New York that has a flourishing arts scene? If so, is the art these people are creating at all informed by their living circumstances in New York (their neighborhood) or their cultural background? 

-Will

Crisis in Crimea

Just a general question. How do we think the seemingly imminent violence in Russia and Ukraine will affect New York City? It seems that Russia has annexation in mind (in fact, Putin stated outright that annexation is his goal) so will we see a mass migration of people out of the Crimean area?

Personally, I think it is likely to happen. I cannot, however, guess how many will come to New York.

Seven Up!

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/reel-life-the-mesmerizing-saga-of-56-up-16-09-2013/

“Seven Up” is a british documentary first aired in 1964 that followed various seven year olds from different economic and social classes.   Intended to be a commentary on the Britain’s class system, the film revealed another interesting perspective;   how much where one comes from shapes their views on life.  The results were so fascinating that the filmmaker Michael Apted decided to continue the series, returning each seven years to check up on the lives of the children-turn-teenagers-turn-adults. 

So how does this apply to us?  This picture allows us to look at people’s lives over time and how they evolved, much in the way that we have been doing in this class.  While not scientific, the study here is comparable to those stories we have looked into.  When someone’s story is told, other people identify with it, or at least with some elements of it.  What made the film so compelling to such a wide range of audiences was everyone connected to it in some way.

I thought it would be both interesting and concise to look at the segment from CBS’s Sunday Morning that shows the longevity of the project and outside interviews on it.  It’s really curious and cute, take a look!

Immigration and education

Note from Connie: This article was brought to our attention by Tom Shachtman, who will be discussing the subject of immigrant businesses in our April 23 class.

Please take a look and weigh in re. what you think of the author’s argument. Do you agree? Disagree? And why. Even a short comment will be helpful.

We need more Asian American kids growing up to be artists, not doctors by Jennifer Lee, Guardian Cif, March 16, 2014.

Consider the article in association with the following famous quote, which I view as the first American statement of the real American immigrant dream, a three-generational one that is not wholly focused on material acquisition. It is from a John Adams letter to his wife Abigail in 1780:

I must study politics and war that my sons may have liberty to study mathematics and philosophy. My sons ought to study mathematics and philosophy, geography, natural history, naval architecture, navigation, commerce, and agriculture, in order to give their children a right to study painting, poetry, music, architecture, statuary, tapestry, and porcelain.

Reflection on the Tenement Museum Visi

            

            My visit to the Tenement Museum expanded my view of New York’s past. Prior to the visit, when I thought of life in New York’s tenements, I thought of the tenements themselves; the cramped living spaces, the lack of bathrooms and and the increased risk of disease. My thoughts of the people in those tenements didn’t extend far past “those poor people”. Seeing the inside of the tenements; the elaborate ceiling made by the original owner, the commentary from the woman who once lived there as a child, and the cabinet her father made that was different from all others, it showed me a level of intimacy about tenement life that I never really thought about before. When I thought of such large families having to share such a small space, I imagined it as being smelly and cramped. I never thought that living in such close proximity might also create the possibility of bringing them closer together. The stories I heard made me see tenement life more as a story and less as a set of statistics. I thought a getting a better experience of tenement life would depress me, but instead, it made me see tenement life as happier and even made me feel a bit more connected with people of the past. It showed me that even when life isn’t easy, there are still ways to make happy memories with one’s loved ones. I now wonder if people in the future will look back on my time period, seeing it as desolate, despondent and outdated, not fully realizing that for us, in spite of what statistics might indicate, we were still able to find happiness. 

The City College of New York circa 1942

In assignment three, I talk of photographs taken by my maternal great-grandfather, Bruce Mackinnon Iles, of my grandmother Gloria at The City College of New York in 1942. (My Lala was exactly our age at the time.) I went back home this weekend to spend time with my Lala and she was kind enough to give me some of those photographs. I figured you all might like to see her on the campus we go to everyday and realize that although many things have changed, others have remained the same. 

My grandmother is on the left of each photograph. Lala CCNY3Lala CCNY5Lala CCNY6

Ethnicity and the East Harlem fire

Note from Connie: As you can see in this article, the story of the East Harlem fire and the deaths that resulted braids together the stories of New Yorkers with far-flung roots — Mexican, Puerto Rican, Greek, Russian, Ecuadorean. Reading an article like this, you really get a vivid portrait, in tragic microcosm, of the melting pot that can be found in so many corners of the city, something that can be hidden behind closed doors and only becomes apparent when something like this happens.

Any thoughts on how an awareness of this ethnic mix will affect people’s reactions to the fire and its aftermath?