The side of New York depicted in Mean Streets is one of masculine hypocrisy. The film opens with its lead character asking God if it’s okay that he repents for his sins in his own way, and moves on to the crimes that this man commits with his friends. They are gruff and violent, insulting and punching each other as often as they can. They call each other “friends” while exchanging money for their gambling and deals for illegal items, but quickly break into a brawl because, after all, they aren’t really fond of each other. The song “Shakey Dog” depicts a similar taste for violence, as the rapper, Ghostface Killah,  and his friend plan to rob a group of drug dealers that trust Ghostface Killah. The saying is true – there is “no honor among thieves.” But, Mean Streets, being in its longer format, is able to depict a happier side of the story of these violent men, showing that there is a degree of camaraderie when they all relax in a bar together.

Both the film Mean Streets and the Ghostface Killah’s song Shakey Dog encapsulates New York as a harsh place with an abundance of illegal activity. Both medias contain gun violence as well as references to New York. This can be seen in Mean Streets through the shooting at the bar and the many shots of old New York as well as in Shakey Dog when the lyrics reference gun violence and 125th street separately. The mix of gun violence and relatable references to New York City helps develop a sense of sentimental criminality. They convey an element of organized illegal activity but do not preach against that activity. The people conducting the illegal activity are not painted as evil, but somewhat moral and relatable. This can be seen through the religious aspect and the humor prevalent in Mean Streets as well as the situational humor in Shakey Dog. This desensitization of violence and criminal activity could potentially reflect the rampant amount of criminality in both the New York depicted in Mean Streets and Shakey Dog.

Despite their similar tones and subject matter, Mean Streets and Shakey Dog have some distinct differences. The song Shakey Dog seems more narrative that the movie so far. The movie seems to have a loser plot that focuses on capturing the life of the characters rather than telling a story. This slow-paced narration is very different than the narration heard in Shakey Dog, as the song is extremely fast-paced and action-packed. That being said, in general, a film gives a slower and more detail and perhaps nuanced view of life while a song gives you the most important, action-packed moment that captures the life.

The slower pace of Mean Streets, along with the film genre itself, allows for a more detailed depiction of characters when compared to Shakey Dog, or the music genre in general. For example, Mean Streets is able to dissect Charlie’s struggle with balancing religion and criminality in a way that Shakey Dog cannot. This struggle is one that can be developed throughout the time span of a movie, while Shakey Dog only has three minutes to convey and necessary plot and character points. Mean Streets is able to depict character development in a way that Shakey Dog cannot.

Mean Streets introduces the viewer into a world of unattended crime in the of New York City, specifically in a small area in Little Italy. Johnny, one of the protagonists of the movie, is introduced as a crime seeking character by setting an explosive for reasons still unclear out on the street. In another scene, Johnny and his friends are shown taking advantage of teenagers looking to pay for drugs. Gambling is shown to be a big part of the crime that takes place in the movie as well as debt counts and friendship confrontations. The friendship aspect is what makes Mean Streets so compelling, in my opinion.

In one of the scenes in the movie, Johnny becomes involved in a fight with one of his friends. Charlie then comes in and reminds the two that they are all fiends. Friendship appears to be the one of the bonding forces between these group of men who actively participate in crime and at the make time look out for each other. In the movie, Charlie looks after Johnny and making sure he pays off his dept to Michael. Charlie pressures his friend into keeping up to date with his payments after seeing Johnny enter the bar with two women by his side and without a single trace of preoccupation on his face. Charlie, nonetheless, appears to have hidden motives for taking care of Jonny. Later on in the movie, Charlie is shown in a relationship with Johnny’s cousin and he promises her that very soon they will move out together.

One of the moral paradoxes in the movie is depicted in the scene in which Charlie goes to church for confession. He expresses his frustration with the religious system in handling the forgiveness of sin and points out that praying does not absolve him of his wrong doings. What adds on to the moral paradox in the movie is that Charlie knows what he is doing is wrong because he makes it clear that he goes to church every week, perhaps because of the remorse he feels for what he is doing in his neighborhood. As a result of his dissatisfaction with the way the church “absolves” him of his sins, Charlie goes on to create his own way of paying for the wrong he has done.

“You don’t make up for your sins in church; you do it in the streets; you do it at home. The rest is bulls–t, and you know it.”

What makes Mean Streets different from Ghostface Killah’s “Shakey Dog” different is the level of violence portrayed in each. In “Shakey Dog,” it is clear that people participate in face to face confrontations and that they are ready to either live or die if they have to. Such example is seen in the following lines from “Shakey Dog.” In Mean Streets, on the other hand, the pool fight scene takes place while an upbeat song is played in the background, which takes away seriousness behind the fight.

Frank shot the skinny dude, laid him out
The bigger dude popped Frankie boy, played him out

Mean Streets highlights the everyday lifestyle of an Italian mobster. The movie focuses in on the moral paradoxes of Charlie, the principal character. At the beginning of the movie, the audiences is made cognizant of Charlie’s conscience. He contemplates his life as a Catholic, inquiring other ways for atoning  his sins rather than praying “Ten Hail Mary’s, Ten Our Fathers, ten whatever.” Being forgiven on the basis of prayer doesn’t sit right with him. Instead, he desires to find his own method of atonement.

Mean Streets , like all mob movies, revolves its plot around money. In the beginning, the audience learns oh Johnny’s reckless nature regarding money, given that he spends money despite being in debt to a collection of mobsters. Johnny begins to feel obligated in helping Charlie, given that they are friends and is sleeping with his cousin. He is loyal towards Johnny, a trait that is deemed of the highest importance in such organizations.

“Shakey Dog” further highlights this drive for money seen in partners involved in organized crime. In his rap, Ghostface Killah unveils a specific incident where he tries to get money from his end of a drug deal. The song centers on the violent aspect of organized crime. In it he raps, “Told him Freeze! lay the fuck down and enjoy the moment, Frank snatched his gat, slapped him, asked him Where’s the cash, coke and the crack? Get to smokin’ you fast.” Eventually, the rap ends with Ghostface’s companion, Frank, shooting people with his gun. Frank himself is then taken out, leaving the rap on a bit of a cliffhanger.

Mean Streets portrays the world of organized crime in NYC. We are sucked into the world of these gangsters and it becomes apparent that money is a central theme in their life. Friends, enemies are decided based on money and the crimes committed are somehow related to money. It’s interesting though that this film does not romanticize nor condemn their lifestyle. It just takes us into their day to day life and shows it to us specifically through Charlie and following his life.

However, Ghostface Killah raps about a specific crime.  We get a glimpse into criminal life in NYC but in Harlem – a very different culture than in Mean Streets. Furthermore, the crime he raps about  seems quite dramatic and out of the ordinary whereas in Mean Streets their criminal lives are portrayed in a no  big deal kind of way.  This  is probably because in a short song it is impossible to comprehensively portray the crime scene in Harlem so Ghostface chose to rap about a specific event which taken out of context seems very intense. In conclusion, since Mean Steets is a film and “Shakey Dog” is a short rap , the realities perceived when watching/listening to them are very different though both relate to crime.

The film, Mean Streets, depicts the cutthroat lifestyle in which wealth is at the center, and artificial friendships are formed on the basis of giving and receiving money. We see the moral paradox most prominently within the character Charlie especially in the church scene. Apart from the fact he goes to clubs, gets tangled in fights and shootings, and isn’t dedicated to religion, his action of going to church may be a way for him to feel better about himself, and make up for his actions. Nevertheless, in the movie we are made aware that he recognizes the Catholic Church as a man-made organization, a business diverging not too far from organized crime, and capable of human fault.Charlie even mentions how he says prayers but the words have no meaning to him. Thus, we can see his attitude towards church is not spiritual but more ironic.The compelling nature of the movie is the thrill and rush, it seems as if the characters live in a world where every next moment is either a fight, adventure, or opportunity. Time doesn’t slow down and the characters move along without looking back.

Within Ghostface Killah’s song “Shakey Dog”. the rhythm and the tune of the music matches the environment of a neighborhood with mystery, crime, and danger. The language used represents a carefree attitude and one that is not looking to respect anyone.The song starts to reach a climactic scene within the house and when the shooting goes off leaving the listeners with an intense feeling. The lyrics have no filter and portray the deep and grimy undertakings of the gang lifestyle. This song connects to Mean Streets as they both represent a life of danger and crime, and most especially how people are out for one another. There is no friendship in the lyrics, nor is there someone to lean back on, as showed in the movie Mean Streets between Charlie and Johnny Boy. Charlie looks out for Johnny and even mentions to Teresa that one of the reasons why he’s staying back is to help his friend out.Thus, the song is a more brutal portrayal of what it is like to be a part of a gang, as opposed to the movie that shows there is loyalty and respect among the members.

The concepts portrayed in both the Mean Streets and Ghostface’s songs highlight lives lived through organized crime. One has an hour and a half to portray the complexities of “mafian life” while the other is limited by three minutes to only display the negatives of the gangster living. In Mean Streets, the movie followed the life of a morally and spiritually young mobster named Charlie who’s future was more than uncertain. The film did capture the essence of the “mafian life” but it softened the harshness of its reality. In one of the bar fight scenes, the director decided to play a rather up beat song, as if to distract the audience from how violent that way of life truly is.

The film also threw a comedic perspective into every element of the mafias. With the obsession over money, loyalty and power, the movie deliberately failed to display the blunt truth. When Charlie was asked for the money he had owed, he nonchalantly failed to give a care and slyly removed himself from that position, even able to persuade the men to have drinks with him afterwards.

Ghostface in his song, Method Man states,

You know the gun show off, whips is gleaming, clean as a fuck
In dirty hallways, the ninas’ll cluck
This is crime station, my obligation is to look raw as ever
Feed my little sons and patients
Cause they hungry, shining, bullet fly right through the lining
Catch me on the plane, humble and wining

Here, there isn’t any romanticization. Here, you have what Mean Streets failed to deliver, the exact truth. Without blurring lines, Ghostface paints the harsh realities of living in this style. He describes violence, death, drugs and sex as it plays in daily life.

Both Martin Scorsese’s  Mean Streets and Ghostface Killah’s “Shakey Dog” provide images of the lives of members involved in organize crime. They have some similarities and some differences. Mean Streets gives a broad view of mafia life, while “Shakey Dog” describes a more specific incident, an armed robbery by the gang.

Both the mafia in Mean Streets and the gang in “Shakey Dog” exhibit extreme loyalty to each other. In Mean Streets, Charlie is very loyal to his family, collecting money for his uncle, and even his girlfriend’s family, protecting her cousin and his friend Johnny. In “Shakey Dog”, Ghostface Killah describes the teamwork of the robbery and how him and Frank worked together.

Another similarity between the mafia and the gang are their usages of violence to get what they want. In Mean Streets, many of Charlie’s collections turn violent, sometimes containing gunshots. In “Shakey Dog” there is also a lot of violence and gunshots, especially done by Frank, who “put two holes in the doorman’s Sassoon” and “show the skinny dude.”

The movie and song diverge in their characterizations of the mafia members and gang members. Scorsese provides a fuller image of the mafia members, showing how they are violent and flawed, but also have consciences, especially Charlie. Charlie is very conflicted about his lifestyle because he is religious and wants to atone for his sins, but does not want to change his actions. He tries to make up for his sins a little bit by protecting Johnny, but is still restless. On the otherhand, Ghostface Killah does not make any attempt to redeem the violent robbers in the eyes of the listeners. He even seems proud of their ruthlessness. This may be due to the nature of a movie, versus the nature a song, since a movie is significantly longer than a song. It may also be due to the artists’ purposes. Scorsese intends to give a holistic view of the mafia, showing the good and bad parts of it; Ghostface Killah, intends to show one incident and maybe even intimidate others so they know to watch out for him and his friends.

Mean Streets portrayed world of obligations and fluctuating moral beliefs . The characters all have obligations whether it was owing money, taking care of a relative, to your beliefs, or to avenging the honor of a person. Money is a theme that is apparent throughout the film (or at least the first half we watched) where money was owed to loaners, was used for scam, was used as bribery, and it was used as a mediator between parties despite the fighting. Charlie, the main protagonist, has made it his duty to watch over Johnny whom is carefree and negligent and neck deep in debt from borrowing from a lot of loaners.

At the start of the movie, Charlie feels that going to confession does not guarantee pardon from his wrongdoings and thus sets out with the belief that the matter is solely in his hands and actions in the real world, thus his relation to Johnny. However we find out that he most likely does this to be with Johnny’s sister whom he has a relationship with. Including this instance, other moral paradoxes are portrayed by the characters such as the bar owner kicking out a man for injecting substances in his bathroom  which he views as unsightly yet he keeps caged lions hidden in the back from dubious sources without a license to keep them. How Charlie wants to be with Teresa but outrightly declares he doesn’t love her despite spending time with her. These contradicting morals makes it interesting that it makes you want to see what he will choose to follow and where that will bring him and add to the growing turmoil in the story.

Ghostface Killah’s Shakey Dog portrays a much more frank and harsh reality through the recounting of a robbery for drugs and money. In Mean Streets,  the characters Charlie with his connection to his uncle, and the loaners like Michael mostly evoke respect and a code of loyalty from other characters. In Shakey Dog, Ghost and Frank presence evoke fear in the streets to the point that they aren’t concerned about anyone witnessing their robbery. The song then narrates what goes on in a robbery to the last detail from getting out their guns, making the plans, and what goes down in a robbery which doesn’t go as smoothly as planned. Their is no regard to the lives of the people they are robbing from and each other’s since Ghost talked about Frank taking the blame if they get caught. We get straight to the action in the song, we aren’t made to get to know the characters like we do in Mean Streets. It’s the story laid out bare to the listeners with no intention of softening the blow, leaving little to consider of the actions they took and the consequences it brought about.

The world portrayed in Martin Scorsese’s movie “Mean Streets” and Ghostface Killah’s song titled “Shakey Dog,” are both similar and different. They both expose a world of organized crime where innocent citizens will turn a blind eye to the crimes and antics of both groups. “Mean Streets” depicts the Italian-American mob in New York City, specifically Little Italy, while on the opposite end of the city, way uptown, we have Ghostface Killah describing a robbery in great detail with his gang “Theodore,” which was a loose collective of rappers centered around Ghostface.

With “Mean Streets,” the viewer gets a broader look at what mob life was like in general, following Charlie. We see him go to the Catholic church, go to strip clubs, get caught in many shootings, have an affair, and meet with “The Boss.” This kind of view is something only a film would provide, allowing a maximum glimpse into the characters life. Unlike a song, a film has the time to make a compelling piece on mafia life in New York City, leaving the audience wanting and wondering for more.

With Ghostface Killah’s song, “Shakey Dog,” the listener is given a detailed heavy and gritty take on one specific aspect of gang life. We listen to Ghostface rap specifically about a robbery and he describes each detail painstakingly so, the listener can’t help but cringe at his abrasiveness. Ghostface only has three minutes and forty-four seconds to give an accurate portrayal of gang life and he accurately does that by retelling a gritty tale of a robbery.

Despite two gruesome takes on organized crime, mafia and gang. Mafia movies are still extremely appealing and compelling to viewers, yet songs like “Shakey Dog” are too harsh and gritty. This is primarily because the mafia is romanticized in film. We watch Charlie not only commit bad acts but also try to repent his sins and have a forbidden affair with a woman he’s not supposed to love. While all we get with a song like Ghostface’s is straight up real and gritty facts that leave no room for any wandering romantic imagination.