Hurricane Sandy and the effect on Manhattan’s Chinatown

Hurricane Sandy: Chinatown Black Market Emerges as Vendors Hawk Batteries, Candles,  Outlets from the Huffington Post (includes a small photo album)

I’m not terribly surprised that after Sandy, black markets emerged. When people are without things that they believe to be necessities, especially in this day and age of technology, they are generally willing to pay any price to gain access to their phones and not to have to sit in the dark. There was a quote from a bakery owner that said “Whatever you can do to stay open, you do it” which I think really sums up what the people who opened up the bodegas and makeshift street stands to sell batteries, flashlights, and other essentials, for way over-price.

Hurricane Sandy Alert: Lower Manhattan Chinatown Needs Volunteers to Help from 8asians

8asians is a blog dedicated to writing about Asian American issues, and during Sandy it sent out a help-wanted alert during Sandy. The Asian American Writers’ Workshop originally sent out the statement, however it is blogs like 8asians who have dedicated followers in the communities that needed help that can get the word out to many more people.

Residents Could be Without Power for Days in Hurricane Sandy Aftermath from OurChinatown (Con-Edison Power Outtage Map)

Several Videos From Youtube

From WSJDigitalNetwork 30 Oct 2012: Shows the LES after Sandy as well as storefront awnings and sides in Chinatown.

From Joel Silver 30 Oct 2012: Shows a brief look at Chinatown after Sandy, the stores were closed and the streets were very empty for Chinatown.

From videonation 1 Nov 2012: Shows footage of Chinatown after Sandy as well as interviews with CAAAV staff members and volunteers.

From meniscuszine 2 Nov 2012: Shows how the stores were closed, the lights out, and how people were lining up to get their phone’s charged and gather supplies from the CAAAV, which took donations.

From Jan Lee 12 Nov 2012: Shows volunteers from Chinatown Community Young Lions helped out at Hamilton Madison House which had been turned into a commissary, warming centre, supply distribution centre, and an information clearing house.

Hurricane Sandy and Avenue U

Avenue U Chinatown while only 10 blocks long goes through both Homecrest and Sheepshead Bay. While Homecrest was not badly affected by Hurricane Sandy, Sheepshead Bay suffered critical damage. Sheepshead Bay really had as much damage as Staten Island and the Rockaways and yet relief took even longer to reach Sheepshead than the other two . Not only did Sheepshead Bay experience extreme damage, but it along with a large part of South Brooklyn was looted:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/31/hurricane-sandy-looting-brooklyn-coney-island_n_2047183.html#slide=1704488

Here is an account of a Sheepshead Bay resident when Sandy first hit:

“At 7:46, the water started coming in,” said Shannon White, 27, standing outside his destroyed house on Stanton Road. “At 8:10, I got out. The water was neck-deep.” He swam to safety with his dog on his shoulders — and then came back. “I got a canoe that washed up on Nostrand Avenue,” he said. “We were oarin’ with two pieces of wood like this,” he said, pointing to a broken fence. “We helped two old couples and a couple kids. I grew up here. This is all like family.”

http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2012/11/sheepshead-bay-no-homes-no-power-no-relief.html

Here are some images of the damage in Sheepshead Bay area:

Finally here is a video of the aftermath of Sandy on Sheepshead Bay:

Emma Park-Hazel

 

Aftermath of Sandy: Chinatown

From asking people to doing research, I have learned that during Hurricane Sandy, the Manhattan branch of Chinatown was left completely in the dark.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/31/hurricane-sandy-chinatown-black-market_n_2050754.html#slide=1708158

This article explains the way the residents of Chinatown dealt with the black skies and black buildings.  Businesses who had power or batteries and other necessities increased their prices greatly in order to stay in open.

This video shows a woman’s perspective of the aftermath of Sandy in Chinatown.   People came to volunteer and help out Chinatown during this time of need, when businesses and houses were in the dark.

Hurricane Sandy Aftermath

Archival Research: Avenue U-Homecrest

Though this article and video are obviously fairly general in regards to emergency coverage in Brooklyn, the fact that Hurricane Sandy coverage was sub-par or lacking completely in southern Brooklyn (in comparison to Manhattan) is both disturbing and telling of the issues that could have affected Avenue U. Naturally, further research is crucial to establish a better picture of the problems specifically faced by the Sheepshead Bay, and consequently Homecrest area; however a most compelling line is: the “media should have been on the scene in these neighborhoods immediately after the storm…in order to convey the most important and useful information for victims and those looking to help.”

http://www.sheepsheadbites.com/2012/11/video-pulitzer-prize-winner-says-medias-hurricane-sandy-coverage-failed-brooklyn-queens/

This short video from YouTube shows Avenue U conditions during Hurricane Sandy.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X-mzNTRYtRI

While pictures of Coney Island devastation are many, specifically Avenue U damage is not as readily available; nevertheless the impact of the natural disaster is astounding:

http://www.brooklynvegan.com/archives/2012/10/coney_island_hu.html

 

(More to be added as needed.)

Archival Data for Homecrest, Brooklyn after Hurricane Sandy

Homecrest, Brooklyn wasn’t hit as hard by Hurricane Sandy as some of the areas around it. Homecrest’s border closest to the water coincided with where the flood waters stopped. As you traveled from this Avenue X border towards the Emmons Avenue Canal, which caused most of the flooding in the area, the waters got higher and higher.

The following video shows the water from the Emmons Avenue Canal beginning to rise. This footage was shot before Sandy hit land. The water continued to rise after this point.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWGNuXum4PI

MHC 150 Archival Data Map

 Power outages in Homecrest were minimal, according to my friends who live in different parts of the neighborhood, and considering that no reports indicated otherwise. Power was lost for only several hours, and stop lights on the Ocean Parkway/Avenue U intersection were not working properly. The following is a post that appeared on a liveblog on www.brooklynpaper.com on October 30th, 2012, after Sandy had done most of its damage.

5:26 pm: Traffic lights across Southern Brooklyn are on the fritz. Things are particularly dicey at the intersection of Ocean Parkway and Avenue U where stoplights not operating. Drivers heading across town should avoid Avenue U, and take Avenue T instead.

There are multiple trees down on Van Sicklen Street, at Gravesend Neck Road and between Avenues U and T.”

That pretty much covers how much damage Homecrest sustained.

No big looting incidents were reported in Homecrest. The biggest looting that was covered happened in Coney Island after Sandy, where people actually carried LCD televisions out of a Rent-A-Center in broad daylight, and thousands of dollars of liquor was stolen off shelves in late morning of October 30th, 2012.

http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/brooklyn/looters-target-coney-island-sandy-article-1.1195080

 

Additional sources used:

www.maps.google.com

http://www.brooklynpaper.com/stories/35/44/all_hurricanesandyliveblogday2_2012_11_02_bk.html

Impact of Sandy in Chinatown

Lower Manhattan, Chinatown being part of it, was one of the most hit parts of NYC by Hurricane Sandy in early Fall 2012. This neighborhood is still recovering from the effect of this disastrous storm, as some of its effects are still visible today. The media played an important role in giving an idea of the proportions of this disaster by portraying the during and the aftermath, also thanks to amateur photographers and filmers who documented what was happening.

Following a few resources about the effects of Sandy in Chinatown.

NY Times video about the effects of Sandy in Lower Manhattan: http://www.nytimes.com/video/2012/10/30/nyregion/100000001875311/lower-manhattan-after-the-storm.html

NY Times article about the impact of Sandy on downtown restaurants: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/07/dining/reviews/restaurant-review-after-hurricane-sandy-downtown-restaurants-need-patrons.html?_r=0

Wikipedia article on the effects of Hurricane Sandy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_Hurricane_Sandy_in_New_York

Website on Chinatown in general: http://www.explorechinatown.com/
Photograph of the black out caused by Sandy in Lower Manhattan

The black-out in Lower Manhattan caused by Sandy

Hurricane Sandy Aftermath: Homecrest

At least a part of the Homecrest area of Brooklyn was seriously affected by Hurricane Sandy, and one can see that is true just from looking at the Avenue U N train station photograph from the disaster:Source:http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2225164/Hurricane-Sandy-batters-New-York-Citys-subway-tunnels-flooded-network-shuts-down.html

Sandy Impact MapScreen Shot 2013-03-06 at 7.26.33 PM
Source: http://prattcenter.net/map/toward-informed-rebuilding-documenting-sandys-impacts

According to this map, the main Homecrest area was not flooded by Hurricane Sandy, but water came up really close to it. Maybe the map labeling of neighborhoods is not entirely accurate since Avenue U passes through the center of Homecrest and it was obviously flooded at least partially, according to photographic evidence like the train station picture above.

Since there is not much information regarding flooding of the Homecrest neighborhood, overall the conditions were probably not as bad as in some other, more coastal places.
Some primary sources reported power outages. (More information to follow.)

Archival Research-Chinatown

Here are a few videos about the effects of Sandy on Chinatown:

Chinatown while recovering from Sandy, gets ready for Election Day: http://vimeo.com/52902492
This video includes segments that show how there was little help in clearing fallen trees in Chinatown. It also shows how some businesses were affected by the storm and power outages.

One Dolla, Chinatown by Jane Teeling:
http://vimeo.com/52664895
This video shows a one-dollar store that opened up after the hurricane. It shows how not everyone took advantage of the situation to raise prices and to make money off the devastation.

Here are sites that show the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy on Chinatown:

http://www.ourchinatown.org/2012/11/29/post-sandy-chinatown-updates-and-links/
This is a collection of posts from the Asian American Writer’s Workshop’s Open City Magazine, which covered the effect of the storm from day one.

http://voicesofny.org/2012/11/chinatown-business-owners-blast-government-over-lack-of-support/
This article assesses the damage the hurricane inflicted on the businesses in Chinatown and whether or not the customers will return.

This is a compelling image of the blackout that occurred in lower Manhattan as a result of the storm.
(http://www.chinatownpartnership.org/newsletter/2012%2011%2007%20Hurricane%20Sandy%20-%20Chinatown%20Update.htm)

The Day After in Lower Brooklyn/ Coney Island

Looting became a problem in the following days and many threatened shop owners created signs warning off potential thieves.

—   This video was taken by a resident and not professionally edited but it tours right through the center of Coney Island and shows the situation just hours after the storm.

–The first video includes interviews of local residents and was done by the New York Post.

url-1

1351696652_4512_Coney Island NY Sandy

Chinatown Archival

The following is a personal account of what happened on Hester Street Day 4 after Hurricane Sandy hit. Lines were forming for food and necessities while community organizations were handing them out for two days before FEMA showed up to offer aid.

http://opencitymag.com/after-hurricane-sandy-day-4-hester-street-in-lower-manhattan/#.UJRgEGl25-I

This link shows a personal account of a Sukjong Hong, who went into a building to help those in need of getting necessities after the hurricane. There are drawn pictures documenting what happened instead of real pictures.

http://opencitymag.com/left-in-the-dark/

The following are pictures of the volunteers and the effort to help the people in Chinatown, who were left without electricity.

http://opencitymag.com/hurricane-sandy-day-4-lower-east-side-and-chinatown/

The following newsletter contains information about subway lines, important information about food (whether it is safe to drink or not), contact information, financial assistance, school information and so on.

http://www.chinatownpartnership.org/newsletter/2012%2011%2007%20Hurricane%20Sandy%20-%20Chinatown%20Update.htm

Archival Research: Sandy Impact on Chinatown

The following are links (including news articles and blog posts) recounting the conditions of Chinatown after Hurricane Sandy:

Who Stayed Open When Sandy Shut Down Lower Manhattan? — http://newsfeed.time.com/2012/10/29/southside-sandy/

Hurricane Sandy: Chinatown Black Market Emerges as Vendors Hawk Batteries, Candles, Outlets —http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/31/hurricane-sandy-chinatown-black-market_n_2050754.html#slide=1708150

Chinatown Post-Sandy by Ellen Jovin — http://ellenjovin.com/blog/entry/chinatown_post_sandy

This article form “The Epoch Times” provides telltale photographs with detailed captions of the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy on various areas, a wine and liquor store near Chinatown being one of many — http://www.theepochtimes.com/n2/united-states/hurricane-sandy-live-updates-new-york-city-308115.html

The following article traces and discusses the impact of Hurricane Sandy on the lives of immigrant workers in Chinatown — http://opencitymag.com/hurricane-sandy-impact-on-immigrant-workers/

Though this is unrelated to the lives of humans that were affected in Chinatown, during my research, I came across this article and thought it was a very interesting inquiry to raise in regard to the environmental effects of Hurricane Sandy. The article discusses the impact that the storm had on New York City’s rat population in different areas, one of which was Chinatown — http://nj1015.com/what-impact-did-sandy-have-on-nycs-rat-population/

The following videos show authentic footage of the aftermath of Sandy in Chinatown:

“Hurricane Sandy Aftermath; Chinatown; November 2, 2012” – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lO5nm1I4XIY

“Weathering Superstorm Sandy in Chinatown” – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5msfFKRKD7I

Archival Research

Article/Video: Chinatown Business Grants Try To Get Neighborhood Past Sandy Slump http://manhattan.ny1.com/content/top_stories/177049/chinatown-business-grants-try-to-get-neighborhood-past-sandy-slump

 

Line outside of one of the CAAAV, a organization that assists and offers help to Asian Americans, office.

VIdeo: Weathering Super Storm Sandy in ChinatownPeople coming to the aid of Chinese Americans in Chinatown and detailing how the demographics played a role in the timing of aid.

The CAAAV organization handing out non perishable items following Hurricane Sandy.

Video: Chinatown relatively deserted following Hurricane Sandy

Photo documenting the damage from the corner of Allen Street and Canal Street following Hurricane Sandy.

Demographics of Chinatown regarding median Household Income, single males, single females, median age, homes with kids and average household size in relation with New York and on a national level.

http://www.zillow.com/local-info/NY-New-York/Chinatown-people/r_193821/

Wooden debris on Pike Street, Chinatown.

A business left in the dark following Hurricane Sandy.

Chinatown residents wait in line for National Guard aid distribution in front of Confucius Plaza. (Photo by: Chinatown BID / CPLDC)

 

Chinatown BID assists with aid distribution in Chinatown. (Photo by: Chinatown BID)

Article regarding the state of businesses following Hurricane Sandy: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/07/dining/reviews/restaurant-review-after-hurricane-sandy-downtown-restaurants-need-patrons.html?_r=0&pagewanted=print

 

Archival Research – Chinatown and Hurricane Sandy

This is a site with many pictures of Chinatown in general:

http://www.nychinatown.org/manhattan.html

Video tour of Chinatown:

Article about some of the aftermath of Sandy and the recovery (with images):

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/31/hurricane-sandy-chinatown-black-market_n_2050754.html

Info on recovery and volunteering after Sandy in Chinatown:

http://www.ourchinatown.org/2012/11/06/hurricane-sandy-volunteering-and-donations-update/

Videos on the aftermath of Sandy in Chinatown and the Lower East Side:

Manhattan Chinatown – Archival (2)

The links below are daily updates on the post-Sandy situation.  Perhaps we can use the details included in these entries to focus our questions for interviews.  The entries also have lots of photos!

http://caaav.org/update-on-caaavs-efforts-post-hurricane-sandy-volunteer-and-donate
http://caaav.org/day-2-hurricane-sandy-relief-efforts-from-caaav
http://caaav.org/day-3-500-volunteers-and-the-lights-are-on
http://caaav.org/day-4-re-allocating-resources-to-far-rockaway-red-hook-and-staten-island
http://caaav.org/november-4th-hurricane-sandy-update

Chinatown Hurricane Sandy

These are some pictures of the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy in Chinatown.

Chinatown Residents Waiting on Line for Supplies Photo by: opencitymag.com

Chinatown Residents Waiting on Line for Supplies
Photo by: opencitymag.com

Fallen Tree in Chinatown Photo: Lori Zimmer

Fallen Tree in Chinatown
Photo: Lori Zimmer

Here are some videos about the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy on Chinatown. Many stores were closed, electricity was shut down, and city officials were not attending to Chinatown’s needs.

 

 

Manhattan Chinatown – Archival

1) http://caaav.org/caaav-endorses-joint-statement-on-federal-grants-for-sandy-relief

CAAAV works towards organizing Asian communities, particularly immigrants and low income families.  CAAAV seems to be active in enabling others, and its site hosts extensive Sandy documentation.  This article draws attention to the ongoing Sandy relief efforts of the CAAAV.  It reiterates the relevance of the storm even today, further validating the credibility of our project.

2) http://www.thelodownny.com/leslog/2012/12/45000-raised-for-post-sandy-chinatown-small-business-grant-program.html

This excerpt focuses on the $45,000 collected for the Chinatown Sandy Fund.  It is interesting to note that such relief efforts are given so much attention, considering the fact that city officials were seemingly absent in Chinatown during the actual disaster (as elucidated in the CAAAV video posted earlier.)

3) http://live.nydailynews.com/Event/Tracking_Hurricane_Sandy_2?Page=2

A new side of the story to perhaps include –  Chinatown was also home to Hurricane Sandy shelters.  Reaching out to volunteers could provide us with a neutral perspective on the situation and orient our project (understand how people came into shelters, what they did during their time there, and how they left these shelters).

Seward Park HS turned shelter for the Hurricane Sandy at 350 Grand St. in Chinatown. Mayor Michael Bloomberg held a press conference to update New Yorkers on preparations for Hurricane Sandy from one of the City's 76 Evacuation Shelters. (Mariela Lombard/for New York Daily News)

Seward Park High School in Chinatown served as a shelter for the Hurricane Sandy. 
(Mariela Lombard/for New York Daily News)

4) http://www.ourchinatown.org/2012/10/30/residents-could-be-without-power-for-days-in-hurricane-sandy-aftermath/

These are excellent co-references to the testimonies given in the CAAAV video that Lindsay posted.  The article acknowledges the power outages in Chinatown and other parts of the Lower East Side, and even cites includes Confucius Plaza (the last site we visited on our tour!) as one of the places experiencing water and power problems.  The Con Edison Power Outage Map provides a nice visual of the power outages during Sandy, and shows that Chinatown (center) was hard hit.  Maybe we could do a nice ‘Ken Burns’ of this map!

Con Edison – Hurricane Sandy Power Outage Map