Author: danielkruglyak

Why this project made me hate where I live…

Starting this project, I knew exactly what to expect. I am not new to the neighborhood, I have been living here for practically my whole life. When I was younger my father used to tell me stories about how when they first came to America, the cops would come to Brighton Beach to harass the new immigrants. Luckily those days have stopped but Brighton Beach has not changed much from those times. The train still runs over head every few min, the streets are still filled with thick heavy accents, and the smell of pierogis still find their way to your nose no matter how far away you are.

In the winter, Brighton Beach has a very dark gloomy atmosphere. The streets are overcrowded with snow and the garbage cans are over flowing with garbage. All the stores start to look dirty and covered in white dust from the salt. As we walked the streets it looked like any other street lined with stores, a large amount of people running from store to store to do shopping. But there was one difference, the faces and bits of conversation that you pick up are all Russian. Just like mentioned in “Changing Face of Brighton Beach” the faces have started to change recently and it is evident in the new stores and restaurants being opened. I feel that soon Brennan may have to write a new article talking about what happened with “Little Odessa.”

In the summer, Brighton starts to change dramatically. It is filled with tourists that come to visit the beach. It is longer filled with just Russians but rapidly becomes a melting pot of different cultures. It is interesting to see that in the summer most of these “outsiders” don’t go to eat pizza but rather embrace Brighton Beach and often get pierogis. In the summer, most of the traffic shifts from the streets to the beach. The congestion on the boardwalk becomes so bad that I often prefer to use the streets to get where I’m going.

Upon doing research I was intrigued by the website Brightonbeach.com. It lists the history of Brighton beach and how it has changed. It also tells the story of how the community came to be and that was very interesting. As a shock as the story was to me, another source did quite the opposite. Neighborhoodscout.com did nothing but confirm what I already knew. The prices in our neighborhood are higher than average due to our location. We are located next to the beach and have multiple stores and modes of transportation within the community. This drives up the prices because of comfort.

What I did learn from this project is that I hate my neighborhood. I love everything about it except the people. Living here my whole life I have never seen a young person move in. It has been the same middle age couples that move in. The area is filled with tons of Russian grandmas that don’t know a word of English and get angry if you assume that they speak English. City-data.com just solidifies my argument by showing that there are roughly only 20% of the population under 25. Maybe I would be okay with the community being mostly of the older generation if the older generation wasn’t so rude. They come from a place that is notoriously cold and bitter and it shows in their personality.

When Diana and I were conducting an experiment to see where people came from, it hit me. The people on Brighton Beach are bitter and rude for absolutely no reason. The moment that made it happen for me was when I asked the first person where they came from and they pretended I didn’t exist. But that opened my eyes to a bigger picture. It has always been like this where I live. No one wants to be bothered by your existence because they aren’t content with their life. They came to America looking for fame and fortune but instead they live in apartments doing nothing all day being too lazy to learn English because there is no need when they are surrounded by Russians.

For this reason, as well as others, I realized that I don’t want to live in this area when I get older.  Although I have made many connections with people around the neighborhood and have all of my child hood memories here, I rather go somewhere else. Perhaps it is because I am Americanized and the idea of having to speak in Russian in order to do my shopping doesn’t interest me. Whether it be one reason or another, I know that I much rather leave this neighborhood than have to put up with the negative vibe that is tossed around, this includes inclusion as well.

For example, my best friend is Chinese. We have been friends for 8 years now and consider each other brothers. Because of his nationality, he isn’t welcome in my neighborhood. When we walk around my building or even around the boardwalk I get looks of disapproval. Looks that I shouldn’t see anymore but because of the fact that everyone that lives on Brighton is still stuck in their old ways, I still do. Another reason that I hate Brighton Beach is that there is always a constant battle of who looks the most luxurious. Who has the nicer car or the nicest fur or even who has the prettiest wife. Seeing it from the side it kind of pathetic that people who don’t even know each other compare their success based off each other. Overall Brighton is an unwelcoming, cold, bitter neighborhood and because of this project, I was able to take a look at the bigger picture and notice it for myself.

Daniel Kruglyak Field Note 2

The second trip I made was on March 19th. This time it was slightly warmer nearing 50 degrees and almost all the snow had melted. This time Anton, Diana and I were going to take a walk down the streets of Brighton Beach. The morning started with Diana and I meeting on the intersection of Ocean Ave and Brighton Beach Ave, the beginning of Brighton Beach. We had an idea to ask the people that we saw where they immigrated from and create a small test. Brighton was nicknamed “little Odessa” so we wanted to see if a large mass of the population was from Odessa. We thought that it would be a perfect day to ask people because it was a Sunday which meant no one was rushing to get anywhere. The first person I asked did not even hesitate to stop, they just kept walking and completely ignored me. Great start to the project. We continued walking further down into Brighton and asking people walking by where they came from. Some people, in better moods than others, wished us luck or even stopped and had small conversations with us. About an hour later Anton showed up and after a brief encounter he went to go take pictures of the stores and of the boardwalk. While asking people about their origin we also wrote down what types of stores we saw on Brighton, whether they were Russian or American chain stores or pharmacies, etc. One person we approached was a man selling books on the street. We asked him where he was from and immediately stuck a conversation with him, we spoke for roughly 30 min and he told us all about himself. Where he lived, what he used to work as, what his kids do, where his kids live and a bunch of interesting information about the books that he sells. Once we finished with him we decided to talk to the lady selling Pierogis. She also gave us some insight on her life and old us more about her customers and what the most popular item is. Then Diana and I both got a beladje, fried dough with meat inside. After a quick snack, we met up with Anton and updated each other on what we had each done. The experience had been much more exciting than when Lauren and I went because the stored where much more energetic. Everyone was doing their shopping for the week, it was nicer weather and a lot of the stores where playing music out onto the street. Reaching the end of Brighton, Diana and I decided to go to the boardwalk to walk home. We were shocked to see how many people where not only strolling on the boardwalk but also the vast amount of people walking on the sand, next to the water. We decided to get closer to the water so that we could hear the waves crashing into the rocks. I didn’t want to get sand in my sneakers so I took them off. The cold wet sand did not feel good on my feet at all. It was as if i was walking through the swamp. We approached the water and I let it cover my feet. Oh boy was that a mistake. the water felt like i had dunked my feet into a bucket of water. I decided to put my sneakers back on because the beach did not feel so good in the winter.  We finally walked all the way back home and as we were heading back to the boardwalk to get off we noticed a lady in a swimsuit getting onto the beach. We decided that we would wait a little longer and see what happens. The lady and her younger male friend started to get ready to go swimming. We watched as the man ran into the water and ran out. While he was drying off we asked him a few questions and he was more than happy to tell us about his life and why he swims. He also told us about the lady that was with him and that she swims every other day, no matter how cold it is. After talking to them we decided to call it a day and went home.

Daniel Kruglyak Field Note 1

Me and Lauren took a trip on March 10th. It was a cold Friday afternoon. Me and Lauren decided to go to Brighton Beach after class while there was still snow on the ground. Since we arrived around 4 o’clock there were not many little kids because they had all been picked up from school already. It was also to early to see the working population shopping because it was before 5. We started from the beginning of Brighton Beach, the intersection of Brighton Beach Ave and Ocean Parkway. The first stop we made was at a Georgian bakery because we were hungry. We looked around the bakery and saw different types of desserts as well as fresh bread, salads, and warm pastries. Me and Lauren both got khachapuri, a traditional Georgian cheese filled bread. While waiting for our food we spoke to the worker that was serving us. He didn’t speak any English and knew very little Russian but was able to tell us that he was happy to serve us and enjoyed seeing people try his food. He was also more than happy to allow us to take pictures of the food for our project. After eating we continued walking down Brighton Beach taking pictures of the streets, restaurants and different store fronts. It was interesting to see the amount of people trekking through ice and snow filled sidewalks despite the awkward time. Despite the fact that it was about 30 degrees that day; we were still able to see the ladies that usually sell pierogis on the streets. You can smell the pierogis from blocks away, especially whenever they would bring out the fresh ones. As we walked we noticed the types of structures that surrounded us. It was very easy to tell the difference between old building and new. The new ones where mostly glass and metal and more comforting than the old brick structures. About every 10 minutes we would hear the Q and the B train run over head. As we approached the end of Brighton I decided to stop at an old pharmacy that I used to work at. I spoke to a few of my old coworkers and tried to interview one of them. Sergey, the one that I tried to interview, came to America 25 years ago and has been working and living on Brighton Beach ever since. Sadly, he did not feel comfortable being interviewed and so we decided to roam the pharmacy a little. While roaming, we found many Russian products that would otherwise not be seen in different pharmacies. Once we left we continued to look around at the new changed that had come to Brighton Beach. My favorite pizzeria had been closed down and turned into a healthy juice bar. We made it all the way to Coney Island Ave and decided to take the bus home because we had gotten very cold. On the bus ride, we had a final look at the streets of Brighton Beach as we drove by them.

Interview With Swimmer

Diana: What was the first time you tried going into the cold water?

Swimmer: The first time was in a frigid winter so this isn’t so bad.

Diana: Where in Ukraine?

Swimmer: Yes, in Kiev, my boxing trainer introduced me to it. But overall the idea really came from the tradition from the villages when they would go to swim during their christening. During the event everyone would go in, not only old people but young as well. There is a very big fan base for swimming in the cold that goes from enthusiast to athletes

Diana: Do you like to swim in the summer?

Swimmer: Of course. I also really enjoy going to the pool as well. To me, sports are a “must have.” You can love it or hate it, it doesn’t matter but you have to have physical exercise. For example, take my friend that is swimming. A lot of the people her age will tell you about all the different pains that they are having from aging. For example, my boxing trainer, he is over 60 years old but there is no one willing to step into a ring with him, he is a very dangerous person.

Diana: When you walk around the streets do you dress warm?

Swimmer: Yes, I dress just like everyone else. You have to look after yourself.

Diana: Has there ever been a time where you have gotten sick from doing this?

Swimmer: No, never.

Diana: So you just always have to be careful with what you are doing?

Swimmer: Yes, the first rule to doing anything in the cold is to keep your feet dry. Even if you are barefoot it will be more beneficial to rub your feet than to shove your feet into a pair of damp socks or shoes. You can find these types of simple things out on something like “Discovery Channel.” For example, when I was drilling through the ice in Kiev and my foot fell through the ice, I went straight to the car to change my shoes. You don’t feel how bad it is but something this simple can result in a minimum of you getting sick and a maximum of an amputation.

Diana: Does it still feel cold to enter the water or not anymore? What is the feeling you get?

Swimmer: The feeling at first when you enter the water is that you don’t really feel anything but then once you get a little deeper, you start to feel rapid numbing of your body.

Diana: Is it scary?

Swimmer: If you don’t know what to do then it is scary but if you are ready then it’s nothing.

Diana: One more question, you don’t have to answer. How old are you?

Swimmer: I’m 28.

Daniel Kruglyak

Hi, I’m Daniel. I have lived on Brighton Beach since I have been born. My parents came here 23 years ago from Ukraine with nothing to their name. They were able to make the best of what they had and create a life that allows us to live comfortably.  Because they were immigrants they turned to Brighton Beach for comfort and familiar faces. The environment gave then a sense of comfort because they were not required to learn a new language and they could relate to almost everyone there. I still live on Brighton today. It is an amazing neighborhood that allows for comfort by providing everything needed within walking distance. The only annoying aspect is parking. Due to the fact that most of the neighborhood is composed of buildings, the congestion of cars is insane. I love my neighborhood and the connections that I have been able to make by living her but I don’t see myself staying here after graduation. As for my parents, I don’t see them ever leaving. The community is very comforting for them and because of work they rarely experience it so every time they go out, its something new. I rather move away to a quieter location that is a bit more suburban. Through this project I have opened my eyes to what my community holds and am happy to guide you through the experience of what it means to live in Brighton Beach.

© 2024 Brighton Beach Bro

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑